3.3 Themes of honor, fate, and divine intervention

The Iliad explores the interplay of honor, fate, and divine intervention in shaping human destiny. These themes drive the epic's narrative, influencing characters' choices and the unfolding of events in the Trojan War.

Honor, embodied in concepts like kleos and timē, motivates heroic actions. Meanwhile, fate and divine intervention create a complex web of causality, challenging notions of free will and responsibility in the Homeric world.

Honor in the Homeric World

Kleos and Timē: Foundations of Honor

Top images from around the web for Kleos and Timē: Foundations of Honor

• 

  Greek Mythology/Heroes/Achilles - Wikibooks, open books for an open world View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Homer - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Homeric - Wiktionary, the free dictionary View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Greek Mythology/Heroes/Achilles - Wikibooks, open books for an open world View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Homer - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Kleos and Timē: Foundations of Honor

• 

  Greek Mythology/Heroes/Achilles - Wikibooks, open books for an open world View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Homer - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Homeric - Wiktionary, the free dictionary View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Greek Mythology/Heroes/Achilles - Wikibooks, open books for an open world View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Homer - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Kleos (glory or renown) represents immortality achieved through great deeds and poetic commemoration
  • Heroes strive for kleos as a form of eternal life through memory
  • Examples include Achilles choosing a short, glorious life over a long, unremarkable one
• Timē (honor or respect) functions as a quantifiable commodity in Homeric society
  • Gained or lost through actions and treatment by others
  • Measured by material possessions, social status, and reputation
• Hero's code of conduct emphasizes key components of honor
  • Bravery in battle (aristeia)
  • Loyalty to comrades
  • Pursuit of excellence (aretē)
• Xenia (guest-friendship) operates as a sacred social contract
  • Violation results in severe dishonor and divine punishment
  • Paris's abduction of Helen violates xenia, leading to the Trojan War

Material and Social Aspects of Honor

• Honor often tied to material possessions and prizes
  • Conflict between Achilles and Agamemnon over Briseis exemplifies this connection
  • War prizes (geras) serve as tangible representations of honor
• Tension between personal honor and collective duty recurs throughout the epic
  • Hector balances familial obligations with societal expectations
  • Achilles withdraws from battle to preserve personal honor, impacting the Greek army
• Shame culture drives characters to prioritize public perception
  • Fear of negative judgment (aidos) motivates heroic actions
  • Characters like Ajax take extreme measures to avoid dishonor
• Honor extends beyond individual to family and community
  • Hector fights to defend Troy's honor
  • Priam risks his life to recover Hector's body, preserving family honor

Fate and Destiny in the Iliad

Moira and Prophecy: The Inevitability of Fate

• Moira (fate or portion) represents an immutable force in Greek mythology
  • Even gods cannot alter moira
  • Determines ultimate destiny of mortals and immortals
• Prophecies and omens foreshadow events and influence decisions
  • Prophecy of Achilles' short but glorious life shapes his choices
  • Calchas interprets the omen of the snake and sparrows, predicting the war's duration
• Homeric fate allows for multiple potential outcomes while maintaining inevitability
  • Achilles' choice between long, uneventful life and short, glorious one
  • Characters can make choices within the framework of their ultimate fate
• Zeus's scales symbolize impartial nature of destiny
  • Weighs fates of heroes and armies at pivotal moments
  • Demonstrates the cosmic balance underlying the narrative

Human Agency vs. Predetermined Destiny

• Characters attempt to defy or embrace their fated roles
  • Hector faces Achilles despite knowing likely outcome
  • Patroclus oversteps his bounds, leading to his fated death
• Concept of ate (divine folly or blindness) drives characters to fulfill fated roles
  • Often acts against better judgment or desires
  • Agamemnon attributes his conflict with Achilles to ate
• Interplay between choice and fate creates dramatic tension and moral complexity
  • Questions nature of human agency in a world governed by destiny
  • Explores responsibility for actions when outcomes seem predetermined
• Fate in the Iliad often manifests through human choices and actions
  • Gods may influence but rarely directly control human decisions
  • Characters like Achilles make conscious choices that align with their fate

Divine Intervention in the Iliad

Forms and Mechanisms of Divine Influence

• Gods actively participate in human affairs
  • Take sides in the conflict (Hera and Athena support Greeks, Apollo supports Trojans)
  • Directly influence battles, negotiations, and individual actions
• Physical assistance or hindrance on the battlefield
  • Aphrodite rescues Paris from Menelaus
  • Athena deflects Hector's spear from Achilles
• Various means of communication with mortals
  • Dreams (Zeus sends a false dream to Agamemnon)
  • Omens (bird signs interpreted by seers)
  • Direct appearances (Apollo appears to Hector in the form of his uncle)
• Theomachy (battle of the gods) reflects divine conflicts mirroring human struggles
  • Olympian factions support opposing sides in the Trojan War
  • Divine conflicts on Olympus parallel mortal battles on earth

Purpose and Limitations of Divine Intervention

• Divine intervention often restores balance or enforces cosmic order
  • Zeus's involvement ensures fulfillment of Achilles' honor
  • Gods intervene to maintain the integrity of funeral rites and respect for the dead
• Limitations of divine power explored through inability to control all events
  • Gods cannot save favored heroes from fated deaths (Sarpedon, Patroclus)
  • Zeus cannot prevent the death of his son Sarpedon
• Intervention raises questions about human responsibility and nature of heroism
  • Diomedes' aristeia enhanced by Athena's support
  • Hector's prowess diminished when gods withdraw their favor
• Gods sometimes act as personifications of natural or psychological forces
  • Ares represents the frenzy of battle
  • Aphrodite embodies desire and passion

Human Agency vs Divine Will

Double Determination and Free Will

• Double determination suggests human actions attributed to both choice and divine influence
  • Creates complex interplay between mortal and immortal causality
  • Helen's self-reflection on her role in the war exemplifies this concept
• Characters struggle with extent of their free will
  • Question whether actions are truly their own or manipulated by gods
  • Paris's choice to fight Menelaus influenced by Aphrodite
• Prayer and sacrifice demonstrate human attempts to influence divine will
  • Chryses prays to Apollo for revenge against the Greeks
  • Trojans offer sacrifices to sway the gods in their favor
• Concept of hubris explores consequences of challenging divine authority
  • Ajax the Lesser's defiance of the gods leads to his destruction
  • Achilles' excessive wrath pushes the boundaries of acceptable behavior

Balancing Mortal and Divine Influences

• Divine favoritism impacts human affairs
  • Raises questions about fairness of divine intervention
  • Challenges notion of true heroic achievement in a world of divine influence
• Instances where human determination overcomes divine obstacles
  • Diomedes wounds Aphrodite and Ares in battle
  • Achilles fights the river god Scamander
• Tension between human agency and divine will contributes to tragic elements
  • Characters grapple with roles in a cosmos influenced but not entirely determined by gods
  • Hector's fate sealed by divine decree, yet his choices lead him to that fate
• Epic explores limits of both human and divine power
  • Gods cannot alter fundamental laws of the universe (fate, death)
  • Humans can sometimes resist or subvert divine intentions through force of will or cunning