9.1 Theories of urban growth and development

Urban growth theories explain how cities expand and develop over time. These models consider factors like population growth, economic development, and technological advancements that shape urban landscapes.

Understanding urban spatial structure is crucial for city planning and development. Different theories, from monocentric to polycentric models, offer insights into how cities organize themselves and how land use patterns emerge.

Urban Growth Drivers

Population Growth and Migration

Top images from around the web for Population Growth and Migration

• 

  Demographic Theories | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Urbanization on the Rise | Introductory Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  World Population Growth - Our World in Data View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Demographic Theories | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Urbanization on the Rise | Introductory Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Population Growth and Migration

• 

  Demographic Theories | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Urbanization on the Rise | Introductory Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  World Population Growth - Our World in Data View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Demographic Theories | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Urbanization on the Rise | Introductory Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Population growth, both natural increase and migration, is a primary driver of urban growth and expansion
• Factors influencing population growth include birth rates, death rates, and net migration
  • High birth rates and low death rates contribute to natural population increase
  • Rural-to-urban migration and international migration can significantly impact urban population growth (e.g., rural migrants seeking employment in cities, refugees fleeing conflict)

Economic Development and Industrialization

• Economic development and industrialization attract businesses and jobs to cities, fueling urban growth
• Key economic factors include the growth of manufacturing, service industries, and knowledge-based economies
  • Manufacturing industries often locate in cities to access labor, markets, and transportation networks (e.g., automotive industry in Detroit)
  • Service industries, such as finance, healthcare, and education, cluster in cities to serve urban populations (e.g., financial services in London)
  • Knowledge-based economies, driven by innovation and technology, thrive in cities with skilled labor and research institutions (e.g., tech industry in San Francisco)

Technological Advancements and Infrastructure

• Technological advancements, particularly in transportation and communication, enable cities to grow and expand by increasing accessibility and connectivity
  • Improvements in transportation technology, such as railways, highways, and airports, facilitate the movement of people and goods, enabling urban expansion (e.g., the impact of the Interstate Highway System on U.S. cities)
  • Advancements in communication technology, such as the internet and mobile phones, allow for the decentralization of economic activities and the emergence of remote work, influencing urban growth patterns (e.g., the rise of suburban office parks)

Government Policies and Planning

• Government policies, such as zoning regulations, infrastructure investments, and tax incentives, can significantly influence the pace and direction of urban growth and development
  • Zoning regulations determine land use patterns and the density of development, shaping urban form (e.g., single-family residential zones, mixed-use zones)
  • Infrastructure investments, such as public transportation and utilities, guide urban growth by making certain areas more attractive for development (e.g., the impact of subway extensions on real estate prices)
  • Tax incentives and subsidies can encourage businesses and individuals to locate in specific areas, influencing urban growth patterns (e.g., enterprise zones, homeownership subsidies)

Globalization and Interconnectedness

• Globalization and the increasing interconnectedness of cities through trade, investment, and cultural exchange contribute to urban growth and the emergence of global cities
  • Trade liberalization and the growth of international trade have led to the concentration of economic activities in cities that serve as global hubs (e.g., the role of port cities like Singapore and Rotterdam in global trade networks)
  • Foreign direct investment (FDI) flows into cities, driving urban development and the growth of multinational corporations (e.g., the impact of FDI on the growth of cities like Shanghai and Dubai)
  • Cultural globalization, facilitated by media, tourism, and migration, has led to the emergence of cosmopolitan cities and the growth of cultural industries (e.g., the influence of Hollywood on the growth of Los Angeles)

Urban Spatial Structure Theories

Monocentric City Models

• The Concentric Zone Model, developed by Ernest Burgess, suggests that cities grow outward in concentric rings, with each ring characterized by different land uses and socioeconomic characteristics
  • The model posits a central business district (CBD) surrounded by zones of transition, working-class housing, middle-class housing, and commuter suburbs
  • The model assumes that land use patterns are determined by the distance from the CBD and the ability of different groups to pay for accessibility
• The Sector Model, proposed by Homer Hoyt, argues that cities develop in sectors along transportation routes, with different sectors characterized by distinct land uses and social groups
  • The model suggests that high-income residential areas tend to develop along major transportation corridors, while low-income areas are located in less accessible sectors
  • The model emphasizes the role of transportation in shaping urban structure and land use patterns

Polycentric City Models

• The Multiple Nuclei Model, put forth by Chauncy Harris and Edward Ullman, posits that cities have multiple centers or nuclei of activity, each with its own specialized function and land use pattern
  • The model recognizes that cities may have several specialized districts, such as a CBD, an industrial district, a university district, and suburban shopping centers
  • The model suggests that the location of these nuclei is influenced by factors such as transportation, land suitability, and historical development patterns
• The Bid Rent Theory, based on the work of William Alonso, explains urban land use patterns through the concept of bid rent curves, which represent the amount different land users are willing to pay for accessibility to the city center
  • The theory posits that land use patterns are determined by the trade-off between accessibility and space, with land users who value accessibility (e.g., retail) outbidding those who require more space (e.g., housing)
  • The theory helps explain the formation of land use zones and the gradual decline of land values from the city center to the periphery

Comparing and Contrasting Urban Spatial Structure Theories

• Differences among these models include the assumed shape of urban growth (concentric, sectoral, or nucleated), the role of transportation in shaping urban structure, and the degree of land use specialization
  • The Concentric Zone Model assumes a circular city, while the Sector Model emphasizes linear development along transportation routes
  • The Multiple Nuclei Model recognizes the existence of multiple specialized centers, while the Bid Rent Theory focuses on the trade-off between accessibility and space
• Similarities include the recognition of the city center as a key focal point, the influence of accessibility on land use patterns, and the tendency for different social groups and land uses to cluster together
  • All models acknowledge the importance of the CBD or city center in shaping urban structure
  • The models recognize that accessibility, whether to the CBD or other nuclei, plays a crucial role in determining land use patterns
  • The models suggest that different land uses and social groups tend to cluster together based on their ability to pay for accessibility and their specific locational requirements

Applicability of Urban Growth Theories

Historical and Cultural Context

• The applicability of urban growth theories varies depending on the historical, cultural, and geographic context of the city in question
  • Cities with a long history of urbanization and a strong central planning tradition may more closely resemble the Concentric Zone or Sector Models (e.g., many European cities)
  • Cities with a more organic or unplanned growth pattern may better fit the Multiple Nuclei Model (e.g., many rapidly growing cities in developing countries)
• Local cultural preferences and values can influence urban growth patterns and the applicability of different theories
  • Cities in cultures that prioritize extended family living arrangements may have different residential patterns compared to those in cultures that favor nuclear family households
  • Cities in cultures with strong traditions of public space and communal living may have different land use patterns compared to those in more individualistic cultures

Economic Development and Urbanization

• In developed countries, particularly those with a long history of urbanization, the Concentric Zone and Sector Models may be more applicable, as these cities often have a well-defined central business district and established transportation networks
  • Cities like Chicago and Paris, which experienced significant growth during the industrial era, often exhibit concentric or sectoral patterns of development
  • The Bid Rent Theory may be more applicable in cities with well-functioning land markets and a strong emphasis on accessibility to the city center (e.g., Tokyo, New York)
• In developing countries experiencing rapid urbanization, the Multiple Nuclei Model may be more relevant, as these cities often have multiple centers of activity and less structured land use patterns
  • Cities like Lagos and Manila, which have experienced rapid population growth and informal settlement, may have a more polycentric structure with multiple specialized districts
  • The influence of globalization and foreign investment may lead to the emergence of new urban centers and specialized clusters in developing country cities (e.g., the growth of high-tech clusters in Bangalore and Shenzhen)

Contemporary Urban Forms and Challenges

• The influence of globalization and the rise of polycentric urban forms may limit the applicability of traditional urban growth theories in contemporary cities
  • The emergence of edge cities, suburban employment centers, and mega-regions has challenged the traditional notion of the monocentric city (e.g., the Los Angeles metropolitan area, the Pearl River Delta region in China)
  • The growth of global cities and the increasing importance of inter-city networks has led to the development of new urban growth theories, such as the world city hypothesis and the global city-region concept
• Local factors, such as topography, natural resources, and environmental constraints, can also influence the applicability of urban growth theories in different contexts
  • Cities located in mountainous or coastal areas may have different growth patterns compared to those in flat, inland regions (e.g., the influence of topography on the growth of Rio de Janeiro and Hong Kong)
  • Cities with abundant natural resources, such as oil or minerals, may experience unique growth patterns driven by resource extraction and related industries (e.g., the impact of the oil industry on the growth of Houston and Dubai)

Agglomeration Economies in Urban Development

Localization Economies

• Localization economies arise when firms in the same industry cluster together, benefiting from shared resources, specialized labor pools, and knowledge spillovers
• Examples of localization economies include:
  • The tech industry in Silicon Valley, where firms benefit from access to skilled labor, venture capital, and a culture of innovation
  • The financial sector in London, where banks and other financial institutions cluster together to share information, talent, and infrastructure
  • The fashion industry in Milan, where designers, manufacturers, and retailers benefit from the city's reputation and specialized services
• Localization economies can lead to the formation of specialized industrial districts and contribute to the growth and competitiveness of cities in specific sectors

Urbanization Economies

• Urbanization economies occur when firms from different industries co-locate in cities, benefiting from shared infrastructure, diverse labor markets, and cross-industry interactions
• Large, diverse cities like New York and Tokyo exemplify urbanization economies, offering:
  • A wide range of business services, such as legal, accounting, and marketing firms, that support multiple industries
  • A diverse and skilled labor pool that can adapt to changing economic conditions and support the growth of new industries
  • Opportunities for cross-industry collaboration and innovation, as firms from different sectors interact and share ideas
• Urbanization economies can contribute to the resilience and adaptability of cities, as the diversity of economic activities helps to buffer against sector-specific shocks

Benefits and Challenges of Agglomeration

• Agglomeration economies can lead to increased productivity, innovation, and economic growth in cities by:
  • Facilitating the exchange of ideas and knowledge spillovers among firms and workers
  • Reducing transportation and transaction costs by allowing firms to access suppliers, customers, and labor more efficiently
  • Creating a more efficient labor market, where workers can find jobs that match their skills and firms can find workers with the right expertise
• The presence of agglomeration economies can attract new firms and investments to cities, further driving urban growth and development
  • Cities with strong agglomeration economies may be more attractive to startups, entrepreneurs, and multinational corporations looking to establish a presence in a particular industry or market
  • The concentration of economic activity in cities can also attract skilled workers, leading to further growth and development through human capital accumulation
• However, agglomeration diseconomies, such as congestion, pollution, and high land prices, can emerge as cities grow, potentially limiting the benefits of agglomeration and leading to the decentralization of economic activity
  • As cities become larger and denser, the costs of congestion and pollution may begin to outweigh the benefits of agglomeration, leading to decreased productivity and quality of life
  • High land prices and rents in cities with strong agglomeration economies may push some firms and workers to relocate to more affordable locations, leading to the decentralization of economic activity and the emergence of new urban centers