4.4 Environmental impacts of resource extraction

Resource extraction fuels our modern world but comes at a steep environmental cost. From strip mining to fracking, these methods wreak havoc on ecosystems, polluting water and destroying habitats. The challenge lies in balancing economic needs with ecological preservation.

Efforts to mitigate impacts include environmental assessments, permits, and new technologies. However, weak enforcement and economic pressures often undermine conservation goals. Finding sustainable solutions requires collaboration between industry, government, and local communities to protect our planet's resources.

Environmental Impacts of Resource Extraction

Extraction Methods and Their Impacts

Top images from around the web for Extraction Methods and Their Impacts

• 

  Extraction of Resources | Geology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surface & Underground Mine Environment Map (Stylized) - SkillsCommons Repository View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surface Mine Environment Map (Stylized) - SkillsCommons Repository View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Extraction of Resources | Geology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surface & Underground Mine Environment Map (Stylized) - SkillsCommons Repository View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Extraction Methods and Their Impacts

• 

  Extraction of Resources | Geology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surface & Underground Mine Environment Map (Stylized) - SkillsCommons Repository View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surface Mine Environment Map (Stylized) - SkillsCommons Repository View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Extraction of Resources | Geology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Surface & Underground Mine Environment Map (Stylized) - SkillsCommons Repository View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Resource extraction methods vary based on the type of resource being extracted (minerals, fossil fuels, timber) and can have significant environmental impacts on land, water, and air
• Surface mining methods, such as strip mining and open-pit mining, remove large amounts of overburden to access the resource, leading to habitat destruction, deforestation, and soil erosion
  • Mountaintop removal mining, a form of surface mining, alters the topography and hydrology of an area, causing long-term ecological damage
• Underground mining methods, such as room-and-pillar and longwall mining, can cause subsidence, where the ground surface sinks due to the collapse of underground mine workings, affecting surface water and groundwater systems

Consequences of Specific Extraction Techniques

• Hydraulic fracturing (fracking) for oil and gas extraction injects high-pressure fluids into rock formations, which can lead to groundwater contamination, induced seismicity, and methane emissions
• Deforestation for timber extraction leads to biodiversity loss, soil erosion, and increased greenhouse gas emissions due to the loss of carbon sequestration provided by forests
• The disposal of mining waste, such as tailings and overburden, contaminates soil and water resources with heavy metals and other pollutants
  • Tailings dam failures can cause catastrophic environmental damage, as seen in the Brumadinho dam disaster in Brazil (2019) and the Mount Polley mine disaster in Canada (2014)

Balancing Resource Extraction and Conservation

Economic Factors and Environmental Sustainability

• Resource extraction is often driven by economic factors, such as global demand and commodity prices, which can create pressure to prioritize short-term economic gains over long-term environmental sustainability
  • The global demand for rare earth elements, used in high-tech devices and renewable energy technologies, has led to increased mining activity and environmental concerns in countries like China and the United States
• Developing countries may rely heavily on resource extraction for economic growth and poverty reduction, making it challenging to implement strict environmental regulations without impacting livelihoods
  • In many African countries, artisanal and small-scale mining provides a vital source of income for local communities but often occurs with minimal environmental oversight

Challenges in Monitoring and Enforcement

• The lack of comprehensive environmental impact assessments and monitoring can lead to underestimating the full extent of environmental damage caused by resource extraction projects
• Inadequate enforcement of existing environmental regulations and weak governance structures allow resource extraction companies to operate with minimal accountability for environmental damage
• The remote locations of many resource extraction sites make it difficult to monitor and control environmental impacts effectively
  • The Cameia National Park in Angola, home to a diverse array of wildlife, has been threatened by oil exploration activities in recent years, highlighting the challenges of monitoring remote areas

Balancing Stakeholder Interests

• Balancing the rights and interests of local communities, particularly indigenous populations, with resource extraction activities can be challenging, as these communities often bear the brunt of environmental and social impacts
  • The Dongria Kondh tribe in India has been fighting against bauxite mining in the Niyamgiri Hills, which they consider sacred and essential for their livelihoods
• Conflicts between resource extraction companies and local communities can arise due to competing land use priorities, environmental concerns, and the distribution of benefits and costs
  • The construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline in the United States faced strong opposition from the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe and environmental activists, who argued that the pipeline threatened water resources and cultural sites

Effectiveness of Environmental Policies

Environmental Impact Assessments and Permits

• Environmental impact assessments (EIAs) identify and assess the potential environmental consequences of resource extraction projects, but their effectiveness can be limited by inadequate baseline data, lack of public participation, and weak follow-up mechanisms
• Permits and licenses for resource extraction often include conditions related to environmental protection, such as water quality standards, air emission limits, and reclamation requirements, but monitoring and enforcement of these conditions can be inconsistent
  • The Samarco mine disaster in Brazil (2015) highlighted the inadequacy of environmental licensing and monitoring processes, as the tailings dam collapse caused severe environmental damage and loss of life

Financial Assurance and Collaborative Approaches

• Financial assurance mechanisms, such as bonds and insurance, ensure that funds are available for environmental remediation and reclamation, but the adequacy of these mechanisms has been questioned in some cases
  • The cleanup of abandoned mines in the United States has been hindered by insufficient bonding requirements, leaving taxpayers to bear the costs of environmental remediation
• Collaborative approaches, such as multi-stakeholder dialogues and co-management arrangements, can help to build consensus and promote more sustainable resource extraction practices, but their success depends on the willingness of all parties to engage in good faith
  • The Initiative for Responsible Mining Assurance (IRMA) brings together mining companies, civil society organizations, and affected communities to develop and implement best practices for responsible mining

Voluntary Standards and Certification Schemes

• Voluntary sustainability standards and certification schemes, such as the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) for timber products, encourage best practices in resource extraction, but their adoption and impact have been limited
  • The Kimberley Process Certification Scheme aims to prevent the trade of conflict diamonds but has faced criticism for its narrow focus and lack of enforcement mechanisms
• The effectiveness of voluntary standards depends on factors such as consumer demand, market incentives, and the capacity of certification bodies to monitor and verify compliance
  • The Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) has been criticized for its limited impact on reducing deforestation and protecting the rights of indigenous communities in palm oil-producing regions

Technology for Sustainable Resource Extraction

Monitoring and Exploration Technologies

• Remote sensing technologies, such as satellite imagery and drone surveys, improve the monitoring of environmental impacts and support more targeted conservation efforts
  • The use of satellite data has helped to track deforestation rates in the Amazon rainforest and identify illegal logging activities
• Advanced exploration techniques, such as 3D seismic surveys and airborne geophysics, help to identify resource deposits more accurately, reducing the need for extensive drilling and minimizing surface disturbance
  • The application of 3D seismic technology in oil and gas exploration has led to increased success rates and reduced environmental impacts compared to traditional 2D seismic methods

Precision Mining and Waste Management

• Precision mining techniques, such as selective mining and continuous mining, reduce waste generation and improve resource recovery rates, thereby minimizing the overall environmental footprint of mining operations
  • The use of longwall mining in underground coal mines allows for higher resource recovery and reduced surface subsidence compared to room-and-pillar methods
• Recycling and reuse of mining waste, such as using tailings as backfill material or recovering valuable metals from waste streams, reduce the need for new resource extraction and minimize the environmental impact of waste disposal
  • The Bingham Canyon copper mine in Utah, United States, has implemented a comprehensive waste management program that includes the use of tailings as backfill and the recovery of metals from waste rock

Renewable Energy and Water Treatment

• Renewable energy technologies, such as solar and wind power, can be integrated into resource extraction operations to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and improve energy efficiency
  • The Diavik Diamond Mine in Canada has installed a wind farm to supplement its diesel power generation, reducing its carbon footprint and fuel costs
• Water treatment technologies, such as reverse osmosis and bioremediation, help to manage and mitigate the impacts of resource extraction on water resources, ensuring the protection of aquatic ecosystems and human health
  • The use of constructed wetlands and bioreactors has been effective in treating acid mine drainage and removing heavy metals from mining wastewater in various locations worldwide