4.3 Church-Turing thesis

Turing machines are the gold standard for computation. The Church-Turing thesis states that anything computable can be done by a Turing machine. This idea unites different models of computation and sets the boundaries for what's possible in computer science.

The thesis has big implications. It helps classify problems as solvable or unsolvable by computers. It also sparks debates about the nature of computation and whether the human mind is like a Turing machine.

Church-Turing Thesis

Statement and Implications

Top images from around the web for Statement and Implications

• 

  Turing Machines and Tooling, Part I View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Computability View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Turing Machines and Tooling, Part I View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Turing Machines and Tooling, Part I View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Computability View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Statement and Implications

• 

  Turing Machines and Tooling, Part I View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Computability View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Turing Machines and Tooling, Part I View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Turing Machines and Tooling, Part I View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Computability View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• The Church-Turing thesis states that a function on the natural numbers is computable by a human being following an algorithm, ignoring resource limitations, if and only if it is computable by a Turing machine
• Asserts that any computable function can be computed by an abstract machine, specifically a Turing machine
• Implies all proposed definitions of computability (lambda calculus, recursive functions) are equivalent to Turing computability
• Establishes a fundamental limit on the power of mechanical computation, suggesting it is impossible to build a computing device that can solve problems a Turing machine cannot solve

Acceptance and Importance

• While the thesis is not a formally proven theorem, it is widely accepted and has never been seriously challenged
• Serves as a foundation for theoretical computer science and the theory of computation
• Provides a precise definition of what it means for a function to be computable or effectively calculable
• Unifies different approaches to computability (lambda calculus, recursive functions, Turing machines) under a single framework

Significance of the Church-Turing Thesis

Implications for Computability Theory

• Allows for the classification of problems into those that are computable (decidable) and those that are not computable (undecidable) based on their reducibility to a Turing machine
• Provides a basis for analyzing the time and space complexity of algorithms in complexity theory
• Suggests that human intuition and ingenuity cannot surpass the capabilities of Turing machines in terms of computability

Philosophical Implications

• Raises questions about the nature of computation and the limits of what can be achieved by mechanical means
• Implies that certain problems, such as the halting problem, are inherently unsolvable by any computational means
• Sparks discussions about the relationship between computation and human cognition, including whether the human mind can be modeled as a Turing machine (strong AI hypothesis)

Turing Machines vs Other Models

Turing Machines as a Standard Model

• Turing machines serve as a standard model of computation against which other models are compared and evaluated for their computational power
• The Church-Turing thesis asserts that any computable function can be computed by a Turing machine, implying that other models of computation cannot solve problems beyond what a Turing machine can solve

Equivalence to Other Models

• Lambda calculus, developed by Alonzo Church, is a formal system for expressing computation based on function abstraction and application
  • The Church-Turing thesis establishes the equivalence between lambda calculus and Turing machines in terms of computability
• Recursive functions, defined by Kurt Gödel and Stephen Kleene, provide another model of computation based on primitive recursive functions and a minimization operator
  • The Church-Turing thesis shows that recursive functions are equivalent to Turing machines in computational power
• Other models of computation, such as register machines, cellular automata, and abstract state machines, have been shown to be equivalent to Turing machines, reinforcing the universality of the Church-Turing thesis

Limitations of the Church-Turing Thesis

Lack of Formal Proof

• The Church-Turing thesis is a hypothesis rather than a formally proven theorem
• While it has strong empirical support, there is no mathematical proof of its validity
• The thesis relies on informal notions such as "algorithm" and "computation," and some argue that a more rigorous and formal definition of computation is needed to establish the thesis on firmer grounds

Efficiency and Practicality

• The thesis does not address the efficiency or practicality of computation
• It only asserts the equivalence of computability between different models, without considering the resources (time and space) required for computation
• In practice, the efficiency of algorithms and the feasibility of solving problems within reasonable time and space constraints are crucial considerations

Challenges to the Thesis

• Some researchers have proposed models of computation that challenge the Church-Turing thesis, such as quantum computing and hypercomputation
  • Quantum computing exploits quantum-mechanical phenomena (superposition, entanglement) to perform certain computations more efficiently than classical computers
  • Hypercomputation refers to hypothetical models that can compute functions beyond those computable by Turing machines
• However, the physical realizability and practical feasibility of these models remain uncertain and are subject to ongoing research and debate

Limitations in Capturing Human Cognition

• The Church-Turing thesis does not capture certain aspects of human cognition and intelligence, such as creativity, intuition, and self-awareness
• It is limited to the notion of effective calculability and does not encompass the full range of human mental capabilities
• The thesis does not address the question of whether human cognition can be fully modeled or simulated by computational means, which is a topic of ongoing philosophical and scientific inquiry