9.2 First-mover advantages and disadvantages

First-mover advantages can be a game-changer in competitive strategy. Companies that pioneer new markets often gain brand recognition, shape customer preferences, and establish dominant market share. These advantages stem from switching costs, economies of scale, and preferential access to resources.

However, being first isn't always best. Pioneers face risks like high costs, uncertain demand, and vulnerability to imitation. The sustainability of first-mover advantages depends on industry factors and a firm's ability to innovate and scale. Sometimes, being a fast follower can be more advantageous.

First-mover advantage

Benefits of pioneering new markets

Top images from around the web for Benefits of pioneering new markets

• 

  Reading: Buying-Process Stages | Principles of Marketing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Strategic Opportunity Matrix | Principles of Marketing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Putting It Together: Marketing Function | Principles of Marketing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Buying-Process Stages | Principles of Marketing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Strategic Opportunity Matrix | Principles of Marketing View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Benefits of pioneering new markets

• 

  Reading: Buying-Process Stages | Principles of Marketing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Strategic Opportunity Matrix | Principles of Marketing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Putting It Together: Marketing Function | Principles of Marketing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Buying-Process Stages | Principles of Marketing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Strategic Opportunity Matrix | Principles of Marketing View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Gain brand recognition and loyalty by being the first to offer a product or service in a new market
• Shape customer preferences and expectations before competitors enter the market
• Establish a dominant market share position that is difficult for later entrants to overcome
• Potential to set industry standards that become widely adopted

Sources of first-mover advantage

• Benefit from switching costs that make it inconvenient or expensive for customers to change to a competitor's product (enterprise software, banking)
• Achieve economies of scale faster than competitors by rapidly growing market share and production volume
• Secure preferential access to scarce resources (prime retail locations) or key distribution channels (exclusive partnerships with suppliers or retailers)
• Develop proprietary technology or accumulate valuable experience and know-how ahead of rivals

Sustainable competitive advantages

Industry characteristics favoring durable first-mover advantages

• High barriers to entry, such as significant upfront capital investment, proprietary technology, or regulatory hurdles deter new entrants
• Strong network effects, where the value of a product or service increases as more people use it (social media platforms, operating systems) create a self-reinforcing advantage
• High customer switching costs, such as the need to retrain employees or migrate data, make it difficult for customers to switch to competitors (enterprise software, banking)
• Exclusive partnerships, contracts, or intellectual property rights limit competitors' ability to replicate the first-mover's offering

Firm-specific factors influencing sustainability of first-mover advantages

• Strength of the pioneering firm's brand reputation, financial resources, or managerial talent relative to potential competitors
• Continuous innovation and improvement of the first-mover's product or service to stay ahead of imitators
• Effective use of patents, trademarks, or other legal protections to prevent copying by rivals
• Ability to rapidly scale up production and distribution to meet growing demand and deter competitive entry

Risks of first-mover strategy

Costs and uncertainties of pioneering a new market

• Bear the expense and effort of educating customers, establishing distribution channels, and navigating regulatory uncertainties
• Risk of investing in the wrong technology or product features that do not align with evolving customer needs or preferences
• Vulnerability to learning and imitation by later entrants who can copy or improve upon the first-mover's products or business model without incurring the same upfront costs
• Potential backlash from established players in adjacent industries who feel threatened by the first-mover's new offering

Challenges in sustaining first-mover advantages

• Rapid erosion of initial lead in fast-moving, technologically dynamic industries (consumer electronics, software) due to rapid innovation and imitation by competitors
• Difficulty in adapting to changing customer preferences or competitive landscape due to inertia or overinvestment in initial product or strategy
• Risk of being overtaken by fast followers with superior execution or resources, as being first to market does not guarantee long-term success
• Challenge of maintaining a culture of innovation and risk-taking as the pioneering firm grows and matures

First-mover advantages vs disadvantages

Industry factors influencing trade-offs

• Duration of product lifecycles and rate of technological change, with longer lifecycles and slower change favoring first-movers (pharmaceuticals, aerospace) and shorter lifecycles and rapid change favoring fast followers (consumer electronics, software)
• Importance of brand loyalty and switching costs in the industry, with higher loyalty and costs favoring first-movers (luxury goods, enterprise software) and lower loyalty and costs favoring later entrants (commodities, consumer packaged goods)
• Extent of network effects and winner-take-all dynamics in the industry, with stronger effects favoring first-movers (social media, operating systems) and weaker effects allowing room for multiple competitors (restaurants, apparel)

Strategic considerations for timing of entry

• Entering too early before the market is ready or the technology is proven can lead to high upfront costs and slow initial growth
• Entering too late after competitors have established a foothold can make it difficult to differentiate and attract customers
• Optimal timing of entry depends on the firm's resources and capabilities relative to competitors, as well as its tolerance for risk and uncertainty
• In some cases, being a fast follower may be preferable to being a first-mover, allowing the firm to learn from the pioneer's mistakes and capitalize on market education and infrastructure development funded by the first-mover