7.1 Competitive dynamics in business ecosystems

Competitive dynamics in business ecosystems are complex and multifaceted. They involve coopetition, where companies both cooperate and compete, and are influenced by network effects, complementors, and overall ecosystem health.

Ecosystem orchestrators face unique challenges in maintaining their position while fostering growth. Bottlenecks within ecosystems can become sources of competitive advantage, allowing companies to control critical resources and capture outsized value.

Competitive Forces in Ecosystems

Complex Dynamics and Coopetition

Top images from around the web for Complex Dynamics and Coopetition

• 

  Checklist: Your Attitude Towards Diverse Participants - Competendo - Digital Toolbox View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Development through Design in a Creative Ecosystem - HAMK Unlimited View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Effects of Coopetition on Firm Performance and Implications for Economic Growth for SADC Countries View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Checklist: Your Attitude Towards Diverse Participants - Competendo - Digital Toolbox View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Development through Design in a Creative Ecosystem - HAMK Unlimited View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Complex Dynamics and Coopetition

• 

  Checklist: Your Attitude Towards Diverse Participants - Competendo - Digital Toolbox View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Development through Design in a Creative Ecosystem - HAMK Unlimited View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Effects of Coopetition on Firm Performance and Implications for Economic Growth for SADC Countries View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Checklist: Your Attitude Towards Diverse Participants - Competendo - Digital Toolbox View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Development through Design in a Creative Ecosystem - HAMK Unlimited View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Business ecosystems feature multi-directional competitive dynamics extending beyond traditional industry boundaries
• Coopetition characterizes ecosystem competition through simultaneous cooperation and competition between actors
• Network effects and increasing returns to scale create winner-take-all dynamics in digital ecosystems (Facebook, Google)
• Complementors enhance core products or platforms value, playing a crucial role in ecosystem competition (App developers for iOS)
• Overall ecosystem health and diversity impact individual actors' competitiveness
  • Healthy ecosystems attract more participants and resources
  • Diverse ecosystems offer more opportunities for specialization and innovation

Ecosystem Orchestrators and Bottlenecks

• Ecosystem orchestrators (keystone players) face unique competitive pressures
  • Maintain central position while fostering ecosystem growth
  • Balance control with openness to encourage innovation
• Bottleneck positions within ecosystems become sources of competitive advantage
  • Control critical resources or capabilities
  • Enable outsized value capture
  • Examples: Intel's dominance in PC processors, Qualcomm in mobile chipsets

Interdependence and Competition

Shared Fates and Ecosystem Health

• Complementary dependencies between actors create shared fates and aligned incentives
  • Competition against rival ecosystems rather than internal conflicts
  • Success of one actor often benefits others in the ecosystem
• Ecosystem health metrics influence competitive strength of all participants
  • Productivity measures efficiency of value creation
  • Robustness indicates ability to withstand external shocks
  • Niche creation reflects innovation and diversity within the ecosystem
• Success of complementors significantly impacts platform leaders' competitive position
  • Popular apps drive smartphone platform adoption
  • Third-party sellers contribute to e-commerce platform growth

Modularity and Multi-homing

• Modular nature of ecosystems allows rapid reconfiguration of competitive alliances
  • Flexible partnerships and collaborations
  • Ability to adapt to changing market conditions
• Multi-homing complicates competitive dynamics and loyalty
  • Actors participate in multiple competing ecosystems
  • Reduces switching costs for users and complementors
  • Examples: Developers creating apps for both iOS and Android

Interdependencies in Digital Ecosystems

• Data flows and AI capabilities create new competitive dynamics
  • Access to high-quality data becomes a key competitive advantage
  • AI-driven insights enable personalized services and improved efficiency
• Standards and interoperability decisions reshape competitive landscapes
  • Open standards promote ecosystem growth and innovation
  • Proprietary standards can create lock-in effects and competitive barriers

Strategies for Ecosystem Competition

Platform and Niche Strategies

• Platform envelopment leverages existing user base to enter adjacent ecosystem niches
  • Amazon expanding from e-commerce to cloud services (AWS)
  • Google leveraging search dominance to enter browser market (Chrome)
• Ecosystem orchestrators balance value creation and capture for healthy competition
  • Provide incentives for complementors while maintaining profitability
  • Invest in shared infrastructure and development tools
• Niche strategies focus on specializing in specific ecosystem roles
  • Avoid direct competition with dominant players
  • Examples: Shopify focusing on e-commerce tools for small businesses

Bridging and Complementor Strategies

• Bridging strategies connect multiple ecosystems for competitive advantage
  • PayPal linking various e-commerce and financial ecosystems
  • Zapier connecting different software applications and platforms
• Complementor strategies align with and enhance core ecosystem offerings
  • Develop products or services that add value to the platform
  • Build strong relationships with platform leaders
  • Example: Zynga's initial success by creating games for Facebook

Bottleneck and Open Innovation Approaches

• Bottleneck strategies control critical ecosystem chokepoints
  • Exert outsized influence on competitive dynamics
  • Example: ARM's dominance in mobile device chip architecture
• Open innovation and crowdsourcing harness ecosystem-wide resources
  • Leverage external ideas and contributions for competitive advantage
  • Linux operating system development as an open-source project

Power Imbalances in Ecosystems

Keystone Players and Data Control

• Keystone players wield disproportionate power in shaping ecosystem dynamics
  • Influence rules, standards, and competitive landscapes
  • Examples: Apple in mobile app ecosystem, Amazon in e-commerce
• Control over critical data or AI capabilities creates significant power imbalances
  • Access to user data becomes a key competitive advantage
  • AI-driven insights enable more effective decision-making and product development

Intellectual Property and Network Effects

• Intellectual property rights and licensing agreements maintain power dynamics
  • Patents and proprietary technologies create barriers to entry
  • Licensing terms can be used to control ecosystem participants
• Network effects amplify power imbalances
  • Make it difficult for new entrants to challenge established leaders
  • Examples: Social media platforms, operating systems

Regulatory Interventions and Orchestration Power

• Regulatory interventions aim to address power imbalances
  • Promote fair competition within ecosystems
  • Antitrust actions against dominant tech companies
• Ability to orchestrate complementor networks is a significant source of power
  • Influence the direction and growth of the ecosystem
  • Example: Microsoft's relationship with PC manufacturers and software developers
• Bottleneck positions in ecosystem value chain leveraged to exert power
  • Control over key components or distribution channels
  • Example: NVIDIA's strong position in GPU market for AI applications