4.5 Major strikes and labor disputes

Labor disputes shaped American business history, highlighting tensions between workers and management. From early mutual aid societies to national unions, these movements fought for better conditions and wages, often through strikes and boycotts.

Government intervention played a key role, from violent suppression to mediating disputes and passing labor laws. Major strikes like Haymarket and Pullman led to reforms, while organizations like the AFL-CIO continue to advocate for workers' rights today.

Origins of labor movements

• Labor movements in American business history emerged as a response to harsh working conditions and exploitation during industrialization
• These movements fundamentally reshaped employer-employee relations and led to significant reforms in labor laws and practices
• Understanding the origins of labor movements provides crucial context for the development of modern workplace standards and regulations

Early worker organizations

Top images from around the web for Early worker organizations

• 

  Union Labor Built the American Dream | Red, white and blue V… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Labor Movement | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Progressive Charlestown: The Workers First Agenda View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Union Labor Built the American Dream | Red, white and blue V… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Labor Movement | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Early worker organizations

• 

  Union Labor Built the American Dream | Red, white and blue V… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Labor Movement | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Progressive Charlestown: The Workers First Agenda View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Union Labor Built the American Dream | Red, white and blue V… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Labor Movement | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Mutual aid societies formed by skilled craftsmen in the late 18th and early 19th centuries
• Journeymen's unions established to protect wages and working conditions (carpenters, printers)
• Mechanics' Union of Trade Associations in Philadelphia (1827) considered the first city-wide labor organization
• Commonwealth v. Hunt case (1842) legalized peaceful union organizing

Impact of industrialization

• Shift from artisanal to factory production created new class of wage laborers
• Long working hours, dangerous conditions, and child labor became widespread issues
• Urbanization led to overcrowded living conditions for workers
• Technological advancements (steam power, assembly lines) increased productivity but often at the expense of worker well-being

Rise of labor unions

• National Labor Union (1866) advocated for 8-hour workday and currency reform
• Noble Order of the Knights of Labor (1869) promoted inclusive unionism across skill levels and industries
• American Federation of Labor (1886) focused on organizing skilled workers by craft
• Industrial Workers of the World (1905) pursued radical syndicalism and industrial unionism

Key labor disputes

• Labor disputes played a crucial role in shaping American business practices and labor laws
• These conflicts often resulted in violence, highlighting the intensity of tensions between workers and management
• Understanding key disputes provides insight into the evolution of labor relations and government intervention in the workplace

Haymarket affair

• Occurred on May 4, 1886, in Chicago during a labor demonstration for the 8-hour workday
• Bomb explosion and subsequent gunfire led to deaths of police officers and civilians
• Resulted in controversial trial and execution of anarchist leaders
• Sparked international outrage and became a symbol for the labor movement
  • Led to the establishment of May Day as an international workers' holiday

Homestead strike

• Took place at Carnegie Steel Company in Homestead, Pennsylvania, in 1892
• Dispute over wage cuts and union-busting tactics by management
• Violent confrontation between striking workers and Pinkerton detectives
• National Guard intervention ultimately broke the strike
  • Resulted in significant setback for the labor movement and decline of unions in the steel industry

Pullman strike

• Began in 1894 at the Pullman Palace Car Company in Chicago
• Workers protested wage cuts and high rents in the company town
• American Railway Union led by Eugene V. Debs joined the strike, causing nationwide railway disruptions
• Federal government intervened with injunctions and troops to break the strike
  • Led to the establishment of Labor Day as a federal holiday to appease workers

Tactics and strategies

• Labor movements employed various tactics to achieve their goals and improve working conditions
• These strategies evolved over time in response to changing economic and political landscapes
• Understanding these tactics provides insight into the power dynamics between workers and employers

Collective bargaining

• Process of negotiation between unions and employers to establish workplace agreements
• Covers issues such as wages, hours, benefits, and working conditions
• Wagner Act (1935) guaranteed the right to collective bargaining for private sector workers
• Taft-Hartley Act (1947) placed restrictions on union activities and collective bargaining processes

Strikes vs lockouts

• Strikes involve workers withholding labor to pressure employers
  • Can be wildcat (unauthorized), sit-down, or general strikes
• Lockouts occur when employers prevent workers from entering the workplace
  • Used as a counter-tactic to strikes or to force concessions from workers
• Both tactics aim to disrupt production and create economic pressure
• Legal protections and limitations for strikes and lockouts vary by jurisdiction and industry

Boycotts and picketing

• Boycotts involve refusing to purchase goods or services from targeted companies
  • Primary boycotts target the direct employer
  • Secondary boycotts target companies doing business with the primary employer (restricted by Taft-Hartley Act)
• Picketing involves demonstrating outside a workplace to discourage others from entering
  • Can be informational, organizational, or recognitional
• Both tactics aim to create public awareness and economic pressure on employers
  • Often used in conjunction with strikes or other labor actions

Government intervention

• Government involvement in labor disputes has been a significant factor in shaping American business history
• Intervention has ranged from pro-business to pro-labor policies depending on the political climate
• Understanding government roles provides context for the development of labor laws and regulations

Labor legislation

• Sherman Antitrust Act (1890) initially used against unions, later clarified by Clayton Act (1914)
• National Labor Relations Act (Wagner Act, 1935) established workers' right to unionize and bargain collectively
• Fair Labor Standards Act (1938) set minimum wage, overtime pay, and child labor regulations
• Taft-Hartley Act (1947) restricted union activities and allowed states to pass right-to-work laws

Federal mediation efforts

• United States Conciliation Service established in 1913 to mediate labor disputes
• Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service (FMCS) created in 1947 to provide neutral third-party assistance
• National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) established in 1935 to enforce labor law and mediate disputes
• Presidential interventions in major strikes (Truman's seizure of steel mills in 1952)

Use of military force

• Militia Act of 1792 allowed presidents to call up state militias to suppress labor unrest
• Federal troops used in numerous strikes (Pullman Strike, Colorado Labor Wars)
• National Guard deployments in state-level labor conflicts (Ludlow Massacre, 1914)
• Shift towards less direct military intervention in labor disputes after World War II
  • Increased reliance on court injunctions and federal mediation

Major labor organizations

• Labor organizations played a crucial role in advancing workers' rights and shaping American business practices
• These organizations evolved in response to changing economic conditions and worker needs
• Understanding major labor organizations provides insight into the development of the American labor movement

Knights of Labor

• Founded in 1869 as a secret society, later became public in 1881
• Advocated for an eight-hour workday, abolition of child labor, and equal pay for equal work
• Included both skilled and unskilled workers, as well as farmers and small business owners
• Declined after the Haymarket Affair and competition from craft unions
  • Membership peaked at 700,000 in 1886 before rapidly declining

American Federation of Labor

• Formed in 1886 under the leadership of Samuel Gompers
• Focused on organizing skilled workers by craft (carpenters, masons, printers)
• Pursued "pure and simple unionism" emphasizing economic gains over political action
• Dominated the American labor movement for much of the early 20th century
  • Membership grew from 250,000 in 1896 to over 4 million by 1920

Congress of Industrial Organizations

• Emerged in 1935 as the Committee for Industrial Organization within the AFL
• Focused on organizing unskilled workers in mass production industries (auto, steel, rubber)
• Led successful sit-down strikes and organizing drives in the 1930s
• Expelled from AFL in 1938, became independent Congress of Industrial Organizations
  • Merged with AFL in 1955 to form AFL-CIO, representing over 15 million workers

Industry-specific strikes

• Different industries experienced unique labor challenges and conflicts
• Industry-specific strikes often had far-reaching impacts on the broader economy and labor movement
• Understanding these strikes provides insight into the diverse nature of labor issues across sectors

Coal mining disputes

• Anthracite Coal Strike of 1902 involved over 140,000 miners in Pennsylvania
  • President Theodore Roosevelt intervened, leading to the first federal mediation of a labor dispute
• Ludlow Massacre (1914) in Colorado resulted in violent suppression of striking coal miners
• United Mine Workers strikes in 1919 and 1946 led to government seizure of mines
  • Highlighted the strategic importance of coal to the national economy

Railroad worker strikes

• Great Railroad Strike of 1877 was the first nationwide strike in U.S. history
  • Resulted in widespread violence and federal troop intervention
• Pullman Strike of 1894 led to a national railway boycott and federal injunctions
• Railroad shopmen's strike of 1922 involved 400,000 workers protesting wage cuts
  • Resulted in the Railway Labor Act of 1926, establishing mediation procedures for railway disputes

Textile industry conflicts

• Lowell Mill Girls' strikes (1834 and 1836) were early examples of women-led labor actions
• Lawrence Textile Strike (1912) united workers from diverse ethnic backgrounds
  • Known as the "Bread and Roses" strike, highlighting demands for dignity as well as fair wages
• Textile workers' strike of 1934 involved 400,000 workers across the Southern United States
  • Demonstrated the challenges of organizing in the anti-union South

Social and economic impact

• Labor movements and disputes had profound effects on American society and economy
• These impacts extended beyond immediate workplace issues to shape broader social and economic policies
• Understanding these effects provides context for the long-term significance of labor history in American business

Public opinion shifts

• Increased awareness of labor issues through media coverage of major strikes
• Progressive Era reforms partly driven by public sympathy for workers' struggles
• Fluctuations in public support for unions influenced by economic conditions and Cold War politics
• Rise of investigative journalism (muckrakers) exposed workplace abuses and swayed public opinion
  • Upton Sinclair's "The Jungle" (1906) led to food safety regulations

Wage and working condition changes

• Gradual adoption of 8-hour workday and 40-hour workweek across industries
• Establishment of minimum wage laws and overtime pay regulations
• Improvements in workplace safety standards and creation of OSHA (1970)
• Expansion of employee benefits (health insurance, pensions) through collective bargaining
  • Taft-Hartley Act (1947) allowed unions to negotiate for multi-employer pension plans

Corporate responses

• Development of welfare capitalism programs to discourage unionization
  • Company towns, employee stock ownership plans, recreational facilities
• Adoption of scientific management techniques to increase efficiency and control
• Use of strikebreakers (scabs) and private security forces (Pinkertons) to combat strikes
• Relocation of production to areas with weaker union presence (South, overseas)
  • Contributed to deindustrialization of traditional manufacturing regions

Technological influences

• Technological advancements significantly impacted labor relations and workplace dynamics
• These influences often created tensions between workers and management over job security and skills
• Understanding technological influences provides context for ongoing debates about automation and the future of work

Mechanization effects

• Introduction of machinery in factories reduced demand for skilled craftsmen
• Assembly line production increased efficiency but led to deskilling and monotonous work
• Mechanization in agriculture displaced farm workers and contributed to urbanization
• Resistance to new technologies sometimes led to labor disputes (Luddite-inspired actions)
  • Longshoremen's strikes against containerization in the 1960s

Automation vs job security

• Post-World War II automation raised fears of widespread technological unemployment
• Unions negotiated for job protection measures and retraining programs
• Debates over the impact of computers and robotics on manufacturing jobs
• Growth of service sector employment partially offset manufacturing job losses
  • Shift from blue-collar to white-collar work changed the nature of labor organizing

Skilled vs unskilled labor

• Technological changes altered the balance between skilled and unskilled workers
• Craft unions faced challenges as machines replaced specialized skills
• Rise of semi-skilled machine operators created new categories of industrial workers
• Ongoing debates over the value of vocational training vs general education
  • Community colleges emerged as a response to changing skill requirements

Post-World War II developments

• The post-war era brought significant changes to the American labor landscape
• Cold War politics, economic shifts, and social changes influenced labor relations
• Understanding these developments provides context for the current state of labor movements

Cold War labor politics

• Taft-Hartley Act (1947) required union leaders to sign non-communist affidavits
• Expulsion of left-wing unions from the CIO during the Red Scare
• AFL-CIO support for anti-communist foreign policy initiatives
• International labor programs as part of Cold War diplomacy
  • AFL-CIO's American Institute for Free Labor Development operated in Latin America

Public sector unionization

• Growth of government employment led to increased public sector unionization
• Executive Order 10988 (1962) granted federal employees limited collective bargaining rights
• State and local government workers gained unionization rights in many jurisdictions
• Teachers' unions became influential in education policy debates
  • National Education Association transformed from professional association to labor union

Decline of union membership

• Peak union density of 35% in mid-1950s declined to about 10% by 2020
• Shift from manufacturing to service sector employment reduced traditional union strongholds
• Increased global competition and offshoring of jobs weakened union bargaining power
• Growth of the gig economy and non-traditional employment arrangements posed organizing challenges
  • Rise of "right-to-work" laws in many states further weakened union influence

Modern labor issues

• Contemporary labor challenges reflect changing economic and technological landscapes
• These issues often involve redefining traditional concepts of employment and worker rights
• Understanding modern labor issues provides insight into potential future developments in American business

Globalization challenges

• Offshoring and outsourcing of jobs to countries with lower labor costs
• Increased competition from foreign workers in both manufacturing and service sectors
• Debates over trade agreements and their impact on domestic employment
• Efforts to establish international labor standards and worker protections
  • Campaigns against sweatshop labor and for fair trade practices

Gig economy impacts

• Growth of platform-based work (Uber, TaskRabbit) challenges traditional employment models
• Debates over worker classification as employees vs independent contractors
• Lack of traditional benefits and job security for gig workers
• Efforts to organize and secure rights for gig economy workers
  • California's AB5 law attempted to reclassify many gig workers as employees

Right-to-work laws

• Legislation allowing workers to opt out of union membership and dues in unionized workplaces
• Spread of right-to-work laws from traditional Southern states to Midwest industrial states
• Debates over the impact on union strength and worker wages
• Union strategies to maintain membership and influence in right-to-work environments
  • Development of "members-only" unions and alternative organizing models

Legacy and significance

• The labor movement has left a lasting impact on American business and society
• Many workplace standards and practices originated from labor struggles
• Understanding this legacy provides context for ongoing debates about worker rights and economic policy

Labor Day establishment

• Created as a federal holiday in 1894 following the Pullman Strike
• Recognized the contributions of American workers to the nation's prosperity
• Evolved from a day of protest and celebration to a general end-of-summer holiday
• Continues to serve as a focal point for discussions of labor issues and worker rights
  • Annual Labor Day addresses by presidents often highlight economic and workforce policies

Workplace safety improvements

• Establishment of Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) in 1970
• Development of industry-specific safety standards and regulations
• Reduction in workplace fatalities and injuries over time
• Ongoing challenges in enforcing safety standards and addressing new workplace hazards
  • Debates over ergonomics standards and psychological safety in modern workplaces

Collective bargaining rights

• National Labor Relations Act (1935) established legal framework for collective bargaining
• Expansion of bargaining rights to public sector workers in many jurisdictions
• Influence of collective bargaining on non-union workplaces (pattern bargaining)
• Ongoing debates over the scope and limitations of collective bargaining rights
  • Recent conflicts over public sector collective bargaining rights in states like Wisconsin