11.3 Sharing economy and platform capitalism

The sharing economy has revolutionized how we access goods and services. From Uber to Airbnb, these platforms connect users directly, disrupting traditional industries. But critics argue this model exploits workers and concentrates power in the hands of a few tech giants.

Platform capitalism uses digital tools to facilitate economic interactions, often through data-driven optimization. While creating new opportunities, it's also led to precarious work conditions and regulatory challenges. Cities grapple with impacts on housing, transportation, and inequality as they adapt to this new economic landscape.

Sharing Economy Characteristics and Models

Key Characteristics of the Sharing Economy

Top images from around the web for Key Characteristics of the Sharing Economy

• 

  Sharing economy, collaborative consumption, peer-to-peer accommodation or trading of space ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Sharing-Exchange Continuum Inside of the Sharing Economy View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Sharing economy, collaborative consumption, peer-to-peer accommodation or trading of space ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Sharing-Exchange Continuum Inside of the Sharing Economy View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Key Characteristics of the Sharing Economy

• 

  Sharing economy, collaborative consumption, peer-to-peer accommodation or trading of space ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Sharing-Exchange Continuum Inside of the Sharing Economy View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Sharing economy, collaborative consumption, peer-to-peer accommodation or trading of space ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Sharing-Exchange Continuum Inside of the Sharing Economy View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• Involves peer-to-peer based sharing of access to goods and services coordinated through community-based online services
  • Key sectors include transportation (Uber), accommodation (Airbnb), and retail (Etsy)
• Represents a form of "platform cooperativism" that some argue exploits labor, avoids regulations, and concentrates market power rather than true "sharing"
• Critics argue these models benefit platforms at the expense of workers and communities

Business Models in the Sharing Economy and Platform Capitalism

• Platform capitalism refers to the use of digital platforms to facilitate economic and social interaction often through algorithmic management and data-driven optimization
  • Examples include Uber, Airbnb, and Amazon
• Business models often involve asset-light, on-demand access to underutilized resources or services
  • Revenue is typically generated through transaction fees, subscriptions, or advertising
• Platforms act as intermediaries that match supply and demand, set prices, and govern transactions
  • They benefit from network effects where the value increases as more users participate

Impacts of the Sharing Economy

Economic Impacts on Traditional Industries and Markets

• Has disrupted traditional industries like hotels and taxis by introducing new competition and altering consumer preferences
  • Led to reduced market share and revenue for some incumbent firms (Hilton, Yellow Cab)
• Can increase resource efficiency by maximizing the utilization of idle assets like cars or spare bedrooms
  • However, it may also encourage unsustainable consumption patterns

Social Impacts on Labor and Inequality

• Platforms have created new income opportunities and lowered barriers to entry for individuals to monetize their skills and assets
  • However, this work is often precarious lacking benefits and protections (health insurance, retirement plans)
• Discrimination by both providers and consumers on platforms can replicate or worsen social inequalities
  • Rating systems and algorithmic pricing have the potential to codify biases (racial, gender)
• Platforms can provide data-driven insights to optimize services and target marketing but also raise privacy concerns around the collection and use of personal information

Regulatory Challenges of the Sharing Economy

Regulatory Gray Areas and Policy Responses

• Sharing economy firms often operate in regulatory gray areas leading to conflicts with existing laws
  • Challenges include licensing, zoning, taxation, insurance, and consumer protection
  • Regulators have struggled to keep pace with rapid technological change
• Some jurisdictions have taken legal action to reclassify platform workers as employees rather than independent contractors
  • Aims to provide access to minimum wages, overtime, collective bargaining, and other protections

Taxation and Housing Market Impacts

• Tax avoidance by platforms and their users is a key regulatory concern
  • Challenges include difficulties tracking and reporting income, ambiguity around tax liability, and the cross-jurisdictional nature of transactions
• Short-term rental platforms like Airbnb have faced criticism for exacerbating housing shortages and gentrification in cities
  • Some municipalities have responded with restrictions on the number or type of listings allowed (San Francisco, Barcelona)

Transportation and Urban Planning Challenges

• Ride-hailing platforms have been associated with increased traffic congestion, emissions, and undermining of public transit systems
  • Policies like congestion pricing, vehicle caps, and data sharing requirements have been proposed in response (New York City, London)

Spatial Patterns of Platform-Based Activities

Uneven Geographic Distribution

• The sharing economy has uneven spatial penetration with the highest participation in large, dense, affluent urban areas
  • Smaller cities and rural areas have more limited platform options and uptake
• Platforms tend to cluster in urban neighborhoods with high levels of education, income, and digital connectivity
  • Can reinforce existing socio-spatial inequalities within and between cities

Impacts on Urban Transportation and Housing

• Ride-hailing platforms have altered urban transportation patterns
  • Led to increased vehicle miles traveled and reduced public transit ridership in some cases (San Francisco, Chicago)
  • Has implications for congestion, emissions, and access
• Short-term rental platforms have been associated with the touristification of residential neighborhoods as housing units are converted from long-term to short-term use
  • Can lead to displacement, affordability challenges, and the erosion of community ties (Barcelona, New Orleans)

Broader Processes of Urban Change

• The platform economy is intertwined with broader processes of urbanization, globalization, and digitalization
  • It is both shaped by and contributes to the restructuring of urban spaces and economies
• Platforms are becoming increasingly influential actors in urban governance and policymaking
  • Raises questions about accountability, transparency, and the privatization of public goods and services