6.5 Control surfaces

Control surfaces are vital components that allow pilots to maneuver aircraft. These movable parts, like ailerons, elevators, and rudders, alter airflow to control pitch, roll, and yaw. Understanding their design and function is crucial for aspiring aeronautical engineers and pilots.

This topic delves into the types, functions, and aerodynamic principles of control surfaces. It covers design considerations, actuation systems, and integration with flight controls. The notes also explore how control surfaces impact aircraft performance and the importance of proper maintenance and inspection.

Types of control surfaces

• Control surfaces are movable aerodynamic devices attached to an aircraft's wings, tail, or fuselage
• Used to control the aircraft's attitude, direction, and speed by altering the airflow around the surfaces
• Different types of control surfaces are designed to perform specific functions and are located at various positions on the aircraft

Ailerons

Top images from around the web for Ailerons

• 

  Introduction to aircraft components - Wikiversity View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 8. Accelerated Performance: Turns – Aerodynamics and Aircraft Performance, 3rd edition View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Introduction to aircraft components - Wikiversity View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 8. Accelerated Performance: Turns – Aerodynamics and Aircraft Performance, 3rd edition View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Ailerons

• 

  Introduction to aircraft components - Wikiversity View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 8. Accelerated Performance: Turns – Aerodynamics and Aircraft Performance, 3rd edition View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Introduction to aircraft components - Wikiversity View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 8. Accelerated Performance: Turns – Aerodynamics and Aircraft Performance, 3rd edition View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• Movable surfaces attached to the trailing edge of the wings near the wingtips
• Used to control the aircraft's roll by generating differential lift between the left and right wings
• When one aileron is raised, the other is lowered, causing the aircraft to roll towards the side with the raised aileron (banking)

Elevators

• Hinged surfaces located on the horizontal stabilizer of the aircraft's tail
• Control the aircraft's pitch by changing the angle of attack of the horizontal stabilizer
• When the elevators are raised, the tail is pushed down, causing the nose to pitch up, and vice versa

Rudders

• Hinged surface attached to the vertical stabilizer of the aircraft's tail
• Controls the aircraft's yaw by generating a sideways force on the tail
• When the rudder is deflected to one side, the tail is pushed in the opposite direction, causing the nose to yaw towards the direction of the deflected rudder

Flaps

• Movable surfaces attached to the trailing edge of the wings, inboard of the ailerons
• Increase the wing's lift coefficient by increasing the camber and surface area of the wing
• Deployed during takeoff and landing to reduce the required runway length and improve low-speed handling (Fowler flaps, slotted flaps)

Slats

• Movable surfaces attached to the leading edge of the wings
• Increase the wing's lift coefficient by delaying flow separation at high angles of attack
• Deployed during takeoff and landing to improve low-speed handling and stall characteristics (Krueger flaps, automatic slats)

Spoilers

• Plates or panels mounted on the upper surface of the wings
• Disrupt the airflow over the wing, reducing lift and increasing drag
• Used for roll control (in conjunction with ailerons), speed brakes, and lift dumping during landing (ground spoilers)

Functions of control surfaces

• Control surfaces are essential for maintaining and changing an aircraft's attitude, direction, and speed
• Different control surfaces are designed to perform specific functions, allowing pilots to control the aircraft in three axes: pitch, roll, and yaw

Pitch control

• Elevators are the primary control surfaces for pitch control
• By changing the angle of attack of the horizontal stabilizer, elevators alter the aircraft's pitch attitude
• Pitching up (nose up) increases the angle of attack, generating more lift, while pitching down (nose down) decreases the angle of attack, reducing lift

Roll control

• Ailerons are the primary control surfaces for roll control
• Differential deflection of ailerons creates a rolling moment, causing the aircraft to bank towards the side with the raised aileron
• Spoilers can also be used for roll control, assisting the ailerons by disrupting the airflow over the wing on one side

Yaw control

• Rudder is the primary control surface for yaw control
• Deflecting the rudder to one side generates a sideways force on the tail, pushing the tail in the opposite direction and causing the nose to yaw towards the direction of the deflected rudder
• Yaw control is essential for coordinated turns and counteracting adverse yaw during roll maneuvers

Lift augmentation

• Flaps and slats are used to increase the wing's lift coefficient during takeoff and landing
• Flaps increase the camber and surface area of the wing, while slats delay flow separation at high angles of attack
• Lift augmentation allows aircraft to operate at lower speeds, reducing the required runway length and improving low-speed handling

Drag reduction

• Spoilers can be used as speed brakes to increase drag and reduce the aircraft's speed
• Deploying spoilers disrupts the airflow over the wing, reducing lift and increasing drag
• Speed brakes are useful for descending, slowing down, and maintaining a desired approach speed

Aerodynamic principles of control surfaces

• The effectiveness of control surfaces depends on various aerodynamic principles that govern the interaction between the surfaces and the airflow
• Understanding these principles is crucial for designing and operating control surfaces efficiently

Bernoulli's principle

• States that an increase in the speed of a fluid occurs simultaneously with a decrease in static pressure or a decrease in the fluid's potential energy
• As air flows over a control surface, the pressure on one side decreases, creating a pressure difference that generates a force on the surface (lift or side force)
• The shape and angle of the control surface determine the magnitude and direction of the force

Angle of attack

• The angle between the chord line of a control surface (or wing) and the oncoming airflow
• Increasing the angle of attack generally increases the lift generated by the surface, up to a certain point (critical angle of attack)
• Control surfaces are designed to operate effectively at various angles of attack, depending on their function and location on the aircraft

Boundary layer

• The thin layer of air near the surface of a control surface (or wing) where the airflow velocity gradients are significant
• The boundary layer can be laminar (smooth and organized) or turbulent (chaotic and mixing)
• Control surfaces are designed to maintain a mostly attached boundary layer for optimal performance, as a separated boundary layer leads to reduced effectiveness

Flow separation

• Occurs when the boundary layer detaches from the surface of a control surface (or wing) due to adverse pressure gradients
• Flow separation results in a loss of lift, increased drag, and reduced control surface effectiveness
• Control surfaces are designed to minimize flow separation through proper shaping, smoothness, and placement

Stall characteristics

• A stall occurs when the critical angle of attack is exceeded, leading to a sudden decrease in lift and increase in drag
• Control surfaces can be affected by stall, losing their effectiveness and leading to reduced controllability
• Slats and flaps are used to delay the onset of stall and improve the stall characteristics of the wing, allowing the aircraft to maintain control at higher angles of attack

Design considerations for control surfaces

• The design of control surfaces involves various factors that affect their performance, reliability, and safety
• These considerations include the airfoil shape, hinge moment, structural integrity, flutter prevention, and balancing

Airfoil shape

• The cross-sectional shape of a control surface determines its aerodynamic characteristics and effectiveness
• Airfoil shapes are selected based on the desired lift, drag, and moment coefficients, as well as the operating conditions (Mach number, Reynolds number)
• Symmetrical airfoils are often used for control surfaces to provide equal effectiveness in both positive and negative deflections (NACA 0012)

Hinge moment

• The aerodynamic moment acting on a control surface about its hinge line
• Hinge moments can make control surfaces harder to deflect, requiring greater actuator forces
• Control surfaces are designed to minimize hinge moments through proper airfoil selection, hinge line placement, and balancing techniques (horn balances, servo tabs)

Structural integrity

• Control surfaces must withstand the aerodynamic loads, inertial forces, and vibrations encountered during flight
• Structural design ensures that control surfaces maintain their shape, stiffness, and strength under various operating conditions
• Materials selection (aluminum alloys, composites) and manufacturing processes (riveting, bonding) play a crucial role in ensuring structural integrity

Flutter prevention

• Flutter is a dangerous aeroelastic instability that can occur when the aerodynamic forces on a control surface couple with its structural dynamics
• Flutter can lead to rapid oscillations, structural damage, and loss of control
• Control surfaces are designed to prevent flutter through proper mass balancing, stiffness distribution, and damping mechanisms (mass balances, dampers)

Balancing vs unbalancing

• Control surfaces can be balanced or unbalanced, depending on the location of their center of gravity relative to the hinge line
• Balanced control surfaces have their center of gravity close to the hinge line, reducing hinge moments and actuator forces
• Unbalanced control surfaces have their center of gravity offset from the hinge line, increasing hinge moments but providing greater control authority and feedback to the pilot

Control surface actuation systems

• Actuation systems are responsible for converting the pilot's (or autopilot's) commands into control surface deflections
• Various actuation technologies are used, depending on the aircraft's size, performance requirements, and system architecture

Hydraulic actuation

• Uses hydraulic fluid pressure to generate the force needed to move control surfaces
• Hydraulic actuators (cylinders, motors) are connected to the control surfaces through linkages or direct drive mechanisms
• Hydraulic systems provide high power density, fast response, and precise control, but require regular maintenance and are vulnerable to leaks and contamination

Electric actuation

• Uses electric motors to drive control surface actuators (linear or rotary)
• Electric actuation systems are becoming more common in modern aircraft due to their simplicity, reliability, and reduced maintenance requirements
• Challenges include power density limitations, thermal management, and electromagnetic interference

Fly-by-wire systems

• Replace traditional mechanical linkages between the pilot's controls and the actuators with electronic signals
• Pilot inputs are processed by a flight control computer, which sends commands to the actuators based on the aircraft's state and control laws
• Fly-by-wire systems enable advanced control algorithms, envelope protection, and weight reduction, but require extensive redundancy and fault tolerance

Redundancy and failsafe mechanisms

• Control surface actuation systems must be highly reliable and fault-tolerant to ensure safe operation
• Redundancy is achieved through multiple independent actuators, power sources, and signal paths for each control surface
• Failsafe mechanisms ensure that control surfaces return to a neutral or safe position in case of actuator or system failure (centering springs, dampers)

Integration with flight control systems

• Control surfaces are an integral part of an aircraft's flight control system, which includes primary and secondary controls, autopilot, and stability augmentation

Primary flight controls

• Consist of the ailerons, elevators, and rudder, which are directly controlled by the pilot through the control yoke (or sidestick) and rudder pedals
• Primary flight controls are essential for maintaining and changing the aircraft's attitude and direction
• Control surface deflections are proportional to the pilot's inputs, providing direct feedback and control authority

Secondary flight controls

• Include flaps, slats, spoilers, and trim systems, which are used to modify the aircraft's lift, drag, and balance characteristics
• Secondary flight controls are typically operated by the pilot through separate levers, switches, or automatic systems
• These controls are used during specific phases of flight (takeoff, landing, cruise) to optimize performance and reduce pilot workload

Autopilot systems

• Automatically control the aircraft's attitude, heading, altitude, and speed by sending commands to the control surface actuators
• Autopilot systems use sensors (gyroscopes, accelerometers, GPS) to measure the aircraft's state and compute the necessary control surface deflections
• Modern autopilot systems can perform complex maneuvers, such as autoland, and integrate with other avionics (flight management systems, navigation systems)

Stability augmentation systems

• Improve the aircraft's handling qualities and reduce pilot workload by automatically damping undesired motions and providing artificial stability
• Stability augmentation systems use sensors to detect the aircraft's motion and apply small control surface deflections to counteract disturbances (gusts, turbulence)
• These systems can be integrated with the primary flight controls (yaw damper) or operate independently (active flutter suppression)

Performance impact of control surfaces

• The design and operation of control surfaces have a significant impact on an aircraft's overall performance, including its lift-to-drag ratio, stall speed, maneuverability, and takeoff and landing distances

Lift-to-drag ratio

• Control surfaces contribute to the aircraft's total drag, reducing the lift-to-drag ratio and fuel efficiency
• Streamlined control surface designs, smooth surfaces, and proper sealing can help minimize drag and improve the lift-to-drag ratio
• Active control technologies, such as adaptive trailing edges and morphing surfaces, can further optimize the lift-to-drag ratio throughout the flight envelope

Stall speed

• The effectiveness of control surfaces, particularly flaps and slats, directly affects the aircraft's stall speed
• Deploying flaps and slats increases the wing's lift coefficient, allowing the aircraft to maintain lift at lower speeds
• Lower stall speeds enable shorter takeoff and landing distances, improved low-speed handling, and enhanced safety margins

Maneuverability

• Control surfaces are essential for an aircraft's maneuverability, enabling it to change attitude, direction, and speed rapidly and precisely
• The size, deflection range, and actuation speed of control surfaces determine the aircraft's agility and responsiveness
• High-performance aircraft (fighters, aerobatic planes) have larger and more powerful control surfaces to achieve extreme maneuvers and high roll rates

Takeoff and landing distances

• Flaps and slats play a crucial role in reducing takeoff and landing distances by increasing the wing's lift coefficient at low speeds
• Deploying these control surfaces allows the aircraft to take off and land at lower speeds, reducing the required runway length
• Spoilers and thrust reversers further assist in reducing landing distances by increasing drag and providing braking force

Maintenance and inspection of control surfaces

• Regular maintenance and inspection of control surfaces are essential for ensuring their proper function, reliability, and safety
• Maintenance activities include cleaning, lubrication, rigging, and repair or replacement of damaged components

Scheduled maintenance intervals

• Control surfaces are inspected and serviced at regular intervals based on the aircraft's maintenance program and regulatory requirements
• Typical intervals include pre-flight checks, daily inspections, periodic (phase) checks, and heavy maintenance visits (letter checks)
• The frequency and scope of maintenance tasks depend on the aircraft type, operating environment, and accumulated flight hours or cycles

Non-destructive testing techniques

• Non-destructive testing (NDT) methods are used to detect and assess structural damage or degradation in control surfaces without causing further harm
• Common NDT techniques include visual inspection, dye penetrant testing, eddy current testing, ultrasonic testing, and radiography
• NDT helps identify cracks, corrosion, delamination, and other defects that may compromise the control surface's integrity and performance

Corrosion prevention

• Control surfaces are susceptible to corrosion due to exposure to moisture, salt, and other environmental factors
• Corrosion prevention measures include regular cleaning, application of protective coatings (paint, sealants), and proper drainage and ventilation
• Corrosion inspections are performed to detect and assess the extent of corrosion damage, and corrective actions are taken to remove corrosion and restore the surface protection

Repair procedures

• Damaged or worn control surfaces may require repair or replacement to maintain their airworthiness and performance
• Repair procedures vary depending on the type and extent of damage, as well as the materials and construction of the control surface
• Common repair techniques include patching, reinforcing, splicing, and bonding, following approved maintenance manuals and repair schemes
• Major repairs or modifications to control surfaces may require additional testing, inspection, and certification by the aircraft manufacturer or regulatory authority