12.2 Therapeutic use of drawing media

Drawing media in art therapy offers a diverse toolkit for creative expression and healing. From pencils to digital tools, each medium brings unique properties that can impact a client's emotional response and therapeutic journey.

Understanding these media allows art therapists to tailor interventions to individual needs. The choice between controlled pencils or expressive markers, familiar crayons or sensory oil pastels, can significantly influence the therapeutic process and outcomes for clients of all ages and backgrounds.

Types of drawing media

• Drawing media in art therapy encompasses a wide range of tools used for creative expression and therapeutic interventions
• The choice of media can significantly impact the client's experience, emotional response, and therapeutic outcomes
• Understanding the properties and effects of different drawing media allows art therapists to tailor interventions to individual client needs

Pencils vs markers

Top images from around the web for Pencils vs markers

• 

  Frontiers | Potential diagnostic markers and therapeutic targets for rheumatoid arthritis with ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Shading - Fairconditioning View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Crayola-Markers.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Potential diagnostic markers and therapeutic targets for rheumatoid arthritis with ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Shading - Fairconditioning View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Pencils vs markers

• 

  Frontiers | Potential diagnostic markers and therapeutic targets for rheumatoid arthritis with ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Shading - Fairconditioning View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Crayola-Markers.jpg - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Potential diagnostic markers and therapeutic targets for rheumatoid arthritis with ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Shading - Fairconditioning View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Pencils offer precise control and gradual shading capabilities
  • Graphite pencils range in hardness (9H to 9B) affecting line darkness and texture
  • Colored pencils provide blending options and layering effects
• Markers produce bold, vibrant lines with less control over pressure
  • Water-based markers offer washable properties suitable for younger clients
  • Alcohol-based markers provide rich color saturation and blending capabilities
• Pencils encourage deliberate, thoughtful expression while markers facilitate spontaneous, expressive work

Crayons and oil pastels

• Crayons offer a familiar, non-threatening medium for clients of all ages
  • Wax-based crayons provide smooth application and layering possibilities
  • Available in various sizes to accommodate different grip strengths and motor skills
• Oil pastels blend rich color with a creamy texture for expressive mark-making
  • Can be manipulated with fingers or tools for smudging and blending effects
  • Offer a sensory experience through their soft, malleable consistency
• Both media allow for color mixing and layering techniques to explore emotions and experiences

Charcoal and chalk

• Charcoal produces rich, dark lines and allows for dramatic shading and contrast
  • Vine charcoal creates soft, easily erasable marks for initial sketching
  • Compressed charcoal offers darker, more permanent lines for emphasis
• Chalk pastels provide a powdery texture and vibrant color options
  • Can be blended easily with fingers or tools for smooth gradients
  • Fixative sprays help preserve chalk drawings and prevent smudging
• Both media encourage expressive, gestural movements and can be used for large-scale drawings

Digital drawing tools

• Tablets and styluses offer a wide range of digital drawing capabilities
  • Pressure-sensitive styluses mimic traditional drawing tools' responsiveness
  • Layer functions allow for non-destructive editing and experimentation
• Drawing apps provide diverse brush options and effects
  • Customizable brush settings simulate various traditional media textures
  • Undo and redo functions reduce anxiety about making mistakes
• Digital tools can be particularly engaging for tech-savvy clients or those with physical limitations

Psychological effects of media

Color impact on emotions

• Colors evoke specific emotional responses and associations in clients
  • Warm colors (red, orange, yellow) often stimulate energy and excitement
  • Cool colors (blue, green, purple) typically promote calmness and relaxation
• Color intensity and saturation influence emotional arousal levels
  • Bright, saturated colors may increase emotional intensity
  • Muted or pastel tones can create a more subdued emotional atmosphere
• Personal and cultural associations with colors affect individual responses
  • Red might symbolize love in one culture but danger in another
  • Allowing clients to choose colors can provide insight into their emotional state

Texture and sensory experience

• Different drawing media offer varied tactile sensations
  • Smooth surfaces (markers, colored pencils) may promote feelings of control
  • Rough textures (charcoal, oil pastels) can encourage sensory exploration
• Sensory engagement during art-making activates multiple brain areas
  • Enhances emotional processing and memory recall
  • Can be particularly beneficial for clients with sensory processing issues
• Texture manipulation provides an outlet for non-verbal expression
  • Pressing hard or soft with media can reflect emotional intensity
  • Smudging or blending techniques may represent integration of experiences

Control vs fluidity

• Media characteristics influence the level of control clients experience
  • Pencils and fine-tipped markers offer precise control for detailed work
  • Watercolors and chalk pastels encourage more fluid, spontaneous expression
• The balance between control and fluidity affects therapeutic outcomes
  • High control media may benefit clients seeking structure and containment
  • Fluid media can facilitate emotional release and spontaneity
• Experimenting with different levels of control allows clients to:
  • Explore comfort zones and challenge self-imposed limitations
  • Develop flexibility in emotional expression and problem-solving

Therapeutic applications

Self-expression through drawing

• Drawing provides a non-verbal outlet for emotions and experiences
  • Allows clients to externalize internal thoughts and feelings
  • Creates a tangible representation of abstract concepts or memories
• Encourages exploration of personal symbols and metaphors
  • Clients develop their own visual language for self-expression
  • Repeated symbols or themes can reveal underlying patterns or concerns
• Facilitates self-discovery and increased self-awareness
  • The drawing process can uncover unconscious material
  • Reflecting on completed artwork promotes insight and personal growth

Trauma processing with media

• Art-making offers a safe container for exploring traumatic experiences
  • Allows gradual exposure to traumatic memories through symbolic representation
  • Provides distance from overwhelming emotions through visual metaphors
• Different media properties support various stages of trauma processing
  • Structured media (colored pencils) can help establish safety and control
  • Fluid media (watercolors) may facilitate emotional release and integration
• Sequential art or comic-style drawings can help reconstruct trauma narratives
  • Breaks down overwhelming experiences into manageable segments
  • Allows for reorganization and reframing of traumatic events

Anxiety reduction techniques

• Repetitive drawing actions promote relaxation and mindfulness
  • Mandala creation using various media encourages focused attention
  • Zentangle patterns with fine-tipped markers induce a meditative state
• Color selection and application can influence anxiety levels
  • Cool colors and gentle blending techniques may reduce physiological arousal
  • Gradual transitions from chaotic to ordered compositions can mirror anxiety reduction
• Sensory-based drawing exercises ground clients in the present moment
  • Texture rubbings with crayons engage tactile awareness
  • Scribble drawings with eyes closed emphasize proprioceptive feedback

Client considerations

Age-appropriate media selection

• Developmental stages influence media suitability and effectiveness
  • Young children benefit from large, easy-to-grip tools (chunky crayons, markers)
  • Adolescents may prefer more sophisticated media (fine-tipped pens, digital tools)
• Safety considerations vary across age groups
  • Non-toxic, washable materials are essential for young children
  • Older adults may require adaptations for arthritic hands or vision impairments
• Media complexity should match cognitive and motor skill levels
  • Simple coloring activities for early childhood or cognitively impaired clients
  • Mixed media projects for adults to encourage experimentation and problem-solving

Physical limitations and adaptations

• Mobility issues require thoughtful media and tool modifications
  • Adaptive grips or larger handles improve control for clients with limited dexterity
  • Easels or tilted drawing surfaces accommodate wheelchair users
• Visual impairments necessitate tactile-focused media choices
  • Textured drawing boards and raised line drawing kits enhance sensory feedback
  • High-contrast media (black markers on white paper) benefit low vision clients
• Fatigue and endurance concerns influence session planning
  • Lightweight materials reduce physical strain during extended art-making
  • Alternating between fine motor and gross motor activities prevents overexertion

Cultural sensitivity in choices

• Media selection should respect cultural norms and preferences
  • Some cultures may associate certain colors with specific meanings or taboos
  • Traditional art forms may inform media choices (calligraphy brushes for East Asian clients)
• Consider the symbolic significance of materials in different cultures
  • Natural materials (charcoal, clay) may hold spiritual importance for indigenous clients
  • Synthetic materials might be preferred in more technologically-oriented societies
• Allow for client input in media selection to honor individual cultural backgrounds
  • Offer a diverse range of materials to accommodate various cultural expressions
  • Remain open to incorporating culturally-specific art materials when appropriate

Techniques for different diagnoses

Depression and mood disorders

• Color-based interventions to influence mood states
  • Gradual introduction of vibrant colors to counter depressive symptoms
  • Creating color wheels to explore and express emotional ranges
• Expressive mark-making to release pent-up emotions
  • Large-scale gestural drawings with charcoal or pastels
  • Scribble techniques with various pressures to externalize feelings
• Positive imagery development using mixed media
  • Collage and drawing combinations to visualize hope and future goals
  • Mandala creation focusing on balance and wholeness

Autism spectrum disorders

• Structured drawing activities to support routine and predictability
  • Step-by-step drawing guides using clear, bold lines
  • Template-based projects with opportunities for personalization
• Sensory-focused media exploration to address sensory processing needs
  • Textured drawing surfaces (sandpaper, bubble wrap) with various media
  • Scented markers or crayons to engage multiple senses
• Social skills development through collaborative drawing projects
  • Turn-taking exercises with shared drawing implements
  • Comic strip creation to practice perspective-taking and narrative skills

PTSD and trauma-related issues

• Containment techniques using structured media and formats
  • Creating "safe containers" with colored pencils to symbolize coping resources
  • Drawing series within defined borders to establish control and safety
• Gradual exposure through symbolic representation
  • Using abstract shapes and colors to represent traumatic memories indirectly
  • Progressive detailing of trauma narratives as tolerance increases
• Bilateral stimulation incorporation in drawing exercises
  • Alternating hands while drawing to mimic EMDR techniques
  • Creating mirrored images to engage both brain hemispheres

Integration with other modalities

Drawing with music therapy

• Synchronizing drawing movements with musical rhythms
  • Using different media to represent various instruments or sounds
  • Creating visual scores or graphic notations of musical pieces
• Emotional expression through color and line in response to music
  • Exploring how different genres evoke unique visual responses
  • Translating musical dynamics (crescendo, diminuendo) into visual elements
• Collaborative music-making and drawing experiences
  • Group murals created in response to live or recorded music
  • Turn-taking between musical improvisation and visual art-making

Movement and drawing exercises

• Incorporating gross motor movements into large-scale drawings
  • Full-body gestures with charcoal or pastels on floor-mounted paper
  • Dancing with ribbons dipped in paint to create fluid line drawings
• Mindful drawing practices combined with gentle stretching or yoga
  • Breath-synchronized mark-making to promote relaxation
  • Creating mandalas or labyrinths as walking meditation guides
• Exploring spatial awareness through movement-based drawing games
  • "Simon Says" style directives for drawing specific shapes or lines
  • Mirroring exercises where partners simultaneously draw each other's movements

Verbal therapy and artwork

• Using drawings as prompts for verbal processing and insight
  • Creating visual timelines of life events to structure narrative therapy
  • Developing personal symbols or metaphors to represent complex emotions
• Integrating cognitive-behavioral techniques with art-making
  • Illustrating thought patterns or cognitive distortions
  • Creating visual reminders of coping strategies or positive affirmations
• Enhancing communication through art-based dialogue
  • "Visual conversations" where clients alternate adding to a shared drawing
  • Using artwork to facilitate family or group discussions on specific themes

Assessment through drawing

Formal assessment tools

• Standardized drawing-based assessments provide structured evaluation
  • House-Tree-Person (HTP) test assesses personality and cognitive functioning
  • Kinetic Family Drawing (KFD) reveals family dynamics and relationships
• Scoring systems offer quantitative data for diagnosis and treatment planning
  • Draw-A-Person (DAP) test uses point scales for developmental assessment
  • Formal Elements Art Therapy Scale (FEATS) evaluates 14 specific artistic elements
• Projective drawing techniques uncover unconscious material
  • Wartegg Drawing Completion Test explores personality through abstract stimuli
  • Bridge Drawing Test assesses transitions and life changes symbolically

Informal observation techniques

• Process-oriented observations reveal client's approach to art-making
  • Noting hesitations, erasures, or repeated elements during drawing
  • Observing body language and verbal comments while creating artwork
• Content analysis of completed drawings provides qualitative insights
  • Identifying recurring themes, symbols, or color choices across sessions
  • Examining spatial relationships and proportions within compositions
• Comparative analysis tracks changes in client's artwork over time
  • Documenting shifts in media preferences or drawing styles
  • Noting evolving complexity or emotional expression in sequential pieces

Interpreting client artwork

• Collaborative meaning-making engages clients in the interpretation process
  • Asking open-ended questions about specific elements or overall impressions
  • Encouraging clients to title their artwork and explain their choices
• Contextualizing artwork within the client's personal and cultural background
  • Considering individual symbolism and cultural significance of imagery
  • Relating drawn content to client's presenting issues and life circumstances
• Balancing objective formal analysis with subjective emotional responses
  • Examining line quality, color use, and composition for technical information
  • Exploring therapist's and client's emotional reactions to the artwork

Ethical considerations

Confidentiality and artwork

• Maintaining client privacy in the creation and storage of artwork
  • Ensuring private workspace for art-making during sessions
  • Obtaining informed consent for any display or reproduction of client art
• Balancing documentation needs with confidentiality concerns
  • Using secure digital storage systems for photographed artwork
  • Developing protocols for de-identifying artwork in clinical records
• Addressing confidentiality in group art therapy settings
  • Establishing clear guidelines for sharing and discussing artwork within groups
  • Implementing strategies to protect individual privacy in collaborative projects

Storage and disposal of drawings

• Developing secure storage systems for physical artwork
  • Using locked cabinets or dedicated art storage rooms with restricted access
  • Implementing a cataloging system to track and retrieve client artwork easily
• Establishing clear policies for artwork retention and disposal
  • Defining retention periods based on legal requirements and clinical needs
  • Creating protocols for safe, confidential destruction of artwork when necessary
• Addressing ownership and return of artwork to clients
  • Clarifying artwork ownership policies in informed consent documents
  • Developing procedures for returning or transferring artwork upon termination

Boundaries in art-making process

• Maintaining appropriate therapeutic boundaries during creative activities
  • Avoiding excessive personal disclosure through the therapist's own art-making
  • Establishing clear guidelines for physical touch when assisting with art techniques
• Respecting client autonomy in the creative process
  • Balancing directive interventions with client-led exploration
  • Avoiding imposing personal aesthetic preferences on client artwork
• Addressing potential dual relationships in art-based communities
  • Establishing clear boundaries between therapeutic and social art-making contexts
  • Developing policies for exhibiting or selling client artwork ethically

Group vs individual settings

Collaborative drawing projects

• Designing group art activities to foster cooperation and communication
  • Creating group murals to explore shared themes or goals
  • Implementing exquisite corpse drawing games to encourage turn-taking
• Facilitating interpersonal learning through shared art-making experiences
  • Observing and discussing different approaches to the same drawing prompt
  • Exploring group dynamics through role assignments in collaborative projects
• Addressing challenges in group art-making processes
  • Managing conflicts over shared materials or space
  • Developing strategies for including diverse skill levels and preferences

Sharing artwork in groups

• Establishing a safe, supportive environment for artwork sharing
  • Implementing clear guidelines for respectful feedback and discussion
  • Offering options for anonymous or partial sharing to respect comfort levels
• Utilizing structured sharing formats to enhance therapeutic benefits
  • Incorporating pair-share activities before full group discussions
  • Using gallery walk techniques to allow quiet reflection on multiple artworks
• Addressing potential triggers or conflicts during artwork sharing
  • Preparing clients for emotional responses to others' artwork
  • Developing strategies for containing and processing intense reactions

Individual expression techniques

• Tailoring drawing interventions to address specific individual needs
  • Designing personalized art directives based on treatment goals
  • Adapting media and techniques to suit individual preferences and abilities
• Encouraging self-reflection and insight through individual art-making
  • Implementing visual journaling techniques for ongoing self-exploration
  • Using series work to track personal growth and change over time
• Balancing structure and freedom in individual art therapy sessions
  • Offering choice within defined parameters to support therapeutic focus
  • Gradually increasing complexity of drawing tasks as client progresses

Art therapy room setup

Organization of drawing supplies

• Implementing efficient storage systems for various drawing media
  • Using clear, labeled containers for easy identification of materials
  • Organizing supplies by type, color, or frequency of use for quick access
• Creating designated areas for different drawing activities
  • Setting up separate stations for wet and dry media to prevent contamination
  • Establishing a cleaning area with appropriate materials for each medium
• Ensuring accessibility and safety in supply arrangement
  • Placing frequently used items at easily reachable heights
  • Storing potentially hazardous materials (fixatives, sharp tools) securely

Creating a safe drawing space

• Designing the physical environment to promote psychological safety
  • Using calming colors and natural lighting to reduce anxiety
  • Incorporating soundproofing elements to ensure privacy and reduce distractions
• Arranging furniture to accommodate various drawing positions and group sizes
  • Providing adjustable easels and drawing boards for different working angles
  • Ensuring adequate space between workstations in group settings
• Implementing health and safety measures for art-making activities
  • Installing proper ventilation systems for use with odorous materials
  • Providing personal protective equipment (smocks, gloves) as needed

Accessibility considerations

• Adapting the art therapy space for clients with diverse needs
  • Installing ramps or wider doorways for wheelchair accessibility
  • Using adjustable-height tables to accommodate different mobility levels
• Incorporating assistive technologies and adaptive tools
  • Providing magnifying devices or task lighting for visually impaired clients
  • Offering a range of adaptive grips and extended-reach tools
• Ensuring clear navigation and organization for all clients
  • Using high-contrast labels and tactile markers for supply identification
  • Creating visual schedules or guides for session structure and material use