7.1 Primacy and recency effects

Memory plays tricks on us. We tend to remember the first and last things better than stuff in the middle. This is called primacy and recency effects. They can mess with our decision-making without us even realizing it.

These effects pop up everywhere in business. From hiring to marketing to negotiations, they shape how we process info and make choices. Knowing about them helps us make fairer, more balanced decisions.

Primacy and Recency Effects in Memory

Defining Primacy and Recency Effects

Top images from around the web for Defining Primacy and Recency Effects

• 

  Cognitive Biases - Sensemaking Resources, Education, and Community View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Raconteur – Cognitive Bias View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How Memory Functions | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Cognitive Biases - Sensemaking Resources, Education, and Community View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Raconteur – Cognitive Bias View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Defining Primacy and Recency Effects

• 

  Cognitive Biases - Sensemaking Resources, Education, and Community View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Raconteur – Cognitive Bias View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How Memory Functions | Introduction to Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Cognitive Biases - Sensemaking Resources, Education, and Community View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Raconteur – Cognitive Bias View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Primacy effect refers to the tendency to remember information presented at the beginning of a list or series better than information in the middle
  • Increased rehearsal and transfer of early items into long-term memory leads to stronger encoding and retention of this initial information
  • Examples of primacy effect: remembering the first few items on a grocery list, recalling the first speaker in a conference lineup
• Recency effect is the tendency to remember information presented at the end of a list or series better than information in the middle
  • Items at the end of a sequence are still held in short-term memory, making them more easily accessible for immediate recall
  • Examples of recency effect: remembering the last few errands you need to run, recalling the final scenes of a movie most vividly
• The serial position effect is the combination of the primacy and recency effects, leading to better recall for items at the beginning and end of a list compared to the middle
  • When recall performance is plotted on a graph, this creates a distinctive U-shaped pattern demonstrating the memory advantages for early and late information
  • Example: In a memory test for a list of 20 words, people typically remember words 1-4 (primacy) and 16-20 (recency) better than the middle words

Factors Influencing Primacy and Recency Effects

• Primacy and recency effects are most pronounced with longer lists of information and when there is a delay between information presentation and recall
  • Longer lists provide more opportunity for primacy and recency effects to manifest as middle items become less distinct
  • Delay between encoding and retrieval allows short-term memory to decay, amplifying the recency effect as later items are lost
• Primacy and recency effects occur in a variety of contexts beyond list learning, such as memory for people, events, or ideas encountered first or most recently in a sequence
  • Primacy effect in impression formation: initial interactions with a new colleague or acquaintance are disproportionately influential
  • Recency effect in current events: the latest news stories are more readily remembered and discussed than earlier developments
• Individual differences in working memory capacity, attention, and information processing strategies can moderate susceptibility to primacy and recency effects
  • People with greater working memory capacity may be less prone to recency effects as they can hold more information in short-term storage
  • Attentional resources dedicated to rehearsing early or late information can accentuate primacy or recency effects

Primacy and Recency Effects in Business

Impacts on Human Resources and Hiring

• In hiring decisions, primacy effect can lead to favoring the first few candidates interviewed, while recency effect biases towards the last few, rather than objectively comparing all candidates
  • Hiring managers may form strong positive impressions of early interviewees and use those as a benchmark for evaluating later applicants
  • Final candidates interviewed may stand out more in memory when it comes time to make a hiring decision
• Performance appraisals or reviews may be skewed by primacy and recency effects if managers focus too heavily on early or late examples of performance instead of the entire evaluation period
  • Primacy effect: An employee's performance in the first few weeks or months on the job may color perceptions of their later performance
  • Recency effect: More recent instances of an employee's successes or failures may carry undue weight compared to their overall body of work

Influences on Investment and Strategic Decisions

• When evaluating a series of investment opportunities or project proposals, primacy and recency effects may lead to disproportionate weighing of the first and last options presented instead of thorough consideration of all choices
  • Venture capitalists may be overly intrigued by the first startup pitch of the day and mentally compare all others to that initial presentation
  • Recency effect may lead to impulsive investment in a stock or company that has recently been in the news or recommended by others
• In strategic planning or brainstorming sessions, the first few ideas generated often become anchors that shape subsequent discussion, while the last few ideas presented may be remembered as the "final options" for consideration
  • Primacy effect: Initial strategic proposals may be given more credence and analysis than later alternatives
  • Recency effect: The strategic options discussed in the latter part of the meeting may dominate post-meeting reflections and decision making

Effects on Marketing, Sales, and Consumer Behavior

• In consumer behavior, primacy effect suggests that initial information or impressions about a product or brand are more influential, while recency effect points to the importance of the most recent messaging or interactions
  • Primacy effect in brand perceptions: A customer's first experience with a brand (product quality, customer service) shapes their long-term attitudes
  • Recency effect in purchasing decisions: Point-of-sale displays or promotions can sway consumers' choices at the critical moment before buying
• The timing and sequence of marketing and advertising strategies can leverage primacy and recency effects to maximize impact and memorability
  • Primacy effect: Key product messages or brand slogans presented early in an advertisement are more likely to be remembered and influence purchasing
  • Recency effect: The final scenes or taglines of a commercial can leave a lasting impression as the ad concludes
• In sales presentations or pitches, primacy effects suggest leading with the most attention-grabbing information, while recency effects emphasize ending on a powerful or memorable note
  • Starting a sales presentation with an impactful customer story or statistic can leverage the primacy effect to engage the audience
  • Finishing a product pitch by restating the key benefits or value proposition taps into recency effect to leave a favorable final impression

Implications for Negotiations and Contracts

• Primacy effects in contract or negotiation discussions can lead to anchoring on early positions or terms, making subsequent movement from those reference points more difficult
  • In a salary negotiation, the first compensation figure proposed (either by the employer or candidate) becomes a powerful psychological anchor
  • Early demands or concessions in a business deal negotiation can constrain the range of acceptable outcomes and limit creative problem-solving
• Recency effects may lead to last-minute changes or concessions carrying more weight in the final agreement than is objectively warranted
  • A counterpart's final offer just before signing a contract may be viewed more favorably due to recency effect, even if it is not significantly different from prior proposals
  • Concessions or demands made in the last stages of a negotiation may be more readily accepted to achieve closure, even if they create imbalance in the agreement

Mitigating Primacy and Recency Effects

Awareness and Training

• Awareness of primacy and recency effects is an important first step in consciously correcting for their influence
  • Simply knowing that we have a cognitive tendency to overweight early and late information can help us mentally adjust our judgments
  • Encouraging team members to call out potential primacy or recency effects during discussions can lead to more balanced evaluation
• Training and reminders can help decision makers be more cognizant of how these biases may be impacting their judgement
  • Incorporating information about primacy and recency effects into employee onboarding or professional development programs raises awareness
  • Posting visual reminders or checklists about cognitive biases in meeting rooms or decision-making spaces cues more deliberate reasoning

Structured Evaluation Processes

• Using structured evaluation criteria or rubrics ensures thorough and consistent assessment of all information, options, or individuals in a decision context
  • Developing a standardized set of criteria for hiring, investment, or strategic decisions reduces the influence of presentation order
  • Scoring each option or candidate on the same set of predetermined metrics guards against over-reliance on initial or final inputs
• Taking notes and reviewing all information before making a decision can counteract the outsized influence of primacy and recency effects by re-exposing decision makers to the full scope of relevant data
  • Keeping a record of key points from a meeting or interview series ensures that middle information is not neglected
  • Carefully reviewing notes and materials before rendering a final judgment refreshes memory for the entirety of the information presented

Timing and Sequence Strategies

• When possible, making decisions after a time delay instead of immediately after information is presented can minimize recency effects by allowing all information to be transferred into long-term memory
  • "Sleeping on it" or taking time to reflect on a decision can create psychological distance and reduce the recency advantage of the last inputs received
  • Imposing a waiting period between information gathering (interviews, pitches) and final choices is a structural way to enforce decision delays
• Presenting the most important information first and last when the sequence of information delivery is controllable, sandwiching less critical details in the middle
  • In a sales presentation, leading with the most compelling value propositions and ending with a strong call to action leverages primacy and recency effects
  • When sharing project updates, highlighting key accomplishments and next steps at the beginning and end increases the likelihood they will be remembered

Group Decision-Making Techniques

• Assigning different team members to focus on and advocate for different sets of information or options ensures more balanced consideration and discussion, mitigating the tendency to focus mostly on early or late inputs
  • Giving each person in a hiring committee responsibility for evaluating a subset of candidates encourages deeper engagement with all applicants
  • Rotating which team member presents first or last in a meeting counteracts the disproportionate influence of those positions
• Explicitly designating a "devil's advocate" role to question initial preferences or last-minute suggestions introduces more critical thinking and guards against primacy and recency effects
  • Assigning someone to argue against the first proposed strategy challenges the anchoring effects of early inputs
  • Having a team member voice potential objections to a decision reached at the end of a meeting reduces the undue influence of recency
• Collecting input independently from all group members before a collective discussion begins establishes a broader foundation of ideas and diminishes primacy and recency effects
  • Gathering written feedback or recommendations from all participants before a decision-making meeting ensures a wider range of perspectives are considered
  • Conducting anonymous polling or voting at the beginning and end of a discussion can reveal how opinions are shaped by primacy and recency effects