12.4 Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW)

The Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW) crisis highlights the disproportionate violence faced by Native American women. With murder rates up to 10 times higher than the national average in some areas, this issue spans reservations and urban settings, crossing jurisdictional lines and complicating responses.

This crisis stems from historical injustices and ongoing systemic racism, causing widespread trauma in Native communities. It disrupts families, erodes cultural practices, and weakens social cohesion. The complex factors behind MMIW violence reveal the deep-rooted challenges in Native American law and policy.

Scope and Severity of MMIW

Crisis Overview and Statistics

Top images from around the web for Crisis Overview and Statistics

• 

  Missing and Murdered Native American Women – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Why Are There So Many Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women? – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  MMIWUSA - Staying Sacred | Tryon Life Community Farm View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Missing and Murdered Native American Women – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Why Are There So Many Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women? – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Crisis Overview and Statistics

• 

  Missing and Murdered Native American Women – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Why Are There So Many Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women? – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  MMIWUSA - Staying Sacred | Tryon Life Community Farm View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Missing and Murdered Native American Women – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Why Are There So Many Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women? – Youth Voices View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• MMIW crisis involves disproportionately high rates of missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls in North America (United States and Canada)
• National Crime Information Center and Urban Indian Health Institute data demonstrate alarming prevalence of violence against Indigenous women
• Indigenous women face murder rates up to 10 times higher than national average in some areas
• Significant number of cases go unreported or unresolved
• Crisis extends beyond reservations, affecting Indigenous women in urban areas
• Crosses jurisdictional boundaries, complicating response efforts

Impacts on Native American Communities

• Intergenerational trauma stemming from historical injustices and ongoing systemic racism contributes to vulnerability of Indigenous women to violence and disappearance
• Far-reaching impacts include psychological trauma for individuals and families
• Erosion of cultural practices due to loss of knowledge keepers and community members
• Disruption of family structures leads to increased instability in Native American communities
• Social cohesion within tribes weakened by constant threat of violence and disappearance
• Economic impacts as resources are diverted to search efforts and support for affected families

Factors Contributing to MMIW Violence

Historical Context

• Legacy of colonialism disrupted traditional Indigenous social structures and support systems
  • Forced relocation (Trail of Tears)
  • Cultural assimilation policies (boarding schools)
  • Boarding school system separated families and suppressed Indigenous languages and traditions
• Historical legal frameworks created jurisdictional complexities hindering effective law enforcement responses
  • Major Crimes Act limited tribal jurisdiction over serious offenses
  • Public Law 280 transferred federal jurisdiction to certain states without tribal consent

Contemporary Challenges

• Systemic racism and discrimination within law enforcement and judicial systems contribute to inadequate investigation and prosecution
• Socioeconomic factors increase vulnerability to violence and exploitation
  • Poverty rates on reservations often exceed national averages
  • Limited access to quality education in many Indigenous communities
  • Restricted economic opportunities in isolated or rural tribal areas
• Intersection of gender-based violence and racial discrimination creates unique challenges for Indigenous women
• Resource extraction projects and man camps near Indigenous territories linked to increased rates of violence
  • Bakken oil fields in North Dakota associated with rise in trafficking and assault cases

Media and Public Awareness

• Limited media representation of MMIW cases contributes to lack of urgency in addressing crisis
• Public awareness often low due to underreporting in mainstream media outlets
• Stereotypes and misconceptions about Indigenous people persist in public discourse, affecting response to MMIW cases

Challenges in Investigating MMIW Cases

Jurisdictional and Resource Issues

• Complexities arising from intersection of tribal, state, and federal law enforcement agencies lead to confusion and delays
• Limited resources and inadequate funding for tribal law enforcement agencies hamper investigation capabilities
  • Insufficient personnel to cover large geographic areas
  • Lack of advanced forensic technologies in many tribal police departments
• Insufficient data collection and sharing among agencies create gaps in understanding full scope of crisis
  • Hinders ability to identify patterns or potential serial offenders
  • Lack of centralized database for MMIW cases across jurisdictions

Cultural and Communication Barriers

• Historical distrust between Indigenous communities and non-Indigenous law enforcement impedes effective cooperation
• Lack of cultural competency in handling MMIW cases due to underrepresentation of Indigenous people in law enforcement and judicial systems
• Language barriers may complicate interviews and evidence gathering in some communities
• Cultural practices and beliefs about death and mourning may conflict with standard investigative procedures

Investigative Challenges

• Lack of standardized protocols for responding to and investigating MMIW cases across jurisdictions results in inconsistent responses
• Challenges in gathering and preserving evidence in remote areas compromise prosecution efforts
  • Limited access to crime scenes in isolated locations
  • Weather conditions in extreme climates can degrade physical evidence quickly
• Difficulties in tracking cases that cross jurisdictional boundaries, especially in border regions

Advocacy and Policy for MMIW

Grassroots Initiatives and Community Mobilization

• Indigenous-led organizations instrumental in raising awareness and advocating for policy changes (Native Women's Association of Canada)
• Community-based approaches fill gaps in official responses
  • Search parties organized by community members
  • Support networks for families of missing women provide emotional and practical assistance
• Social media campaigns amplify Indigenous voices and bring national and international attention to crisis (REDress Project)

Policy and Legislative Efforts

• Savanna's Act aims to improve data collection and increase coordination among law enforcement agencies
• Not Invisible Act enhances support for MMIW victims and their families
• Tribal governments develop own strategies to address MMIW crisis
  • Implementation of amber alert systems on reservations
  • Creation of dedicated MMIW task forces (Navajo Nation Missing Persons Unit)
• Collaborations between Indigenous organizations, academic institutions, and government agencies improve research and data collection
• International bodies recognize MMIW crisis as human rights issue
  • United Nations special rapporteur reports on violence against Indigenous women
  • Inter-American Commission on Human Rights hearings on MMIW in Canada and the US

Strategies for Preventing MMIW Violence

Community-Based Prevention

• Implementing culturally appropriate programs addressing root causes of violence
  • Intergenerational trauma healing initiatives
  • Substance abuse prevention and treatment programs
• Strengthening tribal sovereignty and expanding tribal jurisdiction over non-Native offenders
  • Violence Against Women Reauthorization Act of 2013 allowed some tribal prosecution of non-Native domestic violence offenders
• Incorporating Indigenous perspectives and traditional knowledge into policy development
  • Utilizing talking circles and restorative justice practices in conflict resolution

Systemic Improvements

• Improving coordination and information sharing among tribal, state, and federal law enforcement agencies
  • Joint task forces for MMIW cases (Montana's Missing Indigenous Persons Task Force)
  • Cross-deputization agreements to expand jurisdictional authority
• Increasing funding and resources for tribal law enforcement, victim services, and prevention programs
  • Tribal Access Program (TAP) provides tribes access to national crime information systems
• Developing standardized protocols for responding to missing persons cases involving Indigenous women
  • Implementation of NamUs (National Missing and Unidentified Persons System) for MMIW cases

Education and Support

• Enhancing training for law enforcement, healthcare providers, and social services personnel
  • Cultural competency training specific to Indigenous communities
  • Trauma-informed care practices for working with MMIW survivors and families
• Creating comprehensive support systems for families of MMIW victims
  • Counseling services tailored to Indigenous healing practices
  • Legal assistance navigating complex jurisdictional issues
  • Advocacy services throughout investigation and judicial processes
• Implementing educational programs in schools to raise awareness and promote prevention
  • Curriculum on healthy relationships and consent
  • Indigenous history and cultural awareness to combat stereotypes and racism