11.1 CAD data exchange formats

CAD data exchange formats are crucial for sharing designs between different software systems. They come in two main types: neutral formats like IGES and STEP, which work across platforms, and native formats specific to each CAD program.

Choosing the right format depends on your collaboration needs. Neutral formats are great for working with different CAD systems, while native formats preserve more details when using the same software. It's all about balancing compatibility with data preservation.

CAD Data Exchange Formats

Common Formats and Their Characteristics

Top images from around the web for Common Formats and Their Characteristics

• 

  図形要素 と その変換 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  data exchange formats | BIM arabia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Altium's PCB Design Sharing & Visualization Tool helps to view popular CAD formats in your ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  図形要素 と その変換 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  data exchange formats | BIM arabia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Common Formats and Their Characteristics

• 

  図形要素 と その変換 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  data exchange formats | BIM arabia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Altium's PCB Design Sharing & Visualization Tool helps to view popular CAD formats in your ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  図形要素 と その変換 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  data exchange formats | BIM arabia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• CAD data exchange formats are file types used to transfer design data between different CAD systems or applications
• IGES (Initial Graphics Exchange Specification) is a neutral file format that supports the exchange of 2D and 3D geometry, annotations, and product manufacturing information (PMI) between CAD systems
• STEP (Standard for the Exchange of Product Model Data) is an ISO standard format that enables the exchange of 3D geometry, topology, and product data across different CAD platforms and throughout the product lifecycle
• DXF (Drawing Exchange Format) is a file format developed by Autodesk for exchanging 2D and 3D design data, primarily between AutoCAD and other CAD applications
• Native CAD formats are proprietary file types specific to individual CAD software, such as AutoCAD's DWG, SolidWorks' SLDPRT and SLDASM, or CATIA's CATPart and CATProduct
  • Native formats often preserve more data and features compared to neutral formats (IGES, STEP)

Neutral vs Native Formats

• Neutral formats (IGES, STEP) are generally more suitable for collaboration between different CAD systems
  • They provide a common language for exchanging data between various platforms
  • Neutral formats may not preserve all design intent, parametric features, or complex surfaces
• Native formats are ideal for collaboration within the same CAD platform
  • They preserve the most data, features, and design intent specific to the originating CAD system
  • Native formats require the recipient to have the same CAD software and version, which can hinder collaboration between different organizations or departments

Advantages vs Limitations of CAD Data Exchange

Advantages of Different Formats

• IGES advantages: widely supported by CAD systems, suitable for exchanging 2D and 3D geometry, and can include annotations and PMI
• STEP advantages: robust support for 3D geometry, topology, and product data; maintains design intent and associativity; and is an international standard
• DXF advantages: widely supported, especially for 2D data exchange, and maintains basic geometry and annotations
• Native format advantages: preserves the most data, features, and design intent specific to the originating CAD system

Limitations of Different Formats

• IGES limitations: may not preserve all design intent, parametric features, or complex surfaces
• STEP limitations: complex implementation and may require additional configuration for optimal data exchange
• DXF limitations: limited support for 3D geometry, lacks the ability to preserve parametric features and design intent
• Native format limitations: requires the recipient to have the same CAD software and version, which can hinder collaboration between different organizations or departments

Choosing CAD Data Exchange Formats

Considerations for Selecting Formats

• Consider the capabilities and limitations of each partner's CAD systems when selecting the appropriate data exchange format
  • Ensure that the chosen format is compatible with both the sending and receiving systems
• Evaluate the complexity of the design data and the level of design intent and associativity required
  • Use neutral formats (IGES, STEP) for collaborations involving different CAD platforms and complex 3D geometry
  • Employ native formats for collaborations within the same organization or using the same CAD software
• Assess the specific requirements of the collaboration scenario, such as the need for 2D or 3D data, annotations, or product manufacturing information (PMI)

Recommended Formats for Various Scenarios

• Use IGES when collaborating with partners using different CAD systems and primarily need to exchange 2D or basic 3D geometry, annotations, and PMI
• Choose STEP for collaborations involving complex 3D geometry, topology, and product data that require maintaining design intent and associativity across different CAD platforms
• Employ DXF when collaborating on 2D design data or with partners using AutoCAD or other Autodesk products
• Utilize native formats when collaborating within the same organization or with partners using the same CAD software and version, ensuring the preservation of all design data, features, and intent

Troubleshooting CAD Data Exchange Issues

Common Problems and Their Causes

• Missing or distorted geometry, loss of design intent or parametric features, and issues with annotations or product data when exchanging CAD files between systems
  • These problems may arise due to incompatibilities between CAD systems, outdated format versions, or incorrect export settings
• Incomplete or inaccurate exported CAD data
  • This can occur when the model is not properly prepared for export or when certain features or data are not supported by the chosen exchange format

Strategies for Resolving Issues

• Verify that the chosen exchange format is compatible with the sending and receiving CAD systems and that both systems are using the latest format versions and translators
• Ensure that the exported CAD data is complete and accurate by carefully reviewing and comparing the original and exchanged files, checking for any discrepancies or missing information
• Optimize CAD models for data exchange by simplifying complex geometry, removing unnecessary features or data, and organizing the model structure to facilitate better translation between systems
  • This may involve suppressing or removing detailed features (small holes, fillets) or breaking the model into smaller, more manageable components
• Establish clear communication and guidelines with collaboration partners regarding CAD data exchange requirements, preferred formats, and any specific settings or procedures to minimize compatibility issues
• Utilize CAD data translation and validation tools, such as CAD interoperability software (Datakit CrossCAD, TransMagic) or built-in checkers, to identify and resolve issues related to data exchange and ensure the integrity of the transferred design data