2.2 Decision-Making Models and Approaches

Ethical decision-making models offer structured approaches to tackle moral dilemmas in accounting. They consider factors like consequences, duties, and virtues, helping accountants navigate complex issues. Different frameworks, from utilitarianism to virtue ethics, provide unique perspectives on ethical challenges.

Applying these models to real accounting scenarios involves identifying key facts, stakeholders, and ethical issues. Accountants must weigh potential consequences, assess professional duties, and consult past cases. Balancing insights from multiple frameworks helps reach well-reasoned judgments in tricky situations.

Ethical Decision-Making Models

Structured Approaches to Analyzing Ethical Dilemmas

Top images from around the web for Structured Approaches to Analyzing Ethical Dilemmas

• 

  Rational Decision Making vs. Other Types of Decision Making | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Decision Making Process | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  8-Step Leadership Decision-Making Process for Making the Best Decisions View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rational Decision Making vs. Other Types of Decision Making | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Decision Making Process | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Structured Approaches to Analyzing Ethical Dilemmas

• 

  Rational Decision Making vs. Other Types of Decision Making | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Decision Making Process | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  8-Step Leadership Decision-Making Process for Making the Best Decisions View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rational Decision Making vs. Other Types of Decision Making | Principles of Management View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Decision Making Process | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Ethical decision-making models provide structured approaches to analyzing and resolving ethical dilemmas
• Consider factors such as consequences, duties, virtues, and principles when making decisions
• Models offer guidance for navigating complex moral issues in accounting practice

Types of Ethical Frameworks

• Consequentialist frameworks (utilitarianism) focus on the outcomes of actions
  • Aim to maximize overall well-being or minimize harm
• Deontological models (Kant's categorical imperative) emphasize adherence to moral duties and rules, regardless of consequences
• Virtue ethics approaches prioritize the development of moral character
  • Exercise virtues like integrity, fairness, and professional judgment
• Casuistry involves drawing upon past cases and precedents to guide decision-making in similar situations
• Pragmatic models (Potter Box) consider the context, values, principles, and loyalties involved in a dilemma to reach a reasoned judgment

Applying Models to Accounting Scenarios

Identifying Relevant Factors

• Identify the relevant facts, stakeholders, and ethical issues in a given accounting situation
• Consider potential consequences of various courses of action on different stakeholders
  • Clients, the public, the profession, and oneself
• Assess duties and obligations of the accountant based on professional codes of conduct, laws and regulations, and ethical principles

Analyzing Scenarios Using Multiple Frameworks

• Analyze the scenario using multiple ethical frameworks to gain different perspectives on the dilemma
• Evaluate actions in light of virtues such as honesty, objectivity, professional competence, and confidentiality
• Consult past cases, precedents, and authoritative guidance to inform the decision-making process
  • Prior rulings from professional bodies (AICPA)
  • Legal precedents related to similar situations
• Reach a reasoned judgment that balances insights from different models and frameworks

Decision-Making Approaches: Strengths vs Limitations

Benefits and Drawbacks of Different Models

• Consequentialist models provide clear guidance when outcomes can be predicted but may neglect other morally relevant factors
• Deontological frameworks offer clear rules for behavior but can lead to moral absolutes that allow no exceptions
  • Prohibition on lying, even if it would prevent harm
• Virtue ethics approaches emphasize character development but may not provide specific action guidance in novel situations
• Casuistry draws upon the wisdom of past decisions but may not adequately address unique features of new cases

Balancing Insights from Multiple Frameworks

• Different models may yield conflicting guidance, requiring the decision-maker to balance insights from multiple frameworks
• Pragmatic models consider multiple perspectives but may not resolve conflicts between competing values and loyalties
  • Duties to clients vs. duties to the public interest
• Combining elements of different approaches can provide a more comprehensive analysis of ethical dilemmas

Personal Framework for Ethical Decisions

Developing a Structured Decision-Making Process

• Reflect on personal and professional values, principles, and virtues that should guide decision-making
• Identify key elements of different decision-making models that resonate with one's own moral philosophy and professional identity
• Develop a structured process for analyzing ethical dilemmas, drawing upon strengths of multiple models and frameworks
  • Gathering relevant facts
  • Identifying stakeholders and their interests
  • Applying ethical principles and professional standards
  • Considering consequences and duties
  • Exercising professional judgment

Ongoing Professional Development and Refinement

• Consider the role of consultation with colleagues, professional bodies, and other resources in informing the decision-making process
• Recognize the importance of professional judgment, practical wisdom, and moral courage in resolving complex dilemmas
• Commit to ongoing professional development, including education in ethics and exposure to diverse perspectives on moral issues in accounting
  • Continuing education courses on ethics
  • Participation in professional organizations and discussions
• Regularly review and refine personal framework based on experience, feedback, and developments in professional standards and best practices