3.1 Overexploitation of Plant and Animal Species

Overexploitation of plants and animals is a major threat to biodiversity. It occurs when species are harvested faster than they can reproduce, driven by factors like commercial demand, technology, and weak regulations. This unsustainable use can lead to population declines, extinctions, and ecosystem disruptions.

The consequences of overexploitation are far-reaching. Ecologically, it can cause trophic cascades and alter entire ecosystems. Evolutionarily, it can change species' traits and genetic makeup. Historical examples like whaling and contemporary issues like ivory poaching highlight the ongoing challenges of sustainable resource use.

Overexploitation in Conservation Biology

Definition and Causes

Top images from around the web for Definition and Causes

• 

  Threats to Biodiversity | Boundless Biology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Over-harvesting - Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  NRM Report Cards Threatened Plants and animals View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Threats to Biodiversity | Boundless Biology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Over-harvesting - Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Definition and Causes

• 

  Threats to Biodiversity | Boundless Biology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Over-harvesting - Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  NRM Report Cards Threatened Plants and animals View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Threats to Biodiversity | Boundless Biology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Over-harvesting - Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Overexploitation involves unsustainable harvesting of plant and animal species at rates exceeding natural regeneration or reproduction capacity
• Commercial exploitation, subsistence use, recreational activities, and illegal wildlife trade drive overexploitation
• Economic factors like market demand and profit incentives contribute to overexploitation of valuable species
• Technological advancements in harvesting methods increase exploitation efficiency and scale, potentially leading to overexploitation
• Ineffective regulations, inadequate enforcement, and poor governance allow overexploitation to persist
• Cultural practices, traditional medicine, and luxury goods markets fuel overexploitation of specific species (rhino horn, shark fins)
• Population growth and increasing per capita consumption intensify pressures on natural resources
  • Rising global population increases demand for food, materials, and energy
  • Changing consumption patterns in developing countries contribute to resource depletion

Drivers and Mechanisms

• Market forces shape exploitation patterns
  • High prices for rare species incentivize overexploitation (bluefin tuna)
  • Globalization expands markets for exploited resources
• Technological advancements enable more efficient resource extraction
  • Improved fishing gear allows access to previously unexploited fish stocks
  • Remote sensing technologies aid in locating valuable timber species
• Lack of property rights or open-access resources lead to "tragedy of the commons" scenarios
  • Individuals maximize short-term gains at the expense of long-term sustainability
  • Example: Overgrazing of communal grasslands
• Political and economic instability can drive overexploitation as a survival strategy
  • Poverty and lack of alternatives push communities towards unsustainable resource use
  • Weak governance enables illegal exploitation activities

Consequences of Overexploitation

Ecological Impacts

• Population decline, local extinctions, and potential species-wide extinctions result from overexploitation
• Selective harvesting of desirable traits alters genetic composition of populations
  • Reduces genetic diversity and adaptive capacity
  • Example: Trophy hunting selecting for smaller horns in bighorn sheep
• Disruption of population structure impacts mating systems, social structures, and reproductive success
  • Removal of mature individuals can skew age ratios
  • Loss of experienced individuals affects group dynamics (elephant herds)
• Trophic cascades alter ecosystem dynamics through removal of key species or functional groups
  • Overfishing of top predators can lead to population explosions of their prey
  • Example: Sea otter decline leading to sea urchin overabundance and kelp forest destruction
• Keystone species overexploitation disproportionately affects ecosystem structure and biodiversity
  • Removal of ecosystem engineers like beavers alters habitat characteristics
  • Loss of pollinators impacts plant reproduction and ecosystem functioning

Evolutionary Consequences

• Evolutionary responses to overexploitation include changes in life history traits
  • Earlier maturation in heavily fished populations
  • Smaller body sizes in hunted populations (elephants with smaller tusks)
• Selective pressure from exploitation can lead to rapid evolutionary changes
  • Increased prevalence of cryptic coloration in hunted species
  • Changes in behavior to avoid detection or capture
• Genetic bottlenecks caused by severe population reductions
  • Loss of genetic diversity limits adaptive potential
  • Inbreeding depression in small populations
• Disruption of natural selection processes
  • Artificial selection through human exploitation may counteract natural adaptations
  • Example: Harvesting of largest individuals in a population

Examples of Overexploitation

Historical Cases

• Near-extinction of whales in 19th and 20th centuries due to commercial whaling
  • Decimated populations of multiple whale species (blue whales, right whales)
  • Altered marine ecosystem dynamics and nutrient cycling
• Passenger pigeon extinction in North America
  • Rapid decline from billions to extinction in less than a century
  • Demonstrates vulnerability of even abundant species to overexploitation
• North Atlantic cod fishery collapse
  • Overfishing led to economic and ecological devastation
  • Failure of traditional management approaches to prevent collapse
• American bison near-extinction
  • Population reduced from millions to a few hundred individuals
  • Impacted Native American cultures and prairie ecosystems

Contemporary Examples

• Illegal trade in ivory and rhino horn threatens charismatic megafauna
  • Elephant populations in decline across Africa
  • Near-extinction of multiple rhino species and subspecies
• Unsustainable logging practices in tropical rainforests
  • Targets valuable hardwood species (mahogany, rosewood)
  • Impacts associated biodiversity and ecosystem services
• Overharvesting of medicinal plants
  • American ginseng populations declining in wild
  • Traditional Chinese medicine driving exploitation of numerous species
• Bushmeat hunting in Africa and Asia
  • Threatens primate populations and other wildlife
  • Potential vector for zoonotic disease transmission
• Shark finning for shark fin soup
  • Decimating shark populations globally
  • Disrupting marine food webs and ecosystem balance

Sustainable Management for Overexploitation

Regulatory and Policy Approaches

• Implementing science-based quotas and harvest limits ensures sustainable resource use
  • Total Allowable Catch (TAC) in fisheries management
  • Sustainable yield calculations for timber harvesting
• Establishing protected areas and no-take zones safeguards critical habitats
  • Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) allow fish populations to recover
  • National parks and reserves protect terrestrial species and ecosystems
• Developing and enforcing international agreements regulates trade in endangered species
  • CITES (Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species)
  • Moratoriums on commercial whaling through International Whaling Commission
• Ecosystem-based management approaches consider broader ecological context
  • Integrated coastal zone management
  • Landscape-level conservation planning

Community and Market-Based Solutions

• Promoting alternative livelihoods reduces dependence on exploited species
  • Ecotourism as an alternative to hunting or logging
  • Sustainable agriculture practices to reduce pressure on wild resources
• Implementing certification schemes and eco-labeling promotes sustainable practices
  • Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certification for timber products
  • Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) certification for sustainable fisheries
• Engaging in public education and awareness campaigns reduces demand
  • Campaigns against shark fin soup consumption
  • Promoting alternatives to traditional medicine using endangered species
• Community-based natural resource management empowers local stewardship
  • Communal conservancies in Namibia for wildlife management
  • Indigenous protected areas in Australia