12.1 Key performance indicators (KPIs) and benchmarking

Key performance indicators (KPIs) and benchmarking are crucial tools for measuring and improving sustainability performance. They help companies track progress, compare themselves to peers, and set meaningful targets across environmental, social, and governance areas.

However, KPIs alone can't capture the full complexity of sustainability. Companies must consider qualitative factors, long-term impacts, and stakeholder perspectives to get a complete picture. Effective sustainability assessment requires both quantitative metrics and broader context.

Common Sustainability KPIs

Environmental KPIs

Top images from around the web for Environmental KPIs

• 

  How to mitigate climate change: Key facts from the U.N.'s 2014 report - Journalist's Resource View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to mitigate climate change: Key facts from the U.N.'s 2014 report - Journalist's Resource View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

Top images from around the web for Environmental KPIs

• 

  How to mitigate climate change: Key facts from the U.N.'s 2014 report - Journalist's Resource View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to mitigate climate change: Key facts from the U.N.'s 2014 report - Journalist's Resource View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

• Measure a company's impact on the natural environment
  • Greenhouse gas emissions (carbon dioxide, methane)
  • Energy consumption (electricity, fuel)
  • Water usage (freshwater withdrawal, wastewater discharge)
  • Waste generation (solid waste, hazardous waste)
  • Recycling rates (materials recycled, waste diverted from landfills)

Social KPIs

• Assess a company's impact on its employees, customers, and communities
  • Employee diversity (gender, ethnicity, age)
  • Customer satisfaction (net promoter score, customer retention)
  • Community investment (charitable donations, volunteer hours)
  • Human rights compliance (supplier audits, grievance mechanisms)
  • Workplace safety (injury rates, lost time incidents)

Governance KPIs

• Evaluate the effectiveness of a company's management and decision-making processes
  • Board diversity (gender, ethnicity, skills)
  • Executive compensation (pay ratios, incentive structures)
  • Business ethics (code of conduct, anti-corruption policies)
  • Transparency (sustainability reporting, stakeholder engagement)
  • Risk management (climate risk assessment, supply chain resilience)

Economic KPIs

• Measure a company's financial performance and long-term viability
  • Revenue growth (year-over-year change, market share)
  • Profitability (net income, operating margin)
  • Return on investment (ROI, return on assets)
  • Economic value distributed (employee wages, taxes paid)
  • Research and development (R&D) investment (innovation, patents)

Industry-Specific KPIs

• Address unique sustainability challenges and opportunities within particular sectors
  • Renewable energy generation for utilities (solar, wind)
  • Responsible sourcing for consumer goods companies (certified materials, supplier audits)
  • Sustainable agriculture practices for food companies (soil health, water efficiency)
  • Circular economy initiatives for manufacturing companies (product redesign, recycled content)
  • Green building certifications for real estate companies (LEED, BREEAM)

Benchmarking Sustainability Performance

Comparative Analysis

• Involves comparing a company's sustainability KPIs to those of its industry peers
  • Assesses relative performance
  • Identifies areas for improvement
• Can be conducted at the overall company level or for specific sustainability topics
  • Carbon emissions (Scope 1, 2, and 3 emissions)
  • Workforce diversity (gender pay gap, minority representation)
  • Supply chain management (supplier codes of conduct, responsible sourcing)

Industry Benchmarks

• Established by analyzing the KPIs reported by a representative sample of companies within a given sector
  • Determines industry averages and best practices
  • Provides context for individual company performance
• Sustainability rating agencies and research firms often provide benchmarking data and analysis
  • CDP (formerly Carbon Disclosure Project)
  • Sustainalytics
  • MSCI ESG Research

Applications of Benchmarking

• Sets ambitious yet achievable sustainability targets based on industry norms and leaders
• Prioritizes initiatives and resources based on areas of relative strength or weakness
• Communicates performance to stakeholders in the context of industry standards
  • Investors (ESG ratings, sustainability indices)
  • Customers (product labeling, marketing claims)
  • Employees (attraction and retention, employee engagement)

KPI Effectiveness in Sustainability Measurement

Characteristics of Effective KPIs

• Relevant to a company's overall sustainability strategy and goals
  • Aligned with material issues identified through stakeholder engagement and materiality assessments
• Measurable using reliable and consistent data sources and methodologies
  • Quantifiable metrics with clear definitions and boundaries
• Comparable across time periods and peer companies
  • Standardized calculation methods and reporting frameworks (GRI, SASB)
• Balanced mix of environmental, social, governance, and economic factors
  • Avoids overemphasis on any one dimension of sustainability
  • Captures trade-offs and synergies between different sustainability objectives

Tailoring KPIs to Company Context

• Specific KPIs chosen should reflect a company's industry, business model, and key sustainability risks and opportunities
  • Materiality assessment identifies the most relevant and impactful sustainability issues for a given company
  • Industry-specific frameworks (SASB, GRI Sector Standards) provide guidance on relevant KPIs
• Regular review and updates ensure KPIs remain relevant and responsive to changing stakeholder expectations and business conditions
  • Emerging sustainability issues (biodiversity, just transition)
  • Evolving regulations and reporting requirements (EU Taxonomy, TCFD)

Evaluating KPI Effectiveness

• Ability to drive meaningful sustainability improvements and inform decision-making
  • Target setting and progress tracking against KPIs
  • Integration of KPIs into business strategy and risk management processes
• Engagement and communication with stakeholders around KPI performance
  • Transparency and accountability through sustainability reporting and disclosure
  • Dialogue and feedback mechanisms to understand stakeholder perspectives on KPIs

Limitations of KPI-Only Sustainability Assessment

Capturing Complexity and Context

• KPIs provide a snapshot of sustainability performance at a given point in time
  • May not fully reflect the dynamic and interconnected nature of sustainability issues
  • Historical data and future projections are important for understanding trends and trajectories
• Some sustainability impacts are difficult to quantify and measure through KPIs alone
  • Biodiversity loss (species richness, habitat destruction)
  • Community well-being (social cohesion, cultural heritage)
  • Indirect and cumulative impacts (supply chain, product use phase)

Data Quality and Comparability

• KPIs can be subject to data quality issues, particularly when relying on self-reported information
  • Inconsistent methodologies and assumptions across companies
  • Lack of third-party verification or assurance
• Comparability challenges arise from differences in company size, geography, and business models
  • Normalization techniques (per unit of revenue, per employee) can help but have limitations
  • Industry-specific benchmarks are more meaningful than cross-industry comparisons

Unintended Consequences

• Overemphasis on meeting KPI targets can sometimes lead to perverse incentives or a narrow focus on short-term results
  • Sacrificing long-term sustainability for short-term gains
  • Neglecting important issues that are not easily measured or quantified
  • Gaming the system through creative accounting or selective disclosure
• Holistic approach to sustainability management is needed to balance competing priorities and avoid unintended consequences
  • Qualitative information (case studies, stakeholder testimonials)
  • External verification and assurance of sustainability performance
  • Ongoing stakeholder engagement and dialogue to identify and address emerging issues