1.3 Historical Context and Contemporary Relevance

Native American law has a complex history rooted in colonialism and shifting federal policies. From the Doctrine of Discovery to forced relocation and assimilation attempts, these legal frameworks have profoundly impacted Indigenous communities, shaping present-day challenges and opportunities.

Critical Native Studies examines this history through a decolonial lens, challenging Eurocentric legal paradigms. It informs contemporary issues like tribal sovereignty, resource management, and cultural preservation, while advocating for Indigenous legal traditions and alternative visions of justice and governance.

Historical Context of Native American Law

Foundational Legal Doctrines and Acts

Top images from around the web for Foundational Legal Doctrines and Acts

• 

  Indian Removal Act - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  NATIVE HISTORY ASSOCIATION - The Indian Removal Act of 1830 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indian Removal Act - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indian Removal Act - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  NATIVE HISTORY ASSOCIATION - The Indian Removal Act of 1830 View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Foundational Legal Doctrines and Acts

• 

  Indian Removal Act - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  NATIVE HISTORY ASSOCIATION - The Indian Removal Act of 1830 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indian Removal Act - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indian Removal Act - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  NATIVE HISTORY ASSOCIATION - The Indian Removal Act of 1830 View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Doctrine of Discovery established in 15th century justified European colonization and dispossession of Indigenous lands in Americas
• Marshall Trilogy defined legal status of Native American tribes as "domestic dependent nations" in early 19th century Supreme Court cases
  • Established federal trust responsibility toward tribes
• Indian Removal Act of 1830 authorized forced relocation of Native American tribes to territories west of Mississippi River
  • Resulted in Trail of Tears and other forced migrations

Assimilation and Self-Governance Policies

• General Allotment Act (Dawes Act) of 1887 aimed to assimilate Native Americans by dividing tribal lands
  • Resulted in significant land loss for many tribes (over 90 million acres)
  • Undermined traditional communal land ownership systems
• Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 reversed some aspects of allotment policy
  • Encouraged tribal self-governance, though with federal limitations
  • Allowed tribes to adopt constitutions and establish formal tribal governments
• Termination Era (1940s-1960s) attempted to end federal trust relationship with many tribes
  • Led to loss of federal recognition and services for affected communities (over 100 tribes)
  • Klamath, Menominee, and other tribes lost federal status during this period

Shift Toward Self-Determination

• Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975 marked shift towards greater tribal autonomy
  • Allowed tribes to contract with federal government to administer their own programs
  • Included education, healthcare, housing, and other services
• Enabled tribes to tailor programs to community needs and cultural values
• Represented a major policy shift away from termination and assimilation approaches

Impact of Historical Events on Native Communities

Intergenerational Trauma and Cultural Preservation

• Forced assimilation policies like boarding schools continue to affect Native American mental health
  • Resulted in loss of language, cultural practices, and family connections
  • Contributed to high rates of depression, substance abuse, and suicide in some communities
• Cultural preservation efforts ongoing to address historical losses
  • Language revitalization programs (Navajo, Hawaiian)
  • Traditional knowledge preservation initiatives

Socioeconomic Disparities and Land Issues

• Legacy of land dispossession contributes to ongoing socioeconomic challenges
  • Higher rates of poverty (25.4% compared to 13.4% national average)
  • Higher unemployment (6.6% compared to 3.9% national average)
• Jurisdictional complexities complicate law enforcement and economic development
  • Checkerboard land ownership patterns on many reservations
  • Unclear jurisdiction in criminal cases (Public Law 280 states)

Environmental and Health Impacts

• Environmental injustices rooted in historical land policies persist
  • Disproportionate exposure to toxic waste sites (Navajo Nation uranium contamination)
  • Limited access to clean water (Standing Rock Sioux Tribe)
• Health disparities linked to historical policies and ongoing challenges
  • Higher rates of diabetes, heart disease, and other chronic conditions
  • Limited access to healthcare facilities on many reservations

Relevance of Critical Native Studies

Challenging Eurocentric Legal Paradigms

• Examines intersection of law, policy, and Indigenous rights in context of ongoing colonial structures
• Advocates for incorporation of Indigenous legal traditions in policy-making
  • Peacemaking courts in Navajo Nation
  • Restorative justice practices in some tribal courts
• Questions legitimacy of doctrines such as plenary power
  • Analyzes impact on tribal sovereignty and self-determination

Contemporary Issues Through a Decolonial Lens

• Examines tribal jurisdiction, natural resource management, and cultural property rights
  • McGirt v. Oklahoma case and implications for tribal criminal jurisdiction
  • Protection of sacred sites (Bears Ears National Monument)
• Contributes to development of Indigenous methodologies in legal research
  • Tribal participatory research models
  • Incorporation of oral histories and traditional knowledge in legal arguments

Education and Alternative Visions

• Educates legal professionals and policymakers about unique legal status of Native American tribes
  • Complexities of federal Indian law and tribal sovereignty
  • Government-to-government relationships between tribes and federal government
• Provides platform for Indigenous scholars to articulate alternative visions of justice and governance
  • Restorative justice models based on traditional practices
  • Sustainable resource management based on Indigenous ecological knowledge

Addressing Challenges for Native Communities

Strengthening Sovereignty and Self-Determination

• Informs advocacy efforts for strengthening tribal sovereignty
  • Expansion of tribal criminal jurisdiction (Violence Against Women Act reauthorization)
  • Environmental protection (tribal co-management of public lands)
• Contributes to development of culturally appropriate legal and policy solutions
  • Addressing shortcomings of Indian Child Welfare Act
  • Developing tribal-specific child welfare codes

Economic Development and Cultural Protection

• Provides analytical tools for addressing economic development challenges
  • Navigating complex interplay of federal, state, and tribal regulations
  • Developing tribal tax codes and business regulations
• Supports efforts to protect and repatriate cultural heritage
  • Informs legal strategies related to Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA)
  • Advocates for protection of traditional knowledge and cultural expressions

Environmental Justice and Resource Rights

• Informs debates on climate change policy emphasizing Indigenous knowledge
  • Traditional ecological knowledge in climate adaptation strategies
  • Tribal renewable energy initiatives (Navajo Nation solar projects)
• Develops strategies for protecting tribal water rights
  • Quantification of reserved water rights (Winters Doctrine)
  • Negotiated settlements for water allocation (Arizona Water Settlements Act)