10.2 Patricia Hill Collins' matrix of domination

Patricia Hill Collins' matrix of domination expands on intersectionality, examining how power systems overlap and reinforce each other. It operates through four domains: structural, disciplinary, hegemonic, and interpersonal. This framework provides a deeper understanding of oppression at both individual and societal levels.

The matrix of domination allows for nuanced analysis of resistance and social change. It recognizes that progress in one domain may not translate to others, highlighting the complex nature of power dynamics. This approach offers insights into how marginalized groups can challenge oppression across multiple levels simultaneously.

Matrix of Domination and Power

Four Domains of Power

Top images from around the web for Four Domains of Power

• 

  Oppression and Power – Introduction to Community Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Four Domains of Public Value Creation: A Core Typology - Research leap View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Role of Senior Leaders in Building a Race Equity Culture | Bridgespan View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Oppression and Power – Introduction to Community Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Four Domains of Public Value Creation: A Core Typology - Research leap View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Four Domains of Power

• 

  Oppression and Power – Introduction to Community Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Four Domains of Public Value Creation: A Core Typology - Research leap View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Role of Senior Leaders in Building a Race Equity Culture | Bridgespan View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Oppression and Power – Introduction to Community Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Four Domains of Public Value Creation: A Core Typology - Research leap View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Matrix of domination sociological paradigm developed by Patricia Hill Collins describes how systems of power and oppression intersect and reinforce each other
• Operates through four interconnected domains of power
  • Structural domain organizes social institutions to reproduce oppression over time (laws, policies, economic systems)
  • Disciplinary domain manages and controls oppressed populations through bureaucratic hierarchies and surveillance techniques
  • Hegemonic domain encompasses cultural sphere, including ideology and consciousness, normalizing oppression through dominant narratives
  • Interpersonal domain focuses on everyday interactions and individual experiences of oppression in personal lives and relationships
• Domains interact and reinforce each other, creating complex systems of oppression
• Examples of domain interactions:
  • Structural laws (Jim Crow) reinforced by disciplinary policing practices
  • Hegemonic stereotypes (welfare queen) influence interpersonal discrimination

Application and Analysis

• Framework provides tools for analyzing power dynamics across different social contexts
• Allows examination of how individuals may experience both oppression and privilege within different domains
• Useful for understanding how resistance and social change can occur within and across domains
• Highlights importance of addressing oppression at multiple levels simultaneously
• Can be applied to various forms of oppression (racism, sexism, classism, homophobia)
• Examples of application:
  • Analyzing how workplace policies (structural) intersect with office culture (hegemonic) to create hostile environments for marginalized groups
  • Examining how educational curricula (disciplinary) reinforce societal stereotypes (hegemonic) about certain racial or ethnic groups

Intersectionality vs Domination

Expanding on Intersectionality

• Matrix of domination builds upon Kimberlé Crenshaw's concept of intersectionality
• Provides more comprehensive framework for understanding multiple systems of oppression
• Examines oppression at institutional and societal levels, beyond individual experiences
• Emphasizes importance of context and shifting power relations across social settings and historical periods
• Examples of expanded analysis:
  • Examining how race and gender intersect in workplace discrimination (individual level) while also analyzing broader economic policies and cultural norms (institutional level)
  • Investigating how immigration status intersects with language barriers in healthcare access, considering both personal experiences and systemic issues

Dynamic Analysis of Power and Change

• Framework allows for more nuanced understanding of resistance and empowerment
• Recognizes progress in one domain may not necessarily translate to others
• Provides insights into how social change occurs across different domains of power
• Highlights potential for both oppression and privilege within different domains based on social location
• Examples of dynamic analysis:
  • Examining how legal victories for marginalized groups (structural domain) may not immediately change cultural attitudes (hegemonic domain)
  • Analyzing how grassroots movements (interpersonal domain) can influence policy changes (structural domain) over time

Self-Definition and Resistance

Processes of Self-Definition and Self-Valuation

• Self-definition process by which marginalized individuals and groups create own identities and narratives
• Rejects externally imposed stereotypes and labels
• Self-valuation develops positive sense of self-worth and affirms own experiences and knowledge
• Counteracts societal devaluation of marginalized groups
• Crucial acts of resistance against oppressive systems seeking to define and devalue marginalized groups
• Examples:
  • Black women rejecting Eurocentric beauty standards and embracing natural hair
  • LGBTQ+ individuals creating chosen families and communities that affirm their identities

Importance for Marginalized Groups

• Particularly significant for multiply marginalized groups facing intersecting forms of oppression
• Allows individuals to challenge dominant narratives and create alternative ways of knowing and being
• Validates experiences often dismissed or ignored by mainstream society
• Collective self-definition and self-valuation can lead to development of group consciousness and solidarity
• Essential for social movements and political activism
• Often occurs in "safe spaces" where marginalized individuals can freely express themselves and support one another
• Examples:
  • Formation of Black feminist reading groups to discuss and validate shared experiences
  • Creation of online communities for disabled individuals to share resources and support

Controlling Images and Marginalization

Functions and Impact of Controlling Images

• Controlling images stereotypical representations of marginalized groups used to justify and maintain systems of oppression
• Pervasive in media, literature, and popular culture
• Shape societal perceptions and influence policy decisions
• Serve multiple functions within matrix of domination:
  • Normalize oppression
  • Justify unequal treatment
  • Limit opportunities for marginalized groups
• Intersect with multiple axes of oppression, reinforcing racist, sexist, classist, and other discriminatory ideologies simultaneously
• Internalization by marginalized individuals can lead to self-doubt, lowered self-esteem, and internalized oppression
• Examples:
  • "Model minority" myth limiting opportunities and support for Asian Americans
  • Hypersexualized images of Latinx women in media contributing to workplace harassment

Resistance and Counter-Narratives

• Resistance to controlling images involves creating and promoting counter-narratives
• Importance of authentic representations and diverse portrayals of marginalized groups
• Efforts to challenge stereotypes in various cultural and institutional spaces
• Development of alternative media platforms and cultural productions
• Advocacy for increased representation in decision-making positions
• Education and awareness campaigns to deconstruct harmful stereotypes
• Examples:
  • #OscarsSoWhite campaign highlighting lack of diversity in film industry
  • Indigenous filmmakers creating documentaries to challenge stereotypical portrayals in mainstream media