2.2 The innovator's dilemma and the innovator's solution

The innovator's dilemma explains why successful companies often struggle with disruptive innovations. It highlights the conflict between serving existing customers and exploring new markets. This challenge can lead to missed opportunities and potential obsolescence.

The innovator's solution offers strategies to overcome this dilemma. It emphasizes creating new markets, focusing on customer jobs-to-be-done, and building separate structures for disruptive projects. These approaches help companies balance current success with future growth.

Challenges of Disruptive Innovation

Resource Allocation and Market Focus

Top images from around the web for Resource Allocation and Market Focus

• 

  Disruptive Innovation. What it is, and what it is not. - $_DV View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Cracks In The Foundation Of Disruptive Innovation -e-Literate View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Innovación Disruptiva (Christensen) – juandon. Innovación y conocimiento View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Disruptive Innovation. What it is, and what it is not. - $_DV View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Cracks In The Foundation Of Disruptive Innovation -e-Literate View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Resource Allocation and Market Focus

• 

  Disruptive Innovation. What it is, and what it is not. - $_DV View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Cracks In The Foundation Of Disruptive Innovation -e-Literate View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Innovación Disruptiva (Christensen) – juandon. Innovación y conocimiento View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Disruptive Innovation. What it is, and what it is not. - $_DV View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Cracks In The Foundation Of Disruptive Innovation -e-Literate View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Established companies struggle with resource allocation prioritizing existing profitable products over potentially disruptive innovations that may initially appear less profitable
• The "innovator's dilemma" arises when companies focus on sustaining innovations for existing customers neglecting emerging markets and technologies
• Companies face the challenge of "overshooting" customer needs in established markets leaving them vulnerable to simpler, lower-cost disruptive alternatives
• Difficulty in accurately predicting the potential of disruptive innovations leads to underinvestment or missed opportunities
  • Example: Kodak's underestimation of digital photography's potential
  • Example: Blockbuster's failure to recognize the disruptive potential of Netflix's DVD-by-mail and streaming services

Organizational Barriers

• Organizational inertia and resistance to change impede companies' ability to adapt to disruptive innovations quickly
• Companies may face the "sunk cost fallacy" where previous investments in existing technologies or business models hinder willingness to pivot towards disruptive innovations
  • Example: Nokia's reluctance to abandon its Symbian operating system in favor of adopting Android or developing a new mobile OS
• The "tyranny of the quarterly report" prioritizes short-term financial performance over long-term innovation strategies
  • Example: General Electric's focus on short-term earnings growth under Jack Welch, which ultimately led to long-term decline

The Innovator's Dilemma

Concept and Implications

• Coined by Clayton Christensen describes the paradox where successful companies can fail by making seemingly rational decisions that ultimately lead to their downfall
• Managers face the dilemma of choosing between sustaining innovations for existing customers and disruptive innovations that may cannibalize current product lines but offer long-term growth potential
• Highlights the conflict between short-term profitability and long-term sustainability often leading managers to prioritize incremental improvements over radical innovations
• Emphasizes that success in the past does not guarantee future success requiring managers to continually reassess their strategies and market positions
  • Example: IBM's transition from hardware to services and consulting
  • Example: Apple's shift from personal computers to mobile devices and services

Market Dynamics and Organizational Structures

• Disruptive innovations often start in low-end or new markets initially appearing less attractive than existing high-margin products
  • Example: Personal computers disrupting mainframe computers
  • Example: Minimills disrupting integrated steel mills
• Creates the need for separate organizational structures or spin-off companies to pursue disruptive innovations without the constraints of the core business
• Requires managers to develop ambidextrous leadership skills to balance exploitation of existing markets with exploration of new disruptive opportunities
  • Example: Google's creation of Alphabet to separate core business from moonshot projects
  • Example: Amazon's development of AWS as a separate business unit

Overcoming the Innovator's Dilemma

Customer-Centric Approaches

• Implement a "jobs to be done" approach to understand customer needs beyond product features focusing on the fundamental problem customers are trying to solve
  • Example: Intuit's focus on helping small businesses manage finances rather than just selling accounting software
• Adopt a discovery-driven planning approach to manage uncertainties associated with disruptive innovations using assumptions testing and iterative learning
  • Example: Toyota's development of the Prius through iterative prototyping and market testing
• Transition from a product-centric to a solution-centric approach integrating products and services to address customer jobs more holistically
  • Example: IBM's shift from selling hardware to providing integrated IT solutions

Organizational Strategies

• Develop a culture of continuous learning and experimentation encouraging calculated risk-taking and embracing failure as a learning opportunity
  • Example: 3M's "15% time" policy allowing employees to work on innovative projects
• Create autonomous innovation units or "skunkworks" teams that operate independently from the core business to pursue disruptive ideas without bureaucratic constraints
  • Example: Lockheed Martin's original Skunk Works division for advanced aircraft development
• Adopt an "ambidextrous organization" structure allowing for simultaneous exploitation of existing markets and exploration of new disruptive opportunities
  • Example: Procter & Gamble's Connect + Develop open innovation program
• Implement a portfolio approach to innovation investments balancing resources between sustaining innovations and potentially disruptive projects across different time horizons
  • Example: Johnson & Johnson's innovation portfolio spanning incremental improvements to breakthrough technologies

Innovator's Solution Framework

Market Creation and Reshaping

• Emphasizes creating new markets or reshaping existing ones through disruptive innovation rather than competing in oversaturated markets
• Identify and capitalize on "non-consumption" opportunities creating new markets for previously underserved customers
  • Example: Airbnb tapping into the market of people who couldn't afford traditional hotel accommodations
  • Example: M-Pesa creating mobile banking services for unbanked populations in Kenya

Case Study Applications

• Analyze cases where companies have successfully applied the "jobs to be done" approach to uncover unmet customer needs and create disruptive solutions
  • Example: Netflix's transition from DVD rentals to streaming based on the job of convenient entertainment consumption
• Examine examples of companies that have effectively used resource allocation processes to fund and nurture potentially disruptive innovations alongside their core business
  • Example: Amazon's investment in AWS while maintaining its e-commerce business
• Study cases where companies have successfully created separate organizational structures or spin-offs to pursue disruptive innovations
  • Example: Alphabet's creation of X (formerly Google X) for moonshot projects
• Evaluate instances where companies have leveraged emerging technologies or business models to create new market categories or redefine existing ones
  • Example: Tesla's disruption of the automotive industry through electric vehicles and direct-to-consumer sales model