Processor architectures are the backbone of Exascale Computing. CPUs, GPUs, and accelerators each bring unique strengths to the table, enabling massive computational power for complex scientific problems. Understanding these architectures is crucial for designing efficient systems that can handle the demands of Exascale Computing.
From instruction-level parallelism in CPUs to the massively of GPUs, each architecture offers distinct advantages. Accelerators provide specialized processing for targeted workloads. As we push towards Exascale, future trends like near-memory and neuromorphic computing promise even greater capabilities.
Processor architectures overview
Processor architectures are a critical component of Exascale Computing, as they determine the capabilities and performance of the computing systems used for large-scale simulations and data analysis
Understanding the differences between CPUs, GPUs, and accelerators is essential for designing efficient and scalable Exascale systems that can handle the massive computational demands of complex scientific and engineering problems
The choice of processor architecture has significant implications for power consumption, memory bandwidth, and programmability, which are key considerations in Exascale Computing
CPUs vs GPUs vs accelerators
Top images from around the web for CPUs vs GPUs vs accelerators
ECS 154B: Computer Architecture | Index View original
Is this image relevant?
ECS 154B: Computer Architecture | Index View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 1
Top images from around the web for CPUs vs GPUs vs accelerators
ECS 154B: Computer Architecture | Index View original
Is this image relevant?
ECS 154B: Computer Architecture | Index View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 1
CPUs (Central Processing Units) are general-purpose processors designed for a wide range of computing tasks, offering flexibility and compatibility with existing software (x86, ARM)
GPUs (Graphics Processing Units) are specialized processors originally designed for graphics rendering but have evolved to handle parallel computing workloads, providing high for data-parallel tasks (NVIDIA, AMD)
Accelerators are purpose-built processors designed to accelerate specific types of workloads, such as machine learning or signal processing, and can offer significant performance gains for targeted applications (Google TPU, Phi)
CPU architectures
architectures have evolved to improve performance through various techniques, such as instruction-level parallelism, out-of-order execution, and multi-core designs
These advancements have enabled CPUs to handle more complex and diverse workloads, making them a critical component in Exascale Computing systems
However, the scalability of CPU architectures for Exascale Computing is limited by power consumption and memory bandwidth constraints
Instruction-level parallelism
Instruction-level parallelism (ILP) is a technique that allows multiple instructions to be executed simultaneously within a single CPU core
ILP is achieved through techniques such as pipelining, which overlaps the execution of multiple instructions, and superscalar execution, which allows multiple instructions to be issued and executed in parallel
VLIW (Very Long Instruction Word) architectures (Itanium)
Out-of-order execution
Out-of-order execution is a technique that allows a CPU to execute instructions in a different order than they appear in the program, based on the availability of data and resources
This technique helps to minimize pipeline stalls and improve overall performance by allowing the CPU to continue executing instructions while waiting for data dependencies to be resolved
Examples of out-of-order execution include:
Tomasulo's algorithm
Scoreboarding
Branch prediction
Branch prediction is a technique used by CPUs to predict the outcome of conditional branches in a program, allowing the processor to speculatively execute instructions along the predicted path
Accurate branch prediction can significantly improve performance by reducing pipeline stalls caused by branch mispredictions
Examples of branch prediction techniques include:
Static branch prediction (always taken, always not taken)
Speculative execution is a technique that allows a CPU to execute instructions before it is known whether they will be needed, based on branch predictions or other heuristics
If the speculation is correct, the results are committed, and execution continues normally; if the speculation is incorrect, the results are discarded, and execution resumes from the correct path
Examples of speculative execution include:
Branch prediction-based speculation
Load-store speculation
Multi-core designs
Multi-core designs involve integrating multiple CPU cores onto a single chip, allowing for parallel execution of multiple threads or processes
Multi-core architectures have become prevalent in Exascale Computing systems, as they offer improved performance and energy efficiency compared to single-core designs
Examples of multi-core CPU architectures include:
Intel Xeon (up to 28 cores)
AMD EPYC (up to 64 cores)
Cache hierarchies
Cache hierarchies are used in CPU architectures to bridge the performance gap between the processor and main memory by storing frequently accessed data in faster, smaller memory closer to the processor
Modern CPUs typically employ multiple levels of cache (L1, L2, L3), with each level offering a different balance of capacity and access
Examples of cache hierarchy designs include:
Inclusive cache hierarchies (all data in lower levels is also present in higher levels)
Exclusive cache hierarchies (data is present in only one level of the hierarchy)
Interconnects
Interconnects are the communication channels that allow CPU cores, caches, and other components to exchange data and control signals
The design of interconnects is critical for the performance and scalability of multi-core CPU architectures, as they can impact memory access latency and bandwidth
architectures are designed for massively parallel processing, making them well-suited for data-parallel workloads commonly found in scientific computing, machine learning, and computer graphics
GPUs have become increasingly important in Exascale Computing systems, as they offer high performance and energy efficiency for many computational tasks
However, programming GPUs can be more challenging than CPUs due to their specialized architectures and programming models
Massively parallel processing
GPUs are designed for massively parallel processing, with hundreds or thousands of simple processing cores that can execute many threads simultaneously
This architecture allows GPUs to achieve high throughput for data-parallel workloads, where the same operation is applied to many data elements independently
Examples of massively parallel GPU architectures include:
NVIDIA Ampere (up to 6912 cores)
AMD CDNA 2 (up to 7680 stream processors)
SIMT execution model
GPUs employ a Single Instruction, Multiple Thread () execution model, where a single instruction is executed by multiple threads in parallel
The SIMT model allows GPUs to efficiently process data-parallel workloads by exploiting the inherent parallelism in the application
Examples of SIMT programming models include:
NVIDIA CUDA (Compute Unified Device Architecture)
(Open Computing Language)
Streaming multiprocessors
GPUs are organized into streaming multiprocessors (SMs), which are the basic building blocks of the GPU architecture
Each SM contains multiple processing cores, shared memory, and cache, allowing for efficient execution of parallel threads
Examples of streaming multiprocessor designs include:
NVIDIA Streaming Multiprocessor (SM)
AMD Compute Unit (CU)
Memory subsystems
GPU memory subsystems are designed to provide high bandwidth and low latency access to data for the massively parallel processing cores
GPUs typically employ a hierarchical memory structure, with global memory, shared memory, and cache levels optimized for different access patterns
Examples of GPU memory subsystems include:
NVIDIA HBM2 (High Bandwidth Memory)
AMD GDDR6 (Graphics Double Data Rate)
Compute vs graphics workloads
While GPUs were originally designed for graphics workloads, they have evolved to handle general-purpose compute workloads as well
Compute workloads often have different requirements than graphics workloads, such as higher precision arithmetic and more complex memory access patterns
Examples of compute-focused GPU architectures include:
(dedicated compute GPUs)
AMD Instinct (accelerators for HPC and AI)
Accelerator architectures
architectures are specialized processors designed to accelerate specific types of workloads, such as machine learning, signal processing, or cryptography
These architectures offer significant performance and energy efficiency gains for targeted applications, making them attractive for Exascale Computing systems
However, the specialized nature of accelerators can limit their flexibility and require significant effort to port existing applications
Domain-specific designs
Accelerators are often designed for specific domains, such as machine learning or signal processing, allowing them to be optimized for the unique requirements of those workloads
Domain-specific designs can offer significant performance and energy efficiency gains compared to general-purpose processors
Examples of domain-specific accelerators include:
Google Tensor Processing Unit (TPU) for machine learning
Intel Movidius VPU (Vision Processing Unit) for computer vision
FPGAs for acceleration
Field-Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) are reconfigurable devices that can be programmed to implement custom hardware accelerators
FPGAs offer flexibility and adaptability, allowing them to be optimized for specific workloads and updated as requirements change
Examples of -based accelerators include:
Xilinx Alveo (adaptable accelerator cards)
Intel Stratix 10 (high-performance FPGAs)
ASICs for acceleration
Application-Specific Integrated Circuits (ASICs) are custom-designed chips that are optimized for a specific task or application
ASICs offer the highest performance and energy efficiency for the targeted workload but are less flexible and more expensive to develop than other accelerator options
Google TPU (Tensor Processing Unit) for machine learning
Coupling with host processors
Accelerators are typically coupled with host processors (CPUs) to form a system, where the CPU manages overall system resources and offloads specific tasks to the accelerator
The choice of coupling method (e.g., PCIe, NVLink, CXL) can impact the performance and efficiency of the overall system
Examples of accelerator coupling technologies include:
PCIe (Peripheral Component Interconnect Express)
NVIDIA NVLink (high-bandwidth interconnect for GPUs)
Memory considerations
Accelerators often have their own dedicated memory subsystems, which can have different capacity, bandwidth, and latency characteristics than the host processor's memory
Efficient data movement between the host and accelerator memories is crucial for overall system performance and requires careful consideration of data layouts and transfer methods
Examples of accelerator memory technologies include:
HBM (High Bandwidth Memory) for GPUs and FPGAs
GDDR6 (Graphics Double Data Rate) for GPUs
Heterogeneous computing
Heterogeneous computing refers to the use of multiple types of processors (e.g., CPUs, GPUs, accelerators) within a single computing system to leverage their unique strengths and capabilities
Heterogeneous architectures are becoming increasingly common in Exascale Computing systems, as they offer the potential for improved performance, energy efficiency, and adaptability to diverse workloads
However, heterogeneous computing also introduces challenges in programming, resource management, and system integration
CPU-GPU collaboration
CPU-GPU collaboration involves the cooperative use of CPUs and GPUs to accelerate applications, with the CPU handling control flow and serial tasks while the GPU handles data-parallel tasks
Effective CPU-GPU collaboration requires careful partitioning of the workload, efficient data transfer between the processors, and synchronization of their execution
Examples of CPU-GPU collaboration frameworks include:
NVIDIA CUDA Streams (concurrent execution of CPU and GPU tasks)
OpenCL (open standard for heterogeneous computing)
Accelerator integration
Accelerator integration refers to the process of incorporating specialized accelerators (e.g., FPGAs, ASICs) into a computing system and enabling their use by applications
Effective accelerator integration requires well-defined interfaces, drivers, and programming models that allow applications to leverage the accelerator's capabilities
Examples of accelerator integration technologies include:
Intel OneAPI (unified programming model for heterogeneous computing)
Xilinx Vitis (development platform for FPGA-based accelerators)
Unified memory architectures
Unified memory architectures provide a single, coherent memory space that is accessible by all processors in a heterogeneous system, simplifying programming and reducing the need for explicit data transfers
Unified memory can be implemented through hardware support (e.g., shared physical memory) or software techniques (e.g., virtual memory, memory mapping)
Examples of unified memory technologies include:
NVIDIA Unified Memory (single memory space for CPUs and GPUs)
Heterogeneous System Architecture (HSA) (industry standard for heterogeneous computing)
Programming models
Programming models for heterogeneous computing provide abstractions and tools that allow developers to express parallelism and leverage the capabilities of different processors
Effective programming models should balance performance, portability, and productivity, while providing mechanisms for data movement, synchronization, and resource management
Examples of programming models for heterogeneous computing include:
NVIDIA CUDA (Compute Unified Device Architecture)
OpenMP (Open Multi-Processing)
Performance considerations
Achieving high performance in Exascale Computing systems requires careful consideration of various factors, such as the balance between compute and memory capabilities, the trade-offs between latency and throughput, and the scalability of the system
Performance optimization for heterogeneous architectures can be challenging, as it requires an understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of each processor type and the ability to map workloads effectively to the appropriate resources
Key performance metrics for Exascale Computing systems include floating-point operations per second (), memory bandwidth, and
Compute-bound vs memory-bound
Applications can be classified as either compute-bound or memory-bound, depending on whether their performance is limited by the available computational resources or memory bandwidth
Compute-bound applications require high-performance processors with many cores and fast clock speeds, while memory-bound applications require high-bandwidth memory subsystems and efficient data movement
Examples of compute-bound applications include:
Dense matrix multiplication
Fluid dynamics simulations
Latency vs throughput
Latency and throughput are two key performance metrics for computing systems, with latency measuring the time required to complete a single task and throughput measuring the number of tasks completed per unit time
Different processors and architectures may prioritize latency or throughput, depending on their design and the target workloads
Examples of latency-sensitive applications include:
Online transaction processing (OLTP)
Real-time control systems
Scalability challenges
Scalability refers to the ability of a computing system to maintain performance as the problem size or number of processors increases
Exascale Computing systems face significant scalability challenges, such as managing communication and synchronization overhead, load balancing, and fault tolerance
Examples of scalability bottlenecks include:
Communication latency and bandwidth limitations
Amdahl's Law (diminishing returns from parallelization)
Power efficiency
Power efficiency is a critical concern for Exascale Computing systems, as the energy costs of operating large-scale systems can be substantial
Improving power efficiency requires a combination of hardware and software techniques, such as dynamic voltage and frequency scaling (DVFS), power-aware scheduling, and energy-efficient algorithms
Examples of power-efficient processor architectures include:
ARM big.LITTLE (heterogeneous multi-core architecture)
Intel Lakefield (hybrid CPU architecture)
Future architectural trends
As Exascale Computing systems continue to evolve, new architectural trends and technologies are emerging to address the challenges of performance, power efficiency, and programmability
These trends include the integration of novel computing paradigms, such as near-memory computing and neuromorphic computing, as well as the exploration of new materials and devices, such as quantum computing
The adoption of these technologies will require significant research and development efforts, as well as the evolution of programming models and system software to support their integration
Near-memory computing
Near-memory computing (NMC) is an architectural approach that aims to reduce the performance and energy costs of data movement by placing computation closer to memory
NMC can be implemented through various techniques, such as processing-in-memory (PIM), where computation is performed directly in memory devices, or through the use of 3D-stacked memory with integrated logic
Examples of near-memory computing technologies include:
Hybrid Memory Cube (HMC)
High Bandwidth Memory (HBM) with in-memory processing
Neuromorphic computing
Neuromorphic computing is an approach that seeks to emulate the structure and function of biological neural networks in hardware, with the goal of achieving high energy efficiency and adaptability
Neuromorphic processors typically consist of large arrays of simple, interconnected processing elements that communicate through spikes, similar to neurons in the brain
Examples of neuromorphic computing platforms include:
Intel Loihi (research chip for spiking neural networks)
IBM TrueNorth (brain-inspired computing architecture)
Quantum computing potential
Quantum computing is an emerging paradigm that harnesses the principles of quantum mechanics to perform certain computations much faster than classical computers
While still in the early stages of development, quantum computers have the potential to accelerate certain tasks relevant to Exascale Computing, such as optimization, machine learning, and molecular simulations
Examples of quantum computing technologies include: