12.3 Qualitative methods and ethnographic research

Qualitative methods in economic geography offer a deeper understanding of complex economic phenomena. These approaches, including ethnographic research, capture nuances and lived experiences that quantitative methods might miss. They're increasingly recognized as essential for exploring emerging issues in the field.

Ethnographic fieldwork involves immersing oneself in an economic community to observe and participate in daily activities. This method requires careful planning, reflexivity, and flexible research design. Researchers use various techniques like participant observation and informal conversations to gather rich, context-specific data.

Value of Qualitative Methods

Capturing Nuances and Complexities

Top images from around the web for Capturing Nuances and Complexities

• 

  1.2 WHAT IS GEOGRAPHY? – Introduction to Human Geography View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Qualitative Methods | Introduction to Communication View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Dimensions of Culture – CaseWORK View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  1.2 WHAT IS GEOGRAPHY? – Introduction to Human Geography View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Qualitative Methods | Introduction to Communication View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Capturing Nuances and Complexities

• 

  1.2 WHAT IS GEOGRAPHY? – Introduction to Human Geography View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Qualitative Methods | Introduction to Communication View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Dimensions of Culture – CaseWORK View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  1.2 WHAT IS GEOGRAPHY? – Introduction to Human Geography View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Qualitative Methods | Introduction to Communication View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Qualitative methods, such as ethnography, interviews, and focus groups, provide rich, context-specific data that can capture the nuances and complexities of economic geography phenomena
• Qualitative approaches allow researchers to explore the lived experiences, perceptions, and meanings that individuals and communities attach to economic processes and spaces
• Qualitative methods are particularly useful for understanding the social and cultural dimensions of economic activities, such as the role of networks, norms, and power relations in shaping economic outcomes (kinship networks in ethnic entrepreneurship)
• Qualitative research can generate new insights and theories that challenge or complement existing quantitative models and explanations in economic geography (cultural economy approach to regional development)

Growing Recognition and Use

• The use of qualitative methods in economic geography has grown in recent decades, reflecting a broader "cultural turn" in the social sciences and a recognition of the limitations of purely quantitative approaches
• Qualitative methods are increasingly seen as essential for understanding the complex, multi-layered nature of economic phenomena and the agency of economic actors (consumers, workers, firms)
• The integration of qualitative and quantitative methods, known as mixed methods research, is becoming more common in economic geography as a way to triangulate findings and provide a more comprehensive understanding (combining surveys with interviews)
• The growing use of qualitative methods in economic geography is also driven by the need to engage with emerging issues and contexts, such as the digital economy, sustainable transitions, and alternative economies (sharing economy, circular economy)

Ethnographic Fieldwork for Data

Immersive and Participatory Approach

• Ethnographic fieldwork involves immersing oneself in a particular economic community or context to observe and participate in daily activities, interactions, and meanings
• Ethnographers use a range of methods, such as participant observation, informal conversations, and in-depth interviews, to build rapport with informants and gain a deep understanding of their perspectives and practices
• Participant observation involves actively participating in the economic activities and social life of the community being studied, such as working in a factory, attending trade fairs, or joining a local business association (apprenticeship in a craft workshop)
• Informal conversations and unstructured interviews allow ethnographers to explore emerging themes and follow up on observations in a more natural and dialogic way (talking with street vendors during their work)

Planning and Preparation

• Fieldwork requires careful planning and preparation, including obtaining ethical approval, negotiating access to field sites, and developing a flexible research design that can adapt to changing circumstances
• Ethnographers must be reflexive about their own positionality and how their presence and interactions may shape the data they collect and interpret
• Gaining access to field sites often requires building trust and rapport with gatekeepers, such as community leaders, business owners, or government officials (attending community meetings, volunteering in local organizations)
• Developing a flexible research design allows ethnographers to adapt to unexpected events, follow up on emerging themes, and seize opportunities for data collection (adjusting interview questions based on previous responses)

Documentation and Supplementary Methods

• Fieldnotes are a crucial tool for documenting observations, reflections, and emerging themes during ethnographic research
  • Fieldnotes should be written up as soon as possible after each fieldwork session to capture rich details and fresh insights
  • Fieldnotes can include descriptive accounts of settings, events, and interactions, as well as more analytical memos and theoretical reflections
• Ethnographic data can be supplemented with other qualitative methods, such as visual ethnography (photography, video) and archival research, to provide a more holistic understanding of economic phenomena
• Visual ethnography can capture the material and symbolic aspects of economic spaces and practices, such as the design of retail environments, the performance of service work, or the branding of products (photos of street markets, videos of factory work)
• Archival research can provide historical context and trace the evolution of economic institutions, policies, and discourses over time (company records, government documents, media coverage)

Qualitative Data Analysis Techniques

Coding for Patterns and Themes

• Qualitative data analysis involves an iterative process of organizing, interpreting, and theorizing the rich, textual data gathered through fieldwork and other methods
• Coding is a key technique for breaking down qualitative data into manageable segments and identifying patterns and themes
  • Codes can be descriptive (summarizing the content of a passage), interpretive (capturing the underlying meaning or significance), or theoretical (linking to broader concepts or theories)
  • Coding can be done manually or using qualitative data analysis software such as NVivo or Atlas.ti
• The coding process typically involves several rounds of coding, starting with open coding (identifying initial themes and categories), then axial coding (refining and linking themes), and finally selective coding (identifying core categories and narratives) (grounded theory approach)
• Coding is not a mechanical process but requires analytical thinking and constant comparison of data within and across cases (negative case analysis)

Thematic Analysis and Interpretation

• Thematic analysis involves identifying and interpreting the overarching themes and narratives that emerge from the coded data
  • Themes can be inductively derived from the data itself or deductively informed by existing theories and literature
  • Thematic analysis requires constant comparison and refinement of themes as new data is collected and analyzed
• Qualitative data analysis is not a linear process but involves moving back and forth between data collection, coding, and interpretation in a "hermeneutic circle"
• Interpretation involves making sense of the themes and patterns in relation to the research questions, theoretical frameworks, and broader context of the study (situating findings in the literature)
• The validity and reliability of qualitative analysis can be enhanced through techniques such as triangulation (using multiple data sources or methods), member checking (sharing interpretations with informants), and peer debriefing (discussing findings with colleagues)

Ethical Considerations in Research

Informed Consent and Confidentiality

• Qualitative research involves close interactions with human subjects and communities, raising important ethical considerations around informed consent, confidentiality, and potential harm
• Researchers must obtain informed consent from participants, explaining the purpose, methods, and potential risks and benefits of the study in clear and accessible language
• Informed consent should be an ongoing process, with participants having the right to withdraw from the study at any time (process consent)
• Confidentiality and anonymity of participants must be protected through secure data storage and the use of pseudonyms in published reports
• In some cases, complete anonymity may not be possible or desirable, such as when studying public figures or organizations (negotiated consent)

Power Dynamics and Positionality

• Researchers must be sensitive to power dynamics and potential exploitation in their relationships with informants, particularly when working with marginalized or vulnerable communities
• Power imbalances can arise from differences in social status, economic resources, or cultural capital between researchers and participants (elite interviews)
• Researchers must be aware of the potential for coercion or undue influence in recruiting participants, especially when using gatekeepers or incentives (snowball sampling)
• Positionality refers to the social, cultural, and economic position of the researcher in relation to their informants and how this shapes the research process and findings
  • Researchers must be reflexive about their own biases, assumptions, and privileges and how these may influence their interactions and interpretations in the field
  • Positionality can also create opportunities for building trust and rapport with informants, particularly when researchers share similar backgrounds or experiences (insider research)

Reciprocity and Dissemination

• Qualitative researchers have a responsibility to share their findings and knowledge with the communities they study in accessible and meaningful ways
• Reciprocity involves giving back to participants and communities, such as by providing resources, training, or advocacy (participatory action research)
• Dissemination should go beyond academic publications and include more public-facing outputs, such as community reports, exhibitions, or documentaries (arts-based research)
• Researchers should also consider the potential impact of their findings on participants and communities, both positive and negative (policy implications)
• Ethical considerations and positionality are not static but require ongoing reflection and negotiation throughout the research process