5.4 Mechanical cleaning methods

Mechanical cleaning methods are essential tools in art conservation, using physical action to remove dirt and debris from artwork surfaces. From gentle brushes to precise microabrasion, these techniques offer a range of options for conservators to safely clean delicate artworks.

Selecting the right mechanical cleaning method requires careful assessment of the artwork's materials, condition, and soiling. Conservators must balance cleaning effectiveness with the risk of damage, progressing from gentle to more aggressive techniques as needed. Proper technique and safety measures are crucial for successful treatment.

Mechanical Cleaning Tools and Techniques

Types of Mechanical Cleaning Tools

Top images from around the web for Types of Mechanical Cleaning Tools

• 

  Paintbrush - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Conserving Architectural Models: Behind the Scenes in the Research Institute Conservation Lab ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Conserving Architectural Models: Behind the Scenes in the Research Institute Conservation Lab ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Paintbrush - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Conserving Architectural Models: Behind the Scenes in the Research Institute Conservation Lab ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Types of Mechanical Cleaning Tools

• 

  Paintbrush - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Conserving Architectural Models: Behind the Scenes in the Research Institute Conservation Lab ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Conserving Architectural Models: Behind the Scenes in the Research Institute Conservation Lab ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Paintbrush - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Conserving Architectural Models: Behind the Scenes in the Research Institute Conservation Lab ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Brushes range from soft sable to stiff hog bristle suited for different cleaning tasks and surface types
  • Natural bristle brushes (hog, horse, ox) provide firmer cleaning action
  • Synthetic brushes (nylon, polyester) offer consistent texture and chemical resistance
• Erasers come in block, powder, and kneaded forms with varying levels of abrasiveness
  • Block erasers (vinyl, rubber) remove stubborn dirt but may leave residue
  • Kneaded erasers mold to surfaces and lift dirt without abrasion
• Microabrasion equipment includes air abrasive units and microsandblasters
  • Propel fine abrasive particles (aluminum oxide, glass beads) with compressed air
  • Remove surface deposits while minimizing damage to underlying substrate

Principles and Applications

• Mechanical cleaning utilizes friction, abrasion, or particle impact to remove dirt and debris
• Tool choice depends on soiling type, surface fragility, and desired cleaning level
  • Soft brushes for delicate surfaces (watercolors, pastels)
  • Firmer erasers for tenacious dirt on stable surfaces (oil paintings)
• Combine mechanical methods with chemical cleaning or consolidation for enhanced effectiveness
  • Use solvents to soften dirt before mechanical removal
  • Apply consolidants to stabilize fragile areas prior to cleaning

Selecting Mechanical Cleaning Methods

Artwork Assessment

• Evaluate material composition to determine stability and cleaning sensitivity
  • Identify pigments, binders, and support materials (canvas, wood, paper)
  • Consider age-related changes affecting material properties
• Assess artwork condition noting fragile areas requiring special care
  • Look for flaking paint, lifting canvas, or previous restorations
  • Document condition with detailed photography before cleaning
• Analyze nature and extent of soiling to guide cleaning approach
  • Differentiate between surface dust, ingrained dirt, and stains
  • Identify any potentially harmful deposits (mold, insect residues)

Tool Selection Criteria

• Match cleaning tool abrasiveness to surface hardness and durability
  • Use soft brushes on friable surfaces (chalk pastels, gouache)
  • Apply firmer tools to stable oil or acrylic paintings
• Choose softer tools like smoke sponges for delicate surfaces
  • Vulcanized rubber sponges gently lift dirt without moisture
  • Effective on paper, textiles, and matte paint surfaces
• Select microabrasion for tenacious deposits on stable surfaces
  • Adjust particle size and air pressure based on substrate resilience
  • Effective for removing stubborn accretions or overpaint
• Test cleaning methods on inconspicuous areas before full application
  • Start with gentlest method and progress if needed
  • Document results to inform overall cleaning strategy

Safe Mechanical Cleaning Techniques

Systematic Approach

• Progress from least aggressive to more intensive cleaning methods
  • Begin with dry brushing to remove loose surface dust
  • Advance to erasers or sponges for more adherent dirt
  • Use microabrasion only when gentler methods are ineffective
• Maintain consistent, controlled pressure during cleaning
  • Avoid creating uneven areas or over-cleaning certain spots
  • Use magnification to monitor surface changes during cleaning
• Employ proper brush techniques for gentle and precise cleaning
  • Use side of brush for broad strokes on larger areas
  • Apply brush tip for detailed work in intricate sections

Tool-Specific Techniques

• Work in circular motions when using erasers to distribute pressure evenly
  • Prevents creation of streaks or lines on artwork surface
  • Regularly knead or slice erasers to maintain clean working surface
• Maintain consistent distance and angle for microabrasion nozzle
  • Typically 1-2 cm from surface at 45-degree angle
  • Ensures uniform cleaning and prevents localized damage
• Regularly inspect tools for wear or debris accumulation
  • Replace brushes with splayed bristles or damaged tips
  • Clean eraser residue from artwork surface to prevent redeposition

Safety Measures

• Implement extraction systems for microabrasion to control dust
  • Use HEPA filtration to capture fine particles
  • Prevent contamination of surrounding environment
• Wear appropriate personal protective equipment during cleaning
  • Gloves to protect artwork from oils and conservator from materials
  • Respirators when working with potentially harmful dusts or particles
• Properly dispose of cleaning waste and used materials
  • Separate hazardous waste (lead-containing dust) for special handling
  • Recycle or reuse materials when possible (cleaned brush bristles)

Effectiveness of Mechanical Cleaning Methods

Evaluation of Cleaning Results

• Compare treated areas to untreated sections to assess improvements
  • Look for enhanced color saturation and surface clarity
  • Ensure cleaning has not altered original surface texture
• Recognize effectiveness for loose, particulate soiling
  • Ideal for removal of dust, soot, and non-adhered dirt
  • May have limitations with ingrained or chemically bonded contaminants
• Document cleaning progress with detailed photography
  • Capture before, during, and after treatment images
  • Use raking light to highlight surface changes

Limitations and Considerations

• Understand potential for over-cleaning or surface abrasion
  • Monitor for loss of original material (pigment, patina)
  • Be aware of changes to artwork's intended appearance or finish
• Consider redistribution of soiling on porous or textured surfaces
  • Dirt may be pushed into crevices rather than fully removed
  • May require combination of mechanical and chemical methods
• Acknowledge limitations in addressing subsurface issues
  • Stains, discoloration, or alterations below surface layer
  • May require more invasive treatments (consolidation, infilling)

Documentation and Future Applications

• Record effectiveness of different methods for various soiling types
  • Note which tools work best for specific materials and conditions
  • Create reference guide for future treatments
• Use findings to inform conservation research and treatment planning
  • Contribute to field knowledge through case studies or publications
  • Refine cleaning protocols based on documented outcomes