🏜️American Literature – 1860 to Present Unit 5 – Realism and Naturalism in American Literature

Key Concepts and Definitions

• Realism depicts life as it is, without idealization or romanticization, focusing on ordinary people and everyday situations
• Naturalism builds on realist principles but emphasizes the role of determinism, the idea that human actions and fates are determined by external forces (heredity, environment, chance)
• Verisimilitude refers to the appearance of truth or reality in a work of fiction, a key goal of realist and naturalist writers
• Regionalism focuses on the distinct characteristics, dialects, customs, and settings of a particular geographic region (local color)
  • Includes works set in the American South, Midwest, and West
• Determinism suggests that human behavior and outcomes are shaped by factors beyond individual control (social conditions, biology, chance events)
• Objectivity involves presenting characters and events without authorial judgment or overt moralizing, allowing readers to draw their own conclusions
• Slice-of-life stories depict a brief, representative portion of a character's life, often without a traditional plot structure or resolution
• Social criticism addresses societal problems and injustices (poverty, inequality, corruption) through literature

Historical Context

• Realism and Naturalism emerged in the late 19th century, following the Civil War and Reconstruction eras
• Rapid industrialization, urbanization, and immigration transformed American society, creating new social and economic challenges
• The rise of science and Darwin's theory of evolution influenced literary themes and techniques, emphasizing the role of natural forces in shaping human lives
• Journalism and the growth of mass-circulation magazines created a demand for realistic, socially engaged literature
• The Gilded Age (1870s-1890s) was characterized by economic growth, political corruption, and social inequality, providing rich material for realist and naturalist writers
• The Progressive Era (1890s-1920s) saw reformist efforts to address social problems, reflected in the works of many realist and naturalist authors
• Technological advancements (photography, motion pictures) shaped public expectations for realistic representation in art and literature

Major Authors and Works

• Mark Twain (Samuel Clemens), known for his regionalist works and social satire (Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, The Gilded Age)
• William Dean Howells, a leading proponent of realism and editor who championed the works of other realist writers (The Rise of Silas Lapham, A Modern Instance)
• Henry James, known for his psychological realism and explorations of American and European social mores (The Portrait of a Lady, The Turn of the Screw)
• Stephen Crane, a pioneering naturalist who depicted the harsh realities of war and urban life (The Red Badge of Courage, Maggie: A Girl of the Streets)
• Theodore Dreiser, a naturalist who explored the impact of social and economic forces on individual lives (Sister Carrie, An American Tragedy)
• Kate Chopin, known for her feminist themes and frank depictions of female sexuality (The Awakening, "The Story of an Hour")
• Frank Norris, a naturalist who exposed the exploitation and corruption of the Gilded Age (McTeague, The Octopus)
• Edith Wharton, who critiqued the upper-class society of the Gilded Age (The House of Mirth, The Age of Innocence)

Literary Techniques and Themes

• Detailed, objective descriptions of settings, characters, and events to create a sense of realism
• Use of vernacular speech and regional dialects to capture the authentic voices of diverse characters
• In-depth psychological characterization, exploring the inner lives and motivations of characters
• Emphasis on the impact of social, economic, and environmental forces on individual lives and choices
• Critique of societal problems and injustices (poverty, inequality, corruption, oppression)
• Exploration of determinism and the limits of free will in shaping human destinies
• Use of symbolism and imagery to convey themes and ideas
• Naturalist works often employ a detached, scientific tone and focus on characters from the lower social classes
• Realist works frequently examine the lives of middle- and upper-class characters, exposing the realities beneath social conventions and expectations

Comparison to Other Movements

• Realism and Naturalism rejected the idealism, sentimentality, and escapism of Romanticism, focusing instead on the realities of everyday life
• Realism sought to depict life as it was, without the moral didacticism of earlier movements like Transcendentalism
• Naturalism extended realist principles but emphasized the role of deterministic forces, aligning with scientific theories of the time
• Modernism, which emerged in the early 20th century, built on the realist tradition but experimented with new forms and techniques to capture the fragmented, subjective nature of modern experience
• Realism and Naturalism influenced later movements, such as Social Realism and the Harlem Renaissance, which continued to address social issues and depict marginalized communities

Social and Cultural Impact

• Realism and Naturalism helped to democratize literature by depicting the lives of ordinary people and marginalized groups
• These movements raised public awareness of social problems and injustices, contributing to Progressive Era reforms
• Realist and naturalist works challenged traditional gender roles and expectations, paving the way for more feminist literature in the 20th century
• The emphasis on regional settings and dialects fostered a sense of American cultural diversity and identity
• Realism and Naturalism influenced the development of journalism, encouraging a more objective, fact-based approach to reporting
• These movements also shaped the emerging fields of sociology and anthropology, which studied human behavior and social conditions

Critical Analysis and Interpretation

• Critics have debated the extent to which realist and naturalist works truly capture reality, given the inherent subjectivity of the author's perspective and choices
• Some critics argue that the deterministic worldview of Naturalism is overly pessimistic and denies the possibility of human agency and free will
• Feminist critics have examined the portrayal of women in realist and naturalist works, noting both the progressive depiction of female experience and the limitations of male-authored texts
• Marxist critics have interpreted realist and naturalist works as critiques of capitalist exploitation and class inequality
• Postcolonial critics have explored the representation of race, ethnicity, and power dynamics in works by white authors depicting marginalized communities
• New Historicist critics have situated realist and naturalist works within their historical and cultural contexts, examining how they both reflect and shape societal values and beliefs

Legacy and Modern Relevance

• Realism and Naturalism paved the way for the development of modern literature, influencing writers throughout the 20th and 21st centuries
• The emphasis on social criticism and marginalized voices in these movements anticipated the concerns of later literary traditions (African American literature, proletarian literature, postcolonial literature)
• Many of the themes addressed in realist and naturalist works (inequality, oppression, the impact of social forces on individual lives) remain relevant to contemporary readers
• The techniques of psychological characterization, objective narration, and detailed description continue to be used by modern authors
• Realist and naturalist works provide valuable historical insights into American society and culture in the late 19th and early 20th centuries
• The legacy of these movements can be seen in the enduring popularity and critical acclaim of authors like Mark Twain, Henry James, and Theodore Dreiser
• Contemporary authors continue to draw inspiration from the realist and naturalist traditions, adapting their principles to depict the realities and challenges of modern life