3.4 Roman Law and Justice

Roman law and justice were foundational to the empire's governance. The system evolved from early codes like the Twelve Tables to complex legal principles, shaping civil and criminal law. This development reflected Rome's growth and changing societal needs.

Praetors and other magistrates played key roles in adapting and applying the law. Roman legal concepts, from codification to specific principles, have had a lasting impact on modern legal systems, influencing areas like contracts, corporate law, and legal education.

Development of Roman Law

Foundational Legal Codes and Principles

Top images from around the web for Foundational Legal Codes and Principles

• 

  File:Balanced scale of Justice.svg - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Twelve Tables - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 6: The Roman World from 753 BCE to 500 CE – World History to 1700 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Balanced scale of Justice.svg - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Twelve Tables - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Foundational Legal Codes and Principles

• 

  File:Balanced scale of Justice.svg - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Twelve Tables - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chapter 6: The Roman World from 753 BCE to 500 CE – World History to 1700 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Balanced scale of Justice.svg - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Twelve Tables - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• The Twelve Tables created around 450 BCE marked the first written codification of Roman law
  • Established a foundation for legal principles and citizen rights
  • Carved on bronze tablets and displayed publicly in the Forum
  • Covered areas like property rights, family law, and legal procedures
• Ius civile (civil law) developed as a body of laws applicable only to Roman citizens
  • Included rules on property, contracts, and inheritance
  • Evolved through custom, legislation, and judicial interpretation
• Ius gentium (law of nations) emerged to govern interactions between citizens and non-citizens
  • Addressed issues in international trade and diplomacy
  • Influenced by principles of equity and natural justice
• Ius naturale (natural law) evolved as a philosophical basis for universal legal principles
  • Influenced the development of Roman jurisprudence
  • Emphasized concepts of reason, justice, and equality

Evolution and Adaptation of Roman Law

• The praetor's edict allowed for flexible adaptation of law to changing social needs
  • Annual declaration of legal principles by praetors
  • Contributed to the development of ius honorarium (honorary law)
  • Introduced new legal remedies and procedures (actiones in factum)
• Justinian's Corpus Juris Civilis compiled in the 6th century CE represented a comprehensive codification of Roman law
  • Included the Digest (juristic writings), Institutes (legal textbook), and Codex (imperial constitutions)
  • Preserved and systematized centuries of Roman legal thought
  • Served as a foundation for later European legal systems (civil law tradition)
• Legal commentaries and responsa prudentium (opinions of learned jurists) played a crucial role in interpreting and expanding Roman law
  • Jurists like Gaius, Ulpian, and Papinian provided authoritative legal opinions
  • Their works were often cited in court and used in legal education
  • Contributed to the development of legal doctrine and methodology

Civil vs Criminal Law in Rome

Characteristics of Civil Law

• Civil law (ius civile) primarily dealt with disputes between private individuals
  • Covered areas like property rights, contracts, and family matters
  • Aimed to resolve conflicts and provide compensation for wronged parties
• Civil cases typically initiated by private individuals
  • Plaintiff (actor) brought the case against the defendant (reus)
  • Burden of proof generally fell on the plaintiff
• Standard of proof in civil cases generally lower than in criminal cases
  • Often based on a preponderance of evidence
  • Judges had more discretion in weighing evidence and testimony
• Penalties in civil cases usually involved monetary compensation or restitution
  • Aimed to restore the injured party to their original position
  • Could include specific performance of contracts or transfer of property

Features of Criminal Law

• Criminal law (ius publicum) addressed offenses against the state or public order
  • Included crimes like treason (perduellio), murder (homicidium), and theft (furtum)
  • Focused on maintaining social order and deterring future crimes
• Criminal cases often pursued by state officials or magistrates
  • Quaestors or other appointed officials acted as prosecutors
  • Private citizens could also initiate criminal proceedings in some cases
• Higher standard of proof required in criminal cases
  • Evidence needed to be more substantial and convincing
  • Principle of in dubio pro reo (doubt favors the accused) applied
• Severe punishments possible in criminal cases
  • Included exile (exilium), forced labor (opus publicum), and execution
  • Penalties often aimed at public deterrence and retribution

Intersection of Civil and Criminal Law

• Concept of delicts in Roman law bridged civil and criminal law
  • Covered private wrongs that could lead to both civil liability and criminal penalties
  • Examples included theft (furtum), robbery (rapina), and damage to property (damnum iniuria datum)
• Some offenses could be pursued through either civil or criminal proceedings
  • Choice often depended on the severity of the offense and the desired outcome
  • Allowed for flexibility in addressing wrongdoing and seeking justice

Magistrates and Judges in Roman Law

Role of Praetors in Shaping Roman Law

• Praetors as high-ranking magistrates played a crucial role in shaping Roman law
  • Issued annual edicts outlining legal principles and procedures
  • Granted legal remedies and introduced new forms of action
  • Adapted law to changing social and economic conditions
• Urban praetor (praetor urbanus) had jurisdiction over cases involving Roman citizens
  • Presided over civil disputes between citizens
  • Interpreted and applied the ius civile
• Peregrine praetor (praetor peregrinus) handled cases involving foreigners
  • Developed principles of ius gentium to address international disputes
  • Contributed to the flexibility and adaptability of Roman law

Functions of Other Magistrates and Judges

• Quaestors served as investigative magistrates in criminal cases
  • Gathered evidence and prepared cases for trial
  • Acted as prosecutors in criminal proceedings
  • Worked closely with other magistrates in the administration of justice
• Judges (iudices) in civil cases often private citizens selected from an approved list
  • Determined facts and applied the law as directed by magistrates
  • Served as fact-finders and decision-makers in the trial phase
  • Chosen for their knowledge and reputation in the community
• Permanent courts (quaestiones perpetuae) established for criminal trials
  • Praetors presided over juries of citizens
  • Specialized courts for specific types of crimes (repetundae for extortion, ambitus for electoral corruption)
• Role of religious officials in legal matters gradually diminished
  • Pontifex maximus and other priests initially interpreted and applied sacred law (ius divinum)
  • Legal system became more secular over time
  • Religious elements remained in certain areas (family law, oaths)

Roman Law's Impact on Legal Systems

Influence on Legal Codification and Principles

• Concept of codified law influenced development of legal codes in many European countries
  • Twelve Tables and Justinian's Corpus Juris Civilis served as models
  • Inspired systematic organization of laws in civil law jurisdictions
  • Influenced legal reforms in countries like France (Napoleonic Code) and Germany (BGB)
• Roman legal principles continue as fundamental aspects of modern legal systems
  • Presumption of innocence (praesumptio innocentiae)
  • Burden of proof (onus probandi)
  • Due process (audi alteram partem - hear the other side)
• Roman distinction between ius (abstract law) and lex (specific statutes) shaped understanding of law in contemporary legal traditions
  • Influenced development of common law and civil law systems
  • Contributed to the concept of legal principles versus statutory law

Legacy in Specific Areas of Law

• Roman contract law significantly influenced modern contract law
  • Principles of good faith (bona fides) in contractual dealings
  • Pacta sunt servanda (agreements must be kept) as a cornerstone of contract law
  • Classification of contracts (verbal, written, real, consensual) influenced later legal systems
• Roman concept of legal personality impacted business and corporate law
  • Recognition of corporations as legal entities
  • Principles of limited liability and separate legal personality
  • Influenced development of modern company law and corporate structures
• Systematic study and teaching of law laid foundation for modern legal education
  • Development of legal textbooks and commentaries
  • Establishment of law schools and professional legal training
  • Influenced the structure of legal education in civil law countries