13.4 Writing and Discussing Film Aesthetics

Film aesthetics shape our understanding and appreciation of cinema. In this section, we'll explore how to write and discuss film aesthetics effectively, focusing on structure, evidence, and key concepts.

We'll cover the importance of clear thesis statements, logical organization, and relevant evidence in film analysis. We'll also delve into essential terminology and concepts, helping you engage in thoughtful discussions about cinematic techniques and their impact.

Writing About Film Aesthetics

Structure of film aesthetic arguments

Top images from around the web for Structure of film aesthetic arguments

• 

  Video: The Toulmin Model | Basic Reading and Writing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Narrative Argument - Excelsior OWL View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Constructing the Thesis and Argument—From the Ground Up – UNM Core Writing OER Collection View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Video: The Toulmin Model | Basic Reading and Writing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Narrative Argument - Excelsior OWL View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Structure of film aesthetic arguments

• 

  Video: The Toulmin Model | Basic Reading and Writing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Narrative Argument - Excelsior OWL View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Constructing the Thesis and Argument—From the Ground Up – UNM Core Writing OER Collection View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Video: The Toulmin Model | Basic Reading and Writing View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Narrative Argument - Excelsior OWL View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Formulate a clear thesis statement encapsulates main argument
  • Ensure thesis is specific, arguable, and relevant to film's aesthetics (Citizen Kane's innovative cinematography revolutionized Hollywood filmmaking)
• Organize essay with logical structure
  • Include introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion
  • Use topic sentences to introduce main idea of each paragraph (The deep focus technique in Citizen Kane allows multiple planes of action to remain in focus simultaneously)
  • Ensure each paragraph supports and develops thesis
• Use transitions to connect ideas and maintain coherence throughout essay
  • Employ transitional phrases and sentences to link paragraphs and sections (Furthermore, the low-angle shots in Citizen Kane emphasize the characters' power dynamics)
• Conclude essay by reiterating main points and thesis
  • Provide sense of closure and reinforce significance of argument (Citizen Kane's groundbreaking aesthetics have left an indelible mark on cinema history)

Evidence in film analysis

• Identify relevant scenes, shots, or dialogue that support argument
  • Choose examples directly relate to thesis and main points (The opening shot of Citizen Kane introduces the central mystery surrounding the protagonist's last words)
• Describe selected evidence in detail
  • Provide context for scene or shot (The scene takes place in Kane's opulent Xanadu mansion)
  • Analyze visual and auditory elements, such as cinematography, mise-en-scène, or sound design (The deep focus cinematography in this scene allows the audience to see Kane in the foreground and his staff in the background, emphasizing his isolation)
• Explain how evidence supports interpretation and analysis
  • Connect examples to thesis and main points (This scene demonstrates how Welles uses innovative cinematography to convey Kane's psychological state)
  • Demonstrate how evidence illustrates film's aesthetic choices and their impact on viewer (The juxtaposition of Kane's wealth and his emotional isolation in this scene underscores the film's themes of power and loneliness)

Discussing Film Aesthetics

Film terminology and concepts

• Familiarize yourself with essential film terminology
  • Cinematography terms: shot types (close-up, medium shot), camera angles (high angle, low angle), lighting (high-key, low-key), color (monochromatic, saturated)
  • Mise-en-scène elements: setting (interior, exterior), costume (period-appropriate, symbolic), makeup (aging, transformative), props (meaningful objects), actor placement (blocking, proxemics)
  • Editing concepts: cuts (jump cut, match cut), transitions (dissolve, wipe), montage (intellectual montage), rhythm (slow-paced, fast-paced)
  • Sound design components: diegetic sound (dialogue, sound effects), non-diegetic sound (score, voiceover), music (leitmotif), dialogue (overlapping, silence)
• Apply appropriate terminology when analyzing specific aspects of film
  • Use precise terms to describe visual and auditory elements (The low-key lighting in this scene creates a sense of mystery and unease)
  • Demonstrate understanding of how these elements contribute to film's aesthetics and meaning (The rapid montage sequence conveys the protagonist's mental state and heightens the tension)
• Incorporate film concepts and theories when relevant
  • Apply concepts such as auteur theory (Welles as an auteur in Citizen Kane), genre conventions (film noir elements in Blade Runner), or formalism (Eisenstein's theories of montage) when appropriate
  • Explain how these concepts relate to film's aesthetics and your argument (Welles's auteur status is evident in Citizen Kane's innovative use of cinematography and storytelling techniques)

Discussions of film aesthetics

• Listen actively to others' viewpoints and interpretations
  • Pay attention to their arguments and evidence they present
  • Seek to understand their perspective, even if it differs from your own (I see your point about the use of color in this scene, but I interpreted it differently)
• Respond thoughtfully and respectfully to others' ideas
  • Acknowledge merits of their arguments (That's an interesting observation about the film's use of sound)
  • Build upon their points or offer alternative interpretations (Building on your point, I think the sound design also contributes to the film's overall theme of isolation)
• Support your own perspective with evidence and reasoning
  • Refer to specific examples from film to support viewpoint (The recurring visual motif of the snowglobe in Citizen Kane symbolizes Kane's longing for his lost childhood)
  • Explain interpretation clearly and logically (This motif appears at key moments throughout the film, suggesting its significance to Kane's character development)
• Be open to reconsidering your own interpretation based on others' insights
  • Embrace opportunity to learn from diverse perspectives (I hadn't considered that perspective before, but it makes sense given the historical context of the film's production)
  • Adjust understanding of film's aesthetics when presented with compelling arguments or evidence (After discussing it further, I can see how the film's ending could be interpreted differently)