4.4 Decidability and undecidability

Turing machines are powerful tools for analyzing computability. They help us understand which problems can be solved algorithmically and which ones are beyond the reach of any computer program.

Decidability and undecidability are key concepts in this analysis. Some problems can be decided by algorithms that always give correct answers, while others are provably unsolvable by any algorithm, revealing fundamental limits of computation.

Decidability vs Undecidability

Defining Decidability and Undecidability

Top images from around the web for Defining Decidability and Undecidability

• 

  CS664 - Formal Language Theory View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS 340: Lecture 8: Decidability and the Halting Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS 340: Lecture 8: Decidability and the Halting Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS664 - Formal Language Theory View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS 340: Lecture 8: Decidability and the Halting Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Defining Decidability and Undecidability

• 

  CS664 - Formal Language Theory View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS 340: Lecture 8: Decidability and the Halting Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS 340: Lecture 8: Decidability and the Halting Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS664 - Formal Language Theory View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS 340: Lecture 8: Decidability and the Halting Problem View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• A decision problem is a problem that has a yes-or-no answer
• An algorithm is said to decide the problem if it always terminates with the correct answer
• A decision problem is decidable if there exists an algorithm that decides it
  • The algorithm always halts and produces the correct yes-or-no answer for any input
• A decision problem is undecidable if no such algorithm exists
  • There is no algorithm that can always provide the correct answer for all possible inputs in a finite amount of time

Relationship to the Halting Problem and Implications

• The concept of decidability is closely related to the halting problem
  • The halting problem asks whether a given Turing machine will halt on a given input
• The existence of undecidable problems has significant implications for the limitations of computation
  • It defines the boundaries of what can be effectively computed

Turing Machines for Decidability

Using Turing Machines to Analyze Decidability

• Turing machines serve as a formal model for computation
  • They can be used to analyze the decidability of problems
• A problem is decidable if a Turing machine can be constructed to decide it
  • The Turing machine always halts and produces the correct output for any input

Proving Decidability and Undecidability with Turing Machines

• To prove a problem is decidable, one can design a Turing machine that decides the problem
  • Argue that the Turing machine always halts and produces the correct answer
• To prove a problem is undecidable, one can show that no Turing machine can decide the problem
  • Use techniques such as reduction or diagonalization
• The halting problem is a famous example of an undecidable problem
  • It asks whether a given Turing machine will halt on a given input

Proving Undecidability

Reduction Technique

• Proving the undecidability of a problem typically involves showing that it is at least as hard as a known undecidable problem (halting problem)
• Reduction is a common technique used to prove undecidability
  • Problem A is reduced to problem B, meaning that if A is decidable, then B must also be decidable
• To prove a problem is undecidable, one can reduce a known undecidable problem to it
  • If the problem were decidable, it would imply the decidability of the known undecidable problem, leading to a contradiction

Diagonalization Technique and Examples

• Diagonalization is another technique used to prove undecidability
  • A contradiction is derived by assuming the existence of an algorithm that decides the problem
• Examples of undecidable problems include:
  • The halting problem
  • The Post correspondence problem
  • The word problem for groups

Implications of Undecidability

Limits of Computation and Algorithmic Capabilities

• The existence of undecidable problems has profound implications for the limits of computation
  • It shows that there are certain problems for which no algorithm can provide a solution in all cases, regardless of the available computational resources
• Undecidability has practical consequences in various areas of computer science
  • Program verification: it is not possible to create an algorithm that can determine whether an arbitrary program satisfies a given specification

Undecidability in Formal Systems and Logic

• Undecidability also arises in the context of formal systems and logic
  • Questions about the consistency and completeness of axiomatic systems are undecidable
• Understanding the implications of undecidability helps in recognizing the inherent limitations of computation
  • It guides the development of appropriate strategies for dealing with intractable problems

Importance of Studying Decidability

• Despite the existence of undecidable problems, many important problems in computer science are decidable
• The study of decidability helps in identifying and characterizing the class of problems that can be effectively solved by algorithms
  • It provides insights into the capabilities and limitations of computation