11.3 Performance Assessment and Authentic Assessment

Performance and authentic assessments measure real-world skills, not just memorized facts. They challenge students to apply knowledge in practical situations, like writing business proposals or conducting experiments. These assessments better reflect true abilities and prepare students for life beyond school.

While more engaging and comprehensive, performance assessments can be time-consuming to create and grade. Rubrics help by clearly defining evaluation criteria. Portfolios and project-based assessments offer even more authentic ways to showcase student growth and mastery over time.

Performance and Authentic Assessment

Evaluating Real-World Skills

Top images from around the web for Evaluating Real-World Skills

• 

  P is for Performance Tasks - Innovation: Education View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Use critical questioning to support your learning – Learning to Learn Online View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Principal's Reflections: Empowering Learners to Think with Performance Tasks View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  P is for Performance Tasks - Innovation: Education View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Use critical questioning to support your learning – Learning to Learn Online View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Evaluating Real-World Skills

• 

  P is for Performance Tasks - Innovation: Education View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Use critical questioning to support your learning – Learning to Learn Online View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A Principal's Reflections: Empowering Learners to Think with Performance Tasks View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  P is for Performance Tasks - Innovation: Education View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Use critical questioning to support your learning – Learning to Learn Online View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Performance assessment measures a student's ability to apply knowledge and skills in a practical, real-world context rather than just recalling information
• Authentic assessment involves tasks that closely resemble real-life challenges and problems students will encounter outside of the classroom (writing a business proposal, conducting a scientific experiment)
• Real-world tasks are the foundation of performance and authentic assessment, requiring students to demonstrate their understanding and competency in meaningful, relevant situations (delivering a persuasive speech, designing a website)
• Competency-based assessment focuses on measuring a student's mastery of specific skills, knowledge, and abilities rather than comparing their performance to other students or arbitrary standards

Benefits and Challenges

• Performance and authentic assessments provide a more comprehensive evaluation of a student's abilities, assessing higher-order thinking skills, problem-solving, and creativity
• These assessments can be more engaging and motivating for students as they see the relevance and application of their learning to real-world situations
• Authentic assessments often involve collaboration, communication, and other essential 21st-century skills, preparing students for future academic and professional challenges
• Designing and implementing performance and authentic assessments can be time-consuming and resource-intensive compared to traditional tests and quizzes
• Ensuring reliability and fairness in scoring can be challenging, as these assessments often involve more subjective evaluation and judgment from the assessor

Rubrics and Scoring

Rubric Design and Purpose

• Rubrics are scoring guides that clearly define the criteria and standards for evaluating student performance on a specific task or assignment
• Rubrics provide a consistent, transparent framework for assessment, helping students understand expectations and enabling teachers to give more objective, detailed feedback
• Effective rubrics break down the assessment into key components or dimensions (organization, content, presentation) and describe the characteristics of performance at different levels of proficiency (novice, intermediate, advanced)
• Rubrics can be designed for a wide range of performance tasks, from essays and presentations to projects and portfolios, ensuring alignment between the assessment and the learning objectives

Holistic and Analytic Scoring

• Holistic scoring involves assigning a single, overall score to a student's performance based on a general impression of their work as a whole
• Holistic rubrics provide a quick, global assessment of a student's performance, focusing on the overall quality and impact rather than specific details or components
• Analytic scoring breaks down the assessment into separate dimensions or criteria, assigning a score for each component and then calculating a total score
• Analytic rubrics provide more detailed, specific feedback on a student's strengths and weaknesses, helping them identify areas for improvement and guiding teachers in targeting instruction and support
• The choice between holistic and analytic scoring depends on the purpose of the assessment, the complexity of the task, and the level of feedback desired (a simple oral presentation might use holistic scoring, while a multi-stage research project would benefit from analytic scoring)

Portfolio and Project-based Assessment

Showcasing Student Growth and Mastery

• Portfolios are purposeful collections of student work that demonstrate their learning progress, achievements, and reflections over time
• Portfolios can include a variety of artifacts, such as writing samples, artwork, videos, and self-assessments, providing a rich, multidimensional view of a student's abilities and growth
• Portfolio assessment allows students to take ownership of their learning, selecting and reflecting on pieces that best showcase their strengths, interests, and areas for improvement
• Portfolios can be used for both formative and summative assessment, informing ongoing instruction and providing evidence of mastery for final evaluation or graduation requirements

Authentic, Collaborative Learning Experiences

• Project-based assessment involves students working on complex, open-ended tasks that require the application of multiple skills and knowledge areas to create a final product or solution
• Project-based learning often involves real-world scenarios, community partnerships, and authentic audiences, increasing student engagement and motivation (designing a city park, creating a public health campaign)
• Projects typically involve collaboration, with students working in teams to plan, research, and execute their work, developing essential social and communication skills
• Project-based assessment allows for differentiation and student choice, as projects can be tailored to individual interests, abilities, and learning styles while still meeting common learning objectives
• Assessing project-based learning involves evaluating both the process and the product, using rubrics, self-reflection, and peer feedback to measure student growth and mastery of key skills and concepts