3.6 Task analysis

Task analysis is a crucial step in designing user-friendly systems. It involves breaking down complex tasks into smaller, manageable steps to understand how users interact with a product or service. This process helps identify pain points and opportunities for improvement in existing workflows.

By examining user behavior and cognitive processes, task analysis provides valuable insights for creating intuitive interfaces. It informs the development of user requirements, guides interaction design decisions, and supports usability testing efforts. Ultimately, task analysis helps create more efficient and satisfying user experiences.

Goals of task analysis

• Understand the steps, decisions, and actions users take to accomplish their goals within a system or process
• Identify pain points, inefficiencies, and opportunities for improvement in existing workflows to optimize the user experience
• Provide a foundation for designing intuitive interfaces, user flows, and interactions that align with users' mental models and expectations

Task analysis methods

Hierarchical task analysis

Top images from around the web for Hierarchical task analysis

• 

  AlterEvo Ltd: RCM 4: Logic Trees View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Datei:Hierachical Task Analysis.jpg – InfoWissWiki - Das Wiki der Informationswissenschaft View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  AlterEvo Ltd: RCM 4: Logic Trees View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Datei:Hierachical Task Analysis.jpg – InfoWissWiki - Das Wiki der Informationswissenschaft View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Hierarchical task analysis

• 

  AlterEvo Ltd: RCM 4: Logic Trees View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Datei:Hierachical Task Analysis.jpg – InfoWissWiki - Das Wiki der Informationswissenschaft View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  AlterEvo Ltd: RCM 4: Logic Trees View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Datei:Hierachical Task Analysis.jpg – InfoWissWiki - Das Wiki der Informationswissenschaft View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• Decomposes complex tasks into a hierarchy of subtasks and actions
• Represents tasks visually using a tree-like structure, with higher-level goals broken down into increasingly specific steps
• Helps identify task dependencies, decision points, and potential bottlenecks
  • Example: Breaking down the task of "Booking a flight" into subtasks like "Select departure date," "Choose destination," and "Enter payment information"

Cognitive task analysis

• Focuses on understanding the cognitive processes, knowledge, and strategies involved in completing tasks
• Examines the mental workload, decision-making, and problem-solving aspects of tasks
• Employs techniques like think-aloud protocols, interviews, and observations to uncover users' thought processes
  • Example: Analyzing how experienced mechanics diagnose and troubleshoot complex machinery failures

Task analysis process

Identifying tasks

• Determine the key tasks and goals users need to accomplish within the system or process
• Gather input from stakeholders, subject matter experts, and end-users to ensure comprehensive task coverage
• Prioritize tasks based on their frequency, criticality, and impact on the overall user experience

Breaking down tasks

• Decompose each identified task into its constituent subtasks, steps, and actions
• Use a top-down approach, starting with high-level goals and progressively adding more detail and specificity
• Consider alternative paths, exceptions, and error scenarios that users may encounter during task execution

Organizing task steps

• Arrange the identified subtasks and steps in a logical sequence that reflects the typical user workflow
• Identify dependencies, decision points, and parallel or optional paths within the task structure
• Ensure that the task organization aligns with users' mental models and expectations

Documenting task details

• Record relevant information for each task step, such as input requirements, system responses, and user actions
• Specify any constraints, preconditions, or postconditions associated with each task or subtask
• Include visual aids, such as screenshots or diagrams, to clarify complex interactions or user interfaces

Task analysis outputs

Task flows and diagrams

• Create visual representations of the analyzed tasks using flowcharts, activity diagrams, or similar notations
• Illustrate the sequence of steps, decision points, and alternative paths users may take to complete a task
• Use consistent symbols and formatting to enhance clarity and readability
  • Example: Developing a swimlane diagram to show the interactions between the user and the system during an e-commerce checkout process

Use cases and scenarios

• Describe specific instances or scenarios in which users perform the analyzed tasks
• Provide context, goals, and step-by-step narratives to illustrate how users interact with the system
• Highlight key considerations, constraints, and success criteria for each use case
  • Example: Crafting a detailed scenario for "Scheduling a doctor's appointment" that includes the user's motivations, actions, and expected outcomes

Task inventories and lists

• Compile comprehensive lists of all the identified tasks, subtasks, and steps
• Organize the task inventory hierarchically or by functional areas to facilitate easy reference and navigation
• Include relevant metadata, such as task frequency, complexity, or user roles
  • Example: Creating a spreadsheet that catalogues all the tasks associated with "Managing a project" in a collaborative work management tool

Benefits of task analysis

Improved user experience

• Identifies user pain points, frustrations, and challenges in existing workflows, enabling targeted improvements
• Ensures that system design and functionality align with users' goals, expectations, and mental models
• Facilitates the creation of intuitive, efficient, and satisfying user interfaces and interactions

Increased efficiency and productivity

• Optimizes task flows and eliminates unnecessary steps or redundancies, streamlining user workflows
• Identifies opportunities for automation, decision support, or user guidance to enhance task performance
• Reduces the cognitive load on users by providing clear, logical, and consistent task structures

Reduced errors and frustration

• Uncovers potential sources of user confusion, mistakes, or frustration within existing or proposed task flows
• Enables proactive error prevention through improved interface design, user feedback, and validation mechanisms
• Minimizes the learning curve and supports user success by aligning system behavior with users' expectations

Challenges of task analysis

Time and resource intensive

• Requires significant time and effort to conduct thorough task analysis, especially for complex systems or processes
• Involves coordinating with multiple stakeholders, subject matter experts, and end-users to gather comprehensive insights
• May necessitate iterative refinement and validation to ensure accuracy and completeness of the analyzed tasks

Balancing detail vs abstraction

• Challenges in determining the appropriate level of detail to capture in task analysis without overwhelming or oversimplifying
• Requires judgment to identify which task steps, decision points, and variations are essential to document
• Needs to strike a balance between providing sufficient detail for design while maintaining clarity and manageability

Accounting for user variability

• Accommodating diverse user populations, skill levels, and contexts of use within task analysis
• Considering individual differences in cognitive abilities, domain knowledge, and problem-solving strategies
• Ensuring that task analysis captures both typical and edge cases to design for a wide range of user needs and scenarios

Task analysis in design process

Informing user requirements

• Provides a foundation for defining and prioritizing user requirements based on the identified tasks and goals
• Helps ensure that system functionality and design decisions are grounded in user needs and workflows
• Enables traceability between user requirements and the corresponding task analysis findings

Guiding interaction design

• Informs the design of user interfaces, navigation, and information architecture based on the analyzed task structures
• Helps identify appropriate interaction patterns, controls, and feedback mechanisms to support efficient task completion
• Ensures that the designed interactions align with users' mental models and expectations derived from task analysis

Supporting usability testing

• Serves as a basis for developing test scenarios, tasks, and evaluation criteria for usability testing
• Enables targeted assessment of how well the designed system supports users in accomplishing their goals and tasks
• Provides a benchmark for measuring the effectiveness, efficiency, and satisfaction of the user experience

Tools for task analysis

Flowchart and diagramming software

• Utilize tools like Microsoft Visio, Lucidchart, or draw.io to create visual representations of task flows and diagrams
• Leverage built-in templates, shapes, and connectors to efficiently construct task hierarchies and sequences
• Collaborate with team members and stakeholders to refine and iterate on task diagrams in real-time

User research platforms

• Employ user research tools like UserTesting, UsabilityHub, or UserZoom to gather insights and validate task analysis findings
• Conduct remote user interviews, surveys, or usability tests to collect data on users' task behaviors and experiences
• Analyze user feedback and session recordings to identify patterns, challenges, and opportunities for improvement

Collaborative documentation tools

• Use shared documentation platforms like Google Docs, Notion, or Confluence to document and organize task analysis outputs
• Collaborate with team members to capture task details, use cases, and scenarios in a centralized location
• Facilitate version control, commenting, and review workflows to ensure the accuracy and currency of task analysis documentation

Task analysis best practices

Involving diverse stakeholders

• Engage a wide range of stakeholders, including end-users, subject matter experts, and cross-functional teams, in task analysis
• Seek diverse perspectives to ensure comprehensive coverage of tasks, workflows, and user needs
• Foster open communication and collaboration to align task analysis efforts with business goals and technical constraints

Iterating and refining

• Treat task analysis as an iterative process, continuously refining and updating the findings based on new insights and feedback
• Validate task analysis outputs with users and stakeholders to ensure accuracy and completeness
• Incorporate task analysis iterations into the overall design and development lifecycle to inform ongoing improvements

Maintaining living documentation

• Treat task analysis documentation as a living artifact that evolves alongside the system or process being designed
• Establish processes and ownership for regularly reviewing and updating task analysis outputs as requirements or workflows change
• Ensure that task analysis documentation remains accessible, searchable, and easily consumable by all relevant stakeholders