7.1 Development and characteristics of Old and New Comedy

Greek comedy evolved from religious festivals honoring Dionysus to structured theatrical productions. It developed alongside tragedy but focused on humorous and satirical themes, incorporating elements of folk traditions and ritual mockery.

The genre transformed from Old Comedy's political satire to New Comedy's domestic situations. This shift reflected changing societal norms, with Old Comedy addressing current events and New Comedy exploring everyday life and relationships.

Greek Comedy: Origins to New Comedy

Origins and Early Development

Top images from around the web for Origins and Early Development

• 

  Sarcophagus representing a Dionysiac Vintage Festival (Getty Museum) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek comedy - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Theatre of Dionysus | The Theatre of Dionysus was a major op… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Sarcophagus representing a Dionysiac Vintage Festival (Getty Museum) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek comedy - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Origins and Early Development

• 

  Sarcophagus representing a Dionysiac Vintage Festival (Getty Museum) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek comedy - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Theatre of Dionysus | The Theatre of Dionysus was a major op… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Sarcophagus representing a Dionysiac Vintage Festival (Getty Museum) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek comedy - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Greek comedy originated from religious festivals honoring Dionysus (rural Dionysia and Lenaia)
• Emerged as part of worship rituals dedicated to the god of wine and revelry
• Evolved from informal, improvised performances to structured theatrical productions
• Incorporated elements of folk traditions, such as phallic processions and ritual mockery
• Developed alongside tragedy but focused on humorous and satirical themes

Evolution of Comedy Forms

• Old Comedy (5th century BCE)
  • Prominent representative: Aristophanes
  • Characterized by political satire and fantastical plots
  • Featured larger-than-life protagonists and direct audience address
• Middle Comedy (early to mid-4th century BCE)
  • Transitional phase between Old and New Comedy
  • Shifted away from overt political commentary
  • Focused on more general social issues and literary parody
• New Comedy (late 4th century BCE)
  • Notable playwright: Menander
  • Emphasized domestic situations and stock characters
  • Adopted a more realistic approach to storytelling

Structural Changes

• Parabasis and agon central to Old Comedy structure
  • Parabasis allowed direct address to the audience
  • Agon featured verbal sparring between characters
• New Comedy adopted a five-act structure
  • More plot-driven and focused on character development
  • Reduced emphasis on choral interludes
• Chorus role diminished over time
  • Old Comedy: Chorus integral to the plot and commentary
  • Middle Comedy: Reduced chorus involvement
  • New Comedy: Chorus became largely ornamental, performing between acts

Old Comedy vs New Comedy

Thematic Focus

• Old Comedy
  • Addressed topical political issues and current events
  • Employed personal invective against public figures (Cleon)
  • Incorporated fantastical elements and mythological parodies (Aristophanes' "The Birds")
• New Comedy
  • Explored domestic issues and everyday life situations
  • Focused on romantic entanglements and family conflicts
  • Presented more realistic plots and relatable scenarios (Menander's "Dyskolos")

Character Portrayal

• Old Comedy characters
  • Often caricatures of public figures or embodiments of ideas
  • Exaggerated personalities for comedic effect
  • Included allegorical representations of abstract concepts (Aristophanes' "The Clouds")
• New Comedy characters
  • Introduced stock character types
  • Featured recognizable figures such as the stern father, clever slave, and young lovers
  • Developed more nuanced and psychologically complex characters

Language and Style

• Old Comedy language
  • Employed crude and vulgar expressions
  • Incorporated puns, wordplay, and obscenities
  • Used exaggerated and satirical dialogue
• New Comedy language
  • Adopted a more refined and naturalistic style
  • Focused on realistic conversations and character interactions
  • Reduced use of explicit language and vulgar humor

Structural Elements

• Old Comedy structure
  • Extensive use of chorus interacting with main characters
  • Included parabasis for direct audience address
  • Featured agon (debate) scenes between characters
• New Comedy structure
  • Reduced chorus role to interludes between acts
  • Eliminated parabasis
  • Emphasized dialogue and character-driven plot development

Comedy in Ancient Greek Society

Social Commentary and Critique

• Comedy served as a platform for social commentary
• Playwrights critiqued political leaders, institutions, and societal norms
• Old Comedy utilized parrhesia (freedom of speech) to mock powerful individuals
• Addressed contemporary issues such as war, education, and philosophy
• New Comedy reflected changing social dynamics in Hellenistic society

Political Engagement

• Comedy shaped public opinion and political discourse
• Aristophanes addressed issues like the Peloponnesian War ("Lysistrata")
• Reflected changing political realities from Athenian democracy to Hellenistic period
• Provided a sanctioned outlet for expressing dissent and challenging authority
• Contributed to the democratic process by encouraging critical thinking

Cultural Significance

• Comic performances reinforced Athenian cultural identity
• Showcased intellectual and artistic achievements during religious festivals
• Attracted both citizens and foreign visitors, enhancing Athens' reputation
• Preserved in written form, influencing later Roman comedy and European theatrical traditions
• Provided insights into ancient Greek society, values, and daily life for modern scholars

Psychological and Social Functions

• Served as a "safety valve" for social tensions
• Allowed audiences to confront societal issues through humor
• Provided catharsis by addressing taboo subjects and challenging norms
• Fostered a sense of community through shared laughter and experiences
• Reflected and influenced social attitudes towards gender, class, and politics