3.2 Resonant absorbers

Resonant absorbers are acoustic devices that target specific frequencies, using principles of resonance to absorb sound energy. They come in three main types: Helmholtz resonators, membrane absorbers, and perforated panel absorbers, each with unique design characteristics and applications in architectural acoustics.

These absorbers excel at controlling low-frequency sound and room modes, making them valuable tools in recording studios, industrial settings, and everyday buildings. By strategically designing and placing resonant absorbers, acousticians can create balanced, comfortable environments tailored to specific acoustic needs.

Types of resonant absorbers

• Resonant absorbers are a class of acoustic absorbers that utilize the phenomenon of resonance to absorb sound energy at specific frequencies
• These absorbers are designed to have a high absorption coefficient at their resonant frequency, which is determined by the physical properties and dimensions of the absorber
• The three main types of resonant absorbers are Helmholtz resonators, membrane absorbers, and perforated panel absorbers, each with unique design characteristics and applications in architectural acoustics

Helmholtz resonators

Top images from around the web for Helmholtz resonators

• 

  Resonant Modes of One-Dimensional Metamaterial Containing Helmholtz Resonators with Point Defect View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Resonant Modes of One-Dimensional Metamaterial Containing Helmholtz Resonators with Point Defect View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Resonant Modes of One-Dimensional Metamaterial Containing Helmholtz Resonators with Point Defect View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Resonant Modes of One-Dimensional Metamaterial Containing Helmholtz Resonators with Point Defect View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Resonant Modes of One-Dimensional Metamaterial Containing Helmholtz Resonators with Point Defect View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Helmholtz resonators

• 

  Resonant Modes of One-Dimensional Metamaterial Containing Helmholtz Resonators with Point Defect View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Resonant Modes of One-Dimensional Metamaterial Containing Helmholtz Resonators with Point Defect View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Resonant Modes of One-Dimensional Metamaterial Containing Helmholtz Resonators with Point Defect View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Resonant Modes of One-Dimensional Metamaterial Containing Helmholtz Resonators with Point Defect View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Resonant Modes of One-Dimensional Metamaterial Containing Helmholtz Resonators with Point Defect View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Consist of a rigid enclosure with a small opening (neck) that connects to a larger volume (cavity)
• Sound waves entering the neck cause the air in the cavity to compress and expand, dissipating sound energy through viscous losses and heat transfer
• Commonly used in low-frequency absorption applications (bass traps, room mode control)

Membrane absorbers

• Utilize a thin, flexible membrane (rubber, plastic, or foil) stretched over an air cavity
• Sound waves cause the membrane to vibrate, dissipating energy through mechanical losses and acoustic radiation
• Effective at absorbing low to mid-frequency sound, depending on the membrane material and cavity depth

Perforated panel absorbers

• Consist of a rigid panel with numerous small perforations, backed by an air cavity
• Sound waves passing through the perforations cause viscous losses and acoustic resistance, while the air cavity provides reactive impedance
• Offer a wider absorption bandwidth compared to Helmholtz resonators and membrane absorbers, making them suitable for mid to high-frequency absorption

Helmholtz resonator design

• The design of a Helmholtz resonator involves determining the appropriate cavity volume, neck dimensions, and resonant frequency to achieve the desired absorption characteristics
• These parameters are interdependent and can be calculated using mathematical formulas based on the principles of acoustics and fluid dynamics
• Proper design ensures optimal performance and efficient sound absorption within the targeted frequency range

Cavity volume

• The cavity volume ($V$) is the interior space of the resonator, typically a rectangular or cylindrical enclosure
• Larger cavity volumes result in lower resonant frequencies and increased low-frequency absorption
• The cavity volume is chosen based on the desired resonant frequency and available space constraints

Neck dimensions

• The neck is the opening that connects the cavity to the external environment, characterized by its length ($L$) and cross-sectional area ($A$)
• Longer necks and smaller cross-sectional areas increase the acoustic mass and resistance, lowering the resonant frequency
• Neck dimensions are optimized to achieve the desired resonant frequency and absorption bandwidth

Resonant frequency calculation

• The resonant frequency ($f_0$) of a Helmholtz resonator can be calculated using the following formula: $f_0 = \frac{c}{2\pi} \sqrt{\frac{A}{V(L + 1.7a)}}$

where:

• $c$ is the speed of sound in air
• $A$ is the cross-sectional area of the neck
• $V$ is the cavity volume
• $L$ is the length of the neck
• $a$ is the effective radius of the neck (for circular cross-sections)

Membrane absorber design

• Membrane absorbers are designed by selecting the appropriate membrane material, air cavity depth, and mounting method to achieve the desired absorption characteristics
• The membrane's physical properties, such as density, tension, and damping, play a crucial role in determining the absorber's resonant frequency and absorption efficiency
• Proper design ensures optimal vibration of the membrane and effective dissipation of sound energy within the targeted frequency range

Membrane material properties

• The choice of membrane material affects the absorber's resonant frequency, absorption bandwidth, and durability
• Common materials include rubber, plastic, foil, and specialized acoustic membranes with high internal damping
• Material properties such as density, Young's modulus, and loss factor determine the membrane's vibration behavior and energy dissipation

Air cavity depth

• The depth of the air cavity behind the membrane influences the absorber's resonant frequency and low-frequency absorption
• Deeper cavities result in lower resonant frequencies and increased absorption at longer wavelengths
• The cavity depth is chosen based on the desired resonant frequency, available space, and installation constraints

Resonant frequency calculation

• The resonant frequency ($f_0$) of a membrane absorber can be estimated using the following formula: $f_0 = \frac{1}{2\pi} \sqrt{\frac{T}{\rho_s d}}$

where:

• $T$ is the membrane tension per unit length
• $\rho_s$ is the surface density of the membrane (mass per unit area)
• $d$ is the depth of the air cavity

Perforated panel absorber design

• Perforated panel absorbers are designed by selecting the appropriate panel material, perforation size and spacing, and air cavity depth to achieve the desired absorption characteristics
• The panel's physical properties, such as material type, thickness, and perforation pattern, influence the absorber's acoustic resistance and reactive impedance
• Proper design ensures efficient sound energy dissipation through viscous losses and acoustic interactions within the perforations and air cavity

Panel material and thickness

• The panel material and thickness affect the absorber's durability, aesthetics, and acoustic properties
• Common materials include wood, metal, gypsum board, and specialized acoustic panels
• Thicker panels generally provide higher acoustic resistance and a more robust construction

Perforation size and spacing

• The size and spacing of the perforations determine the absorber's acoustic resistance and absorption bandwidth
• Smaller perforations and closer spacing result in higher acoustic resistance and broader absorption range
• Perforation patterns can be regular (uniform spacing) or irregular (optimized for specific frequency ranges)

Air cavity depth

• The depth of the air cavity behind the perforated panel influences the absorber's reactive impedance and low-frequency absorption
• Deeper cavities result in lower resonant frequencies and increased absorption at longer wavelengths
• The cavity depth is chosen based on the desired absorption characteristics, available space, and installation constraints

Resonant frequency calculation

• The resonant frequency ($f_0$) of a perforated panel absorber can be estimated using the following formula: $f_0 = \frac{c}{2\pi} \sqrt{\frac{P}{t_e + 0.8a}}$

where:

• $c$ is the speed of sound in air
• $P$ is the perforation ratio (open area divided by total area)
• $t_e$ is the effective panel thickness (panel thickness plus cavity depth)
• $a$ is the effective perforation radius

Absorption coefficient

• The absorption coefficient ($\alpha$) is a dimensionless quantity that represents the fraction of incident sound energy absorbed by a material or absorber
• It ranges from 0 (perfect reflection) to 1 (perfect absorption) and varies with frequency
• The absorption coefficient is a key parameter in evaluating the performance of resonant absorbers and designing acoustic treatments for architectural spaces

Measurement techniques

• The absorption coefficient can be measured using standardized methods, such as the reverberation room method (ISO 354) or the impedance tube method (ISO 10534-2)
• The reverberation room method involves measuring the decay of sound energy in a diffuse field, with and without the absorber present
• The impedance tube method uses a small sample of the absorber and measures the complex reflection coefficient using a standing wave pattern

Typical absorption curves

• Resonant absorbers exhibit characteristic absorption curves, with peak absorption at or near their resonant frequencies
• Helmholtz resonators and membrane absorbers typically have narrow absorption peaks, while perforated panel absorbers have broader absorption ranges
• The shape and width of the absorption curve depend on the absorber's design parameters and damping characteristics

Factors affecting absorption

• Several factors can influence the absorption coefficient of resonant absorbers:
  • Material properties (density, porosity, flow resistance)
  • Absorber geometry and dimensions
  • Mounting conditions (surface treatment, air gap behind the absorber)
  • Environmental conditions (temperature, humidity)
• Understanding these factors is crucial for optimizing the performance of resonant absorbers in real-world applications

Placement of resonant absorbers

• The placement of resonant absorbers within a room plays a significant role in their effectiveness and overall impact on the acoustic environment
• Strategic placement involves considering the room's geometry, modal behavior, and the absorbers' specific absorption characteristics
• Proper placement ensures efficient control of room modes, reduction of standing waves, and improvement of overall sound quality

Room modes and modal density

• Room modes are standing wave patterns that occur at specific frequencies, determined by the room's dimensions and boundary conditions
• Modal density refers to the number of modes per frequency band, which increases with frequency and room volume
• Resonant absorbers are often placed to target problematic low-frequency modes and reduce their impact on the acoustic environment

Optimal locations for absorption

• Optimal locations for resonant absorbers depend on the room's modal distribution and the absorbers' absorption characteristics
• For low-frequency modes, absorbers are typically placed at pressure maxima (corners, walls, and ceiling) to maximize their effectiveness
• For mid and high-frequency absorption, absorbers are distributed more evenly throughout the room to achieve a diffuse sound field

Integration with room aesthetics

• The placement of resonant absorbers should also consider the room's aesthetics and interior design
• Absorbers can be integrated into the room's architecture, such as disguised as functional elements (bookshelves, furniture) or decorative features (wall panels, artwork)
• Careful integration ensures a balance between acoustic performance and visual appeal

Advantages vs disadvantages

• Resonant absorbers offer unique advantages and disadvantages compared to other types of acoustic absorbers, such as porous materials
• Understanding these factors is essential for selecting the appropriate absorber type for a given application and optimizing the overall acoustic design

Comparison to porous absorbers

• Porous absorbers (fiberglass, mineral wool) provide broadband absorption, particularly effective at mid and high frequencies
• Resonant absorbers excel at targeting specific frequency ranges, making them suitable for low-frequency absorption and room mode control
• Porous absorbers are generally less effective at low frequencies, where resonant absorbers can provide significant absorption

Durability and maintenance

• Resonant absorbers are typically more durable and resistant to damage compared to porous absorbers
• Porous materials can deteriorate over time due to moisture, dust, and physical impact, requiring regular maintenance or replacement
• Resonant absorbers, such as perforated panels and Helmholtz resonators, are more robust and easier to clean or refinish

Cost considerations

• The cost of resonant absorbers varies depending on the materials, design complexity, and manufacturing process
• Custom-designed resonant absorbers may have higher initial costs compared to off-the-shelf porous absorbers
• However, the long-term durability and targeted absorption performance of resonant absorbers can offset the initial investment

Applications of resonant absorbers

• Resonant absorbers find numerous applications in architectural acoustics, where controlling specific frequency ranges and reducing unwanted noise is crucial
• These applications span various settings, from recording studios and performance spaces to industrial environments and everyday buildings
• The versatility and adaptability of resonant absorbers make them valuable tools in creating optimal acoustic environments

Recording studios and performance spaces

• In recording studios, resonant absorbers are used to control low-frequency room modes and reduce coloration of the recorded sound
• Helmholtz resonators and membrane absorbers are commonly employed as bass traps to absorb standing waves in corners and along walls
• Perforated panel absorbers can be used to fine-tune the mid and high-frequency response of the room, ensuring a balanced and accurate listening environment

Noise control in industrial settings

• Industrial environments often generate low-frequency noise from machinery, ventilation systems, and other sources
• Resonant absorbers, such as Helmholtz resonators and perforated panels, can be designed to target specific noise frequencies and reduce overall sound levels
• By strategically placing absorbers near noise sources or along transmission paths, industrial noise can be effectively mitigated, improving worker comfort and safety

Architectural acoustics in buildings

• In buildings such as offices, schools, and residential spaces, resonant absorbers can be used to control noise, reduce reverberation, and enhance speech intelligibility
• Perforated panel absorbers can be integrated into ceiling tiles, wall panels, or furniture to provide targeted absorption without compromising aesthetics
• Membrane absorbers can be disguised as decorative elements, such as stretched fabric wall coverings or acoustic artwork, combining sound control with visual appeal
• By carefully selecting and placing resonant absorbers, architects and acousticians can create comfortable and acoustically optimized spaces that support the intended use of the building