14.1 Strategy Evaluation Frameworks and Techniques

Strategy evaluation is a crucial process for assessing a company's performance and adapting to change. It involves reviewing current strategies, measuring performance, and taking corrective actions. This process helps businesses stay competitive and achieve their goals in dynamic environments.

Key components of strategy evaluation include internal factors like financial performance and organizational culture, as well as external factors such as industry trends and economic conditions. Various techniques, both quantitative and qualitative, are used to assess strategies and ensure alignment with the company's capabilities and market realities.

Strategy Evaluation Process and Techniques

Components of strategy evaluation

Top images from around the web for Components of strategy evaluation

• 

  Strategic Management | Boundless Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Stages and Types of Strategy | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  External Forces That Shape Business Activities | Introduction to Business View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Strategic Management | Boundless Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Stages and Types of Strategy | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Components of strategy evaluation

• 

  Strategic Management | Boundless Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Stages and Types of Strategy | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  External Forces That Shape Business Activities | Introduction to Business View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Strategic Management | Boundless Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Stages and Types of Strategy | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Strategy evaluation process involves
  • Reviewing current strategy assesses its effectiveness and relevance
  • Measuring performance determines progress towards objectives
  • Taking corrective actions addresses identified issues and gaps
• Key components of strategy evaluation include
  • Internal factors
    • Financial performance measures profitability, liquidity, and efficiency (ROI, current ratio)
    • Non-financial performance assesses customer satisfaction, employee engagement, and operational efficiency
    • Organizational structure and culture impact strategy implementation and adaptability
  • External factors
    • Industry and competitive environment shape opportunities and threats (market trends, competitor actions)
    • Macroeconomic factors influence demand, costs, and overall business conditions (inflation, GDP growth)
    • Technological advancements disrupt industries and create new possibilities (digitalization, AI)
• Steps in the strategy evaluation process include
  1. Establish performance metrics and targets aligned with strategic objectives
  2. Monitor and measure actual performance using quantitative and qualitative data
  3. Compare actual performance with desired performance to identify gaps
  4. Identify gaps and areas for improvement through root cause analysis
  5. Develop and implement corrective actions to address identified issues
  6. Reassess and adjust the strategy as needed based on evolving circumstances

Techniques for strategy assessment

• Quantitative techniques provide objective and measurable insights
  • Financial ratio analysis evaluates
    • Profitability ratios measure return on investments and equity (ROI, ROE, ROCE)
    • Liquidity ratios assess ability to meet short-term obligations (current ratio, quick ratio)
    • Efficiency ratios gauge resource utilization and productivity (inventory turnover, asset turnover)
  • Balanced Scorecard offers a holistic view of performance across four perspectives
    • Financial perspective tracks financial outcomes and value creation
    • Customer perspective measures customer satisfaction, loyalty, and market share
    • Internal business process perspective assesses operational efficiency and innovation
    • Learning and growth perspective evaluates employee skills, culture, and infrastructure
  • Economic Value Added (EVA) measures economic profit and value creation
    • Calculating EVA: $EVA = [NOPAT](https://www.fiveableKeyTerm:NOPAT) - (Invested Capital \times [WACC](https://www.fiveableKeyTerm:WACC))$
    • NOPAT is Net Operating Profit After Tax
    • WACC is Weighted Average Cost of Capital
• Qualitative techniques provide contextual and strategic insights
  • SWOT analysis assesses internal and external factors
    • Strengths and weaknesses are internal factors (brand reputation, cost structure)
    • Opportunities and threats are external factors (untapped markets, regulatory changes)
  • PESTEL analysis examines macro-environmental factors
    • Political factors include government policies, regulations, and political stability
    • Economic factors cover economic growth, interest rates, and exchange rates
    • Social factors encompass demographics, cultural trends, and consumer behavior
    • Technological factors involve technological advancements, R&D, and innovation
    • Environmental factors include climate change, sustainability, and resource scarcity
    • Legal factors cover legal and regulatory frameworks, compliance, and liability risks
  • Porter's Five Forces analysis evaluates industry attractiveness and competitive dynamics
    • Threat of new entrants is influenced by entry barriers and capital requirements
    • Bargaining power of suppliers affects input costs and quality
    • Bargaining power of buyers impacts pricing and profitability
    • Threat of substitutes creates competitive pressure and reduces customer loyalty
    • Industry rivalry intensifies competition and affects profitability

Strategy alignment with environments

• Assessing strategic fit ensures strategy aligns with internal capabilities and external realities
  • Alignment with organizational mission, vision, and values provides direction and purpose
  • Consistency with organizational structure and culture facilitates effective implementation
  • Compatibility with available resources and capabilities ensures feasibility and sustainability
• Evaluating external alignment ensures strategy responds to market dynamics and stakeholder expectations
  • Responsiveness to industry trends and market conditions enables agility and competitiveness
  • Adaptability to changing customer needs and preferences enhances customer satisfaction and loyalty
  • Positioning relative to competitors differentiates the firm and creates competitive advantage
• Identifying misalignments and gaps reveals areas for improvement and potential risks
  • Inconsistencies between strategy and internal factors lead to implementation challenges and underperformance
  • Mismatches between strategy and external environment result in missed opportunities and strategic drift
  • Potential sources of competitive disadvantage erode market position and financial performance

Strategy adjustments from evaluation

• Types of strategic adjustments address different growth and diversification opportunities
  • Market penetration increases market share in existing markets through enhanced marketing and sales efforts
  • Market development enters new markets with existing products (geographic expansion, new customer segments)
  • Product development introduces new products in existing markets to meet evolving customer needs
  • Diversification enters new markets with new products to spread risk and explore synergies
• Factors influencing strategic adjustments include internal and external changes
  • Changes in the competitive landscape require repositioning and differentiation (mergers, new entrants)
  • Shifts in customer preferences and market trends demand product and service innovations
  • Emergence of new technologies or business models disrupts traditional industry dynamics (e-commerce, sharing economy)
  • Identification of untapped opportunities or underserved segments presents growth potential
• Implementing strategic adjustments involves a systematic approach
  • Developing a plan for implementing changes defines objectives, timelines, and responsibilities
  • Allocating resources and aligning organizational structure supports strategy execution
  • Communicating the revised strategy to stakeholders ensures buy-in and coordination
  • Monitoring the effectiveness of the adjustments over time enables continuous improvement and adaptation