11.3 Neoplatonism and Stoicism

Roman philosophy evolved, blending Greek ideas with mysticism and pragmatism. Neoplatonism, founded by Plotinus, saw reality as emanating from "The One." It influenced Christian theology and encouraged spiritual introspection.

Stoicism, emphasizing reason and virtue, appealed to Roman values of duty and resilience. It provided a practical ethical framework for governance and personal conduct, shaping Roman political thought and social attitudes.

Neoplatonism: Principles and Influence

Core Concepts and Structure

Top images from around the web for Core Concepts and Structure

• 

  Commons:Graphic Lab/Illustration workshop/Archive/2021 - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Neoplatonismo - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Robert Fludd 1.gif - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Commons:Graphic Lab/Illustration workshop/Archive/2021 - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Neoplatonismo - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Core Concepts and Structure

• 

  Commons:Graphic Lab/Illustration workshop/Archive/2021 - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Neoplatonismo - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Robert Fludd 1.gif - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Commons:Graphic Lab/Illustration workshop/Archive/2021 - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Neoplatonismo - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Neoplatonism synthesized Platonic ideas with mysticism and Eastern thought founded by Plotinus in the 3rd century CE
• "The One" represents the ultimate source of all existence from which reality emanates hierarchically
• Three primary hypostases form the structure of reality
  • The One: ineffable source of all existence
  • Intellect (Nous): first emanation from The One, realm of pure thought and ideas
  • Soul (Psyche): emanation from Intellect, bridge between intelligible and physical realms
• Human existence aims to achieve union with The One through contemplation and spiritual ascent
  • Involves purification of the soul and detachment from material concerns
  • Meditation and philosophical reflection serve as means to ascend spiritually

Influence on Roman Thought

• Provided philosophical framework reconcilable with monotheistic tendencies and mystical experiences
• Porphyry and Iamblichus significantly contributed to Neoplatonic development in the Roman world
  • Porphyry's "Isagoge" became standard logic textbook for centuries
  • Iamblichus introduced theurgic practices, blending philosophy with religious ritual
• Influenced development of early Christian theology
  • St. Augustine incorporated Neoplatonic concepts into Christian doctrine
  • Concept of divine emanation paralleled Christian ideas of God's creation
• Shaped Roman attitudes towards the soul and its relationship to the divine
  • Encouraged introspection and spiritual self-improvement
  • Provided philosophical basis for belief in an immortal soul

Stoicism: Tenets and Appeal

Fundamental Principles

• Founded by Zeno of Citium in 3rd century BCE emphasized living in accordance with reason and virtue
• Logos (universal reason) governs the cosmos as a rational and providential order
• Virtue stands as the only true good while external circumstances remain indifferent
• Cardinal virtues highly valued in Roman society
  • Wisdom (sophia): understanding of nature and human affairs
  • Justice (dikaiosyne): fair and equitable treatment of others
  • Courage (andreia): fortitude in face of adversity
  • Self-control (sophrosyne): moderation and discipline in all aspects of life
• Teaches acceptance of what cannot be changed (amor fati) and focus on personal responsibility

Appeal to Roman Intellectuals and Politicians

• Emphasized duty self-discipline and resilience in face of adversity aligning with Roman values
• Provided practical framework for ethical decision-making in governance and public life
• Prominent Roman Stoics adapted philosophy to address practical concerns of Roman life
  • Seneca advised on personal ethics and political conduct
  • Epictetus focused on individual freedom and self-mastery
  • Marcus Aurelius applied Stoic principles to leadership and self-reflection
• Offered consolation and guidance during periods of political instability and social change
• Complemented Roman ideals of virtus (virtue) and gravitas (seriousness)

Neoplatonism vs Stoicism: Philosophical Approaches

Metaphysical and Ethical Focus

• Neoplatonism focuses on metaphysical and mystical aspects of reality
  • Emphasizes hierarchical structure of existence
  • Seeks ultimate truth through contemplation and mystical experiences
• Stoicism emphasizes practical ethics and living in harmony with nature
  • Focuses on cultivating virtue in everyday life
  • Aims to achieve inner peace through rational understanding and acceptance

Concepts of Divine Order

• Both acknowledge divine or cosmic order but differ in interpretation
  • Neoplatonism: hierarchical emanation from The One
  • Stoicism: all-pervading rational principle (logos)
• Neoplatonism emphasizes soul's ascent towards union with The One
• Stoicism focuses on aligning individual reason with universal logos

Views on Evil and Human Condition

• Neoplatonism sees evil as privation of good
  • Evil results from distance from The One
  • Spiritual ascent reduces evil's influence
• Stoicism views evil as result of ignorance and false judgments
  • Emphasizes importance of correct perception and rational thinking
  • Virtue and wisdom counteract evil's effects
• Both offer frameworks for understanding human condition
  • Neoplatonism: more speculative and mystical approach
  • Stoicism: more practical and action-oriented philosophy

Impact of Neoplatonism and Stoicism on Roman Society

Influence on Religion and Spirituality

• Neoplatonism significantly influenced early Christian theology
  • St. Augustine incorporated Neoplatonic concepts into Christian doctrine
  • Facilitated transition from polytheistic practices to more monotheistic approaches
• Neoplatonism's mystical elements influenced Roman religious practices
  • Development of theurgy ritual magic aimed at purifying the soul
  • Encouraged more personal and introspective spiritual experiences
• Stoicism provided ethical framework compatible with traditional Roman religion
  • Emphasized moral aspects of religious observance
  • Influenced Roman concepts of piety and divine providence

Political and Social Impact

• Stoicism shaped Roman political thought and governance
  • Influenced emperors like Marcus Aurelius in their approach to leadership
  • Provided philosophical basis for Roman law and justice (ius naturale)
• Both philosophies contributed to Roman concept of humanitas
  • Emphasized cultivation of reason and virtue as essential aspects of human nature
  • Promoted ideals of education and self-improvement
• Stoic ethics and ideas of cosmopolitanism influenced Roman attitudes towards citizenship
  • Expanded notion of moral responsibility beyond local communities
  • Contributed to more inclusive view of empire and its diverse populations
• Provided intellectual frameworks for coping with political and social challenges
  • Offered solace and meaning during times of instability (fall of Western Roman Empire)
  • Influenced development of Roman Stoicism as practical life philosophy