6.7 Ethical decision-making

Ethical decision-making is a cornerstone of responsible journalism. Reporters must navigate complex dilemmas, balancing truth-telling with source protection, objectivity with accountability, and independence with corporate pressures. These challenges require a strong ethical foundation.

Frameworks like utilitarianism and Kant's Categorical Imperative can guide journalists through tough calls. Strategies like transparency, consultation with colleagues, and ongoing ethics training help build a culture of integrity. Ultimately, ethical journalism is crucial for maintaining public trust and press freedoms.

Ethical principles in journalism

Truth and accuracy

Top images from around the web for Truth and accuracy

• 

  Reinventing Local TV News | Shorenstein Center View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to fact-check - Misinformation, disinformation, malinformation, and fake news - Research ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The 5 Principles of Ethical Journalism – Respect Words View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reinventing Local TV News | Shorenstein Center View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to fact-check - Misinformation, disinformation, malinformation, and fake news - Research ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Truth and accuracy

• 

  Reinventing Local TV News | Shorenstein Center View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to fact-check - Misinformation, disinformation, malinformation, and fake news - Research ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The 5 Principles of Ethical Journalism – Respect Words View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reinventing Local TV News | Shorenstein Center View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to fact-check - Misinformation, disinformation, malinformation, and fake news - Research ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Journalists have a fundamental obligation to seek and report the truth
• Requires thorough fact-checking and verification of information from multiple sources
• Avoiding distortions, exaggerations or misrepresentations of the facts
• Clearly distinguishing between fact and opinion in reporting
• Promptly correcting errors and clarifying ambiguous or misleading statements

Independence from sources

• Maintaining a critical distance and avoiding conflicts of interest that could compromise objectivity
• Not accepting gifts, favors or special treatment that could be perceived as influencing coverage
• Disclosing any unavoidable conflicts to editors and readers
• Refusing to allow sources to dictate terms of reporting or demand favorable coverage
• Resisting pressure to suppress information that may be damaging to sources

Accountability to the public

• Journalists serve as watchdogs and representatives of the public interest
• Have an obligation to hold the powerful accountable and expose wrongdoing
• Involves being responsive to feedback and criticism from readers
• Explaining editorial decisions and processes to the public
• Admitting and correcting mistakes in a forthright manner

Ethical challenges for business journalists

Pressure from corporate interests

• Companies may threaten to withhold access or advertising revenue to influence coverage
• Resisting demands to suppress negative information or hype positive news
• Maintaining skepticism about corporate claims and spin
• Avoiding becoming too cozy with executives or PR representatives

Maintaining objectivity vs advocacy

• Tension between neutral reporting and advocating for certain economic policies or outcomes
• Fairly representing different perspectives on complex issues
• Avoiding ideological bias or partisanship in coverage
• Clearly labeling analysis and commentary as distinct from straight news reporting

Protecting confidential sources

• Honoring promises of anonymity to sources who could face retribution for disclosing information
• Carefully evaluating motives of anonymous sources and corroborating their claims
• Resisting legal demands to reveal identities of confidential sources
• Weighing public interest in disclosure against potential harm to sources

Verifying information from sources

• Ensuring accuracy of technical or arcane financial information
• Independently confirming facts and figures provided by companies
• Pressing sources for documentation to back up claims
• Consulting multiple experts to vet complex information
• Clearly attributing information to sources to maintain transparency

Frameworks for ethical decision-making

Utilitarian vs deontological approaches

• Utilitarian framework focuses on consequences and maximizing benefits for greatest number
• Deontological approach emphasizes moral duties and absolute rules (truthtelling, promise-keeping)
• Both frameworks can help analyze and weigh competing ethical obligations

Kant's Categorical Imperative

• Principle that one should act according to rules that could be universally adopted
• Requires considering whether an action would still be ethical if everyone did it
• Focuses on motives and intentions behind actions rather than just consequences

Aristotle's Golden Mean

• Seeks balance or moderation between extremes of excess and deficiency
• In journalism, could mean balancing skepticism and open-mindedness, detachment and empathy
• Requires practical wisdom to discern appropriate response to each situation

Potter Box model of reasoning

• Systematic framework for analyzing ethical dilemmas
• Considers facts, values, principles and loyalties at stake in a situation
• Helps clarify options and reason through potential courses of action
• Provides structure for discussing and resolving ethical issues as a newsroom

Applying ethical principles in practice

Case studies of ethical dilemmas

• Examining real-world situations where journalists faced difficult choices
• Illustrating how ethical principles and frameworks can guide decision-making
• Sparking discussion of how different journalists might respond to the same situation
• Demonstrating that there are often no clear-cut right or wrong answers

Strategies for resolving conflicts

• Looking for creative compromises or alternative solutions that uphold key principles
• Prioritizing fundamental duties (truthtelling) over competing loyalties (relationships with sources)
• Seeking input from colleagues and editors to gain outside perspectives
• Negotiating with sources or subjects to find mutually agreeable terms

Importance of transparency in process

• Clearly disclosing to readers any factors that might influence reporting
• Explaining how information was obtained and verified
• Acknowledging any limitations or uncertainties in a story
• Inviting feedback and dialogue with readers about editorial decisions

Consulting editors and colleagues

• Utilizing newsroom ethics codes and policies as decision-making resources
• Seeking advice from editors or ethics committees on difficult calls
• Hashing out dilemmas with colleagues to surface considerations and counterarguments
• Developing a culture of open discussion about ethics rather than unilateral decisions

Consequences of unethical reporting

Damage to public trust

• Undermines credibility and reputation of individual journalists and news organizations
• Breeds cynicism and distrust of the media as an institution
• Makes it harder for honest reporting to be believed and have an impact
• Can take years to rebuild trust squandered by ethical lapses

Legal and financial repercussions

• News organizations can face expensive lawsuits for libel, privacy violations, etc.
• Reporters may be fined or jailed for refusing to divulge confidential sources
• Deceptive reporting techniques (misrepresentation, trespassing) can lead to criminal charges
• Ethical breaches can drive away readers, subscribers and advertisers

Impact on journalist's credibility

• Plagiarism, fabrication or other dishonest practices can taint a journalist's reputation
• Reporters may be fired, blacklisted or unable to find work due to ethical violations
• Hard-won professional credibility built up over years can be wiped out by a single lapse
• Unethical conduct makes it easier for critics to dismiss a journalist's legitimate work

Erosion of press freedoms

• Ethical scandals can be used as a pretext for government restrictions on press rights
• Public backlash against "fake news" and media bias can lead to support for curbs on journalists
• Weakening of legal and cultural support for independent, aggressive reporting
• Unethical conduct feeds perception of the press as arrogant and untrustworthy

Building a culture of ethics

Role modeling by senior journalists

• Veteran reporters and editors set the tone by exemplifying high ethical standards
• Demonstrating through their actions how to uphold principles in the face of pressures
• Talking openly about how they have grappled with and resolved ethical dilemmas
• Serving as mentors and sounding boards for younger journalists facing quandaries

Ongoing ethics training and discussion

• Incorporating ethics lessons and case studies into staff training and development
• Regularly revisiting and updating newsroom policies and guidelines
• Encouraging reporters to raise ethical concerns and conundrums with colleagues
• Bringing in outside experts or ethicists for workshops and consultations

Rewarding ethical decision-making

• Praising and promoting journalists who exhibit integrity and moral courage
• Recognizing tough, principled calls even when they result in missed scoops or lost access
• Factoring ethical track record into performance reviews, raises and assignments
• Celebrating examples of exemplary ethical journalism to reinforce values and norms

Importance of diverse newsrooms

• Including journalists of different backgrounds and perspectives to broaden ethical considerations
• Ensuring that a range of voices are heard in newsroom debates over ethics and coverage
• Reducing risk of blind spots or cultural biases in ethical decision-making
• Fostering a culture of questioning assumptions and grappling with complex issues