12.3 The League of Nations

The League of Nations emerged as a bold attempt to prevent future wars after World War I. Championed by US President Woodrow Wilson, it aimed to maintain peace through collective security, disarmament, and international cooperation.

Despite its lofty goals, the League faced significant challenges. Lacking its own military and hampered by the absence of major powers like the US, it struggled to prevent aggression and ultimately failed to stop World War II.

League of Nations' Purpose and Goals

Founding Principles and Objectives

Top images from around the web for Founding Principles and Objectives

• 

  File:Origin of the League of Nations.png - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fourteen Points - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  League of Nations - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Origin of the League of Nations.png - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fourteen Points - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Founding Principles and Objectives

• 

  File:Origin of the League of Nations.png - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fourteen Points - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  League of Nations - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Origin of the League of Nations.png - Wikimedia Commons View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fourteen Points - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Established in 1920 as first international organization dedicated to maintaining world peace and security through collective action
• President Woodrow Wilson's Fourteen Points, particularly Point 14, provided foundational concept for League of Nations
• Aimed to prevent future wars through disarmament, negotiation, and arbitration of international disputes
• Promoted collective security with member nations agreeing to defend each other against aggression
• Sought to impose economic sanctions on nations violating international agreements
• Encouraged international cooperation in various fields (labor conditions, treatment of native inhabitants, human trafficking, drug trafficking)

Mandate System and Global Governance

• Oversaw administration of territories, colonies, and defeated nations through mandate system
• Divided former Ottoman and German colonies into three classes of mandates (A, B, C) based on level of development
• Class A mandates (Iraq, Palestine, Transjordan) considered nearly ready for independence
• Class B mandates (Tanganyika, Cameroons) required more oversight and development
• Class C mandates (South West Africa, New Guinea) deemed to need long-term administration
• Mandates aimed to promote self-governance and eventual independence of territories

Peacekeeping and Conflict Resolution

• Established mechanisms for peaceful settlement of disputes between nations
• Created framework for international arbitration and mediation
• Encouraged diplomatic negotiations to resolve conflicts before escalation
• Implemented economic sanctions as non-military means of pressuring aggressive states
• Sought to prevent arms races through disarmament conferences (Washington Naval Conference, 1921-1922)
• Aimed to create transparent system of international relations to prevent secret alliances

League of Nations' Structure and Bodies

Principal Organs and Decision-Making

• Assembly served as League's primary deliberative body
  • All member states had equal representation
  • Met annually to discuss global issues
  • Elected non-permanent members of the Council
  • Approved League's budget and admitted new members
• Council acted as executive body
  • Initially composed of four permanent members (Britain, France, Italy, Japan) and four non-permanent members
  • Later expanded to include additional permanent and non-permanent members
  • Met more frequently than Assembly to address urgent matters
  • Decisions required unanimous agreement, often leading to paralysis
• Permanent Secretariat handled League's administrative functions
  • Headed by Secretary-General
  • Prepared reports on international issues
  • Organized conferences and maintained League records

Judicial and Specialized Bodies

• Permanent Court of International Justice served as League's judicial branch
  • Established to settle international disputes
  • Precursor to modern International Court of Justice
  • Issued advisory opinions on legal questions referred by League organs
• Technical organizations and committees addressed specific global issues
  • International Labor Organization promoted workers' rights and fair labor practices
  • Health Organization tackled global health challenges (malaria, tuberculosis)
  • Permanent Central Opium Board monitored international drug trade
  • Nansen International Office for Refugees assisted displaced persons

Constitutional Framework

• League operated under Covenant, its constitutional document
• Covenant outlined League's structure, procedures, and principles
• Article 10 committed members to respect territorial integrity of other members
• Article 16 provided for collective action against aggressors
• Articles 8 and 9 addressed disarmament and arms control
• Article 22 established mandate system for former colonies
• Amendments to Covenant required ratification by all Council members and majority of Assembly

League of Nations' Strengths vs Weaknesses

Diplomatic Achievements and Humanitarian Work

• Successfully resolved minor territorial disputes in early years
  • Aaland Islands dispute between Sweden and Finland (1920)
  • Upper Silesia conflict between Germany and Poland (1921)
• Established framework for international cooperation and diplomacy
  • Set precedent for future global organizations (United Nations)
  • Promoted regular meetings between world leaders
• Technical organizations made significant contributions
  • Assisted over 400,000 prisoners of war to return home
  • Helped relocate 1.5 million refugees after World War I
  • Combated epidemic diseases (typhus in Eastern Europe)
  • Improved working conditions through International Labor Organization

Structural and Operational Limitations

• Lacked independent military force for enforcement actions
  • Relied on member states to provide troops, often leading to inaction
  • Unable to intervene effectively in major conflicts
• Absence of major powers undermined League's authority
  • United States never joined, weakening League's global influence
  • Germany admitted only in 1926, Soviet Union in 1934
  • Japan and Germany withdrew in 1933, Italy in 1937
• Principle of unanimity in decision-making often paralyzed League
  • Any Council member could veto resolutions
  • Made swift action in crises difficult or impossible

Failures in Conflict Prevention and Resolution

• Failed to prevent major acts of aggression
  • Japanese invasion of Manchuria (1931)
  • Italian conquest of Ethiopia (1935-1936)
  • German remilitarization of Rhineland (1936)
• Economic sanctions proved ineffective without universal participation
  • Sanctions against Italy during Ethiopian crisis poorly enforced
  • Lack of oil embargo allowed Italy to continue military operations
• Unable to prevent outbreak of World War II
  • Failed to stop German annexation of Austria and Czechoslovakia
  • Powerless to intervene in Spanish Civil War (1936-1939)
• Exposed limitations in enforcing collective security principle
  • Member states often prioritized national interests over collective action
  • Lack of will to confront aggressors emboldened expansionist powers

US Non-Participation in the League

Political Opposition and Treaty Rejection

• United States Senate rejected Treaty of Versailles, which included League Covenant
• Republican opposition led by Senator Henry Cabot Lodge
  • Lodge proposed reservations to treaty to protect US sovereignty
  • Clash between Lodge and President Wilson led to partisan divide
• Senate voted against treaty ratification twice (November 1919, March 1920)
• Wilson's failure to include prominent Republicans in treaty negotiations contributed to lack of support

Sovereignty and Foreign Policy Concerns

• Concerns over potential loss of sovereignty to international body
  • Fear of League decisions overriding US Constitution
  • Worries about League interfering in domestic affairs
• Article X of League Covenant particularly controversial
  • Obligated members to preserve territorial integrity of other members
  • Seen as threat to US autonomy in foreign policy decisions
• Concerns over congressional war powers being compromised
  • Constitution gives Congress power to declare war
  • League membership perceived as potentially bypassing this authority

Isolationist Sentiment and Domestic Politics

• Fear of entanglement in European affairs influenced public opinion
• Desire to maintain America's traditional policy of isolationism
  • Rooted in George Washington's Farewell Address warning against foreign alliances
  • Strengthened by disillusionment with outcomes of World War I
• Domestic political factors contributed to lack of support
  • Wilson's stroke in October 1919 limited his ability to campaign for treaty
  • Republican gains in 1918 midterm elections shifted balance of power in Congress
• Absence of US weakened League's ability to enforce decisions
  • Reduced economic and military potential of organization
  • Diminished League's global legitimacy and influence

Complex Relationship with League

• Despite non-membership, US cooperated with League on various issues
  • Participated in League-affiliated organizations (International Labor Organization)
  • Sent unofficial observers to League meetings
• US involvement in League activities increased over time
  • Collaborated on efforts to combat drug trafficking and slavery
  • Participated in League-sponsored disarmament conferences
• American citizens worked in League Secretariat and technical organizations
  • Notable example: Arthur Sweetser, Director of Information Section
• US non-participation remained point of debate in interwar American politics
  • Some advocated for joining League to promote world peace
  • Others maintained isolationist stance until outbreak of World War II