6.2 Gender and the Great Depression

The Great Depression hit America hard, shaking up traditional gender roles. Men lost jobs and struggled with their identity as providers. Women stepped up, entering the workforce to support their families, but faced discrimination and lower wages.

Despite economic pressures, society clung to traditional gender expectations. Women juggled work and home responsibilities, while men grappled with unemployment and loss of status. The New Deal offered some relief but often reinforced gender inequalities.

Gendered Impacts of the Great Depression

Economic Downturn and Job Losses

Top images from around the web for Economic Downturn and Job Losses

• 

  Great Depression - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great Depression - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tville4 - 41. welch, blake View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great Depression - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great Depression - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Economic Downturn and Job Losses

• 

  Great Depression - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great Depression - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Tville4 - 41. welch, blake View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great Depression - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Great Depression - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• The Great Depression, which began with the stock market crash in 1929 and lasted until the late 1930s, had significant and differing impacts on men and women in terms of employment, family roles, and societal expectations
• The economic downturn led to widespread job losses, with men being more severely affected due to their traditional role as primary breadwinners
  • This challenged the prevailing notion of masculinity and men's identity as providers for their families
  • Many men experienced a sense of failure, loss of status, and psychological distress as a result of unemployment
• Women's employment initially declined during the early years of the Depression but later increased as they sought work to support their families
  • However, women often faced discrimination, lower wages, and limited job opportunities compared to men
  • Married women, in particular, were often blamed for contributing to male unemployment by taking jobs away from men

Altered Family Dynamics and Social Expectations

• The economic pressures of the Great Depression altered family dynamics, with women taking on more responsibilities as homemakers and caretakers while men struggled with unemployment and a sense of diminished authority within the household
  • Women often had to stretch limited resources to provide for their families, engaging in strategies such as budgeting, home production, and bartering
  • Men's unemployment sometimes led to strained family relationships, as traditional gender roles and power dynamics were disrupted
• Social expectations regarding gender roles were both challenged and reinforced during the Depression era
  • While some women found empowerment through increased labor force participation, others faced criticism for taking jobs away from men
  • The media and popular culture often reinforced traditional gender stereotypes, portraying men as strong, resilient providers and women as nurturing, self-sacrificing caregivers

Gender Roles During the Great Depression

Challenges to Traditional Masculinity

• The Great Depression had a complex impact on traditional gender roles, simultaneously challenging and reinforcing prevailing notions of masculinity and femininity
• The economic crisis undermined the traditional male breadwinner model, as many men lost their jobs and were unable to fulfill their expected role as providers
  • This led to a sense of emasculation and a challenge to traditional masculine identity
  • Men often experienced feelings of inadequacy, shame, and a loss of self-esteem when unable to provide for their families
• The shift in gender roles, with women increasingly entering the workforce, further challenged traditional notions of masculinity
  • Some men felt threatened by women's growing economic independence and perceived competition for jobs
  • Others supported their wives' employment as a necessary means of family survival

Persistence and Reinforcement of Traditional Expectations

• Despite the changes in employment patterns, traditional gender expectations persisted in many aspects of life
  • Women were still primarily responsible for household duties and childcare, even when employed outside the home
  • The "double burden" of balancing work and domestic responsibilities fell disproportionately on women
• The media and popular culture of the time often reinforced traditional gender stereotypes
  • Advertisements, magazines, and movies depicted idealized images of men as strong, capable providers and women as nurturing, devoted homemakers
  • These representations helped to maintain traditional gender norms and expectations, even in the face of economic and social upheaval

Workforce Experiences in the Great Depression

Men's Unemployment and Psychological Distress

• Men, who were traditionally seen as the primary breadwinners, faced widespread unemployment and a sense of failure in their prescribed gender role
  • The loss of a job and the inability to provide for one's family led to psychological distress, feelings of inadequacy, and a diminished sense of self-worth
  • Unemployment challenged men's identity and status within the family and society, often leading to strained relationships and a sense of powerlessness
• The experience of unemployment varied among men, depending on factors such as age, race, and social class
  • Older men often faced greater difficulty in finding new employment, as employers favored younger, cheaper labor
  • African American men experienced even higher rates of unemployment and discrimination compared to white men

Women's Increased Workforce Participation and Discrimination

• Women's participation in the workforce increased during the Depression, particularly in lower-paying, traditionally female-dominated sectors such as domestic service, clerical work, and teaching
  • Economic necessity drove many women to seek employment to support their families, especially when their husbands were unemployed
  • The expansion of the service sector and the growth of industries such as textiles and garment manufacturing provided some job opportunities for women
• Women often faced discrimination in the workplace, including lower wages, limited opportunities for advancement, and the perception that they were taking jobs away from men
  • The notion of the "family wage," which assumed that a man's income should be sufficient to support a family, contributed to the belief that women's employment was secondary and temporary
  • Married women, in particular, were often the first to be laid off and the last to be hired, as they were seen as less deserving of employment than men or single women
• The experiences of women in the workforce varied based on factors such as race, class, and location
  • African American women faced even greater discrimination and limited job prospects compared to white women, often relegated to the lowest-paying and least desirable positions
  • Women from middle-class backgrounds sometimes had access to better education and employment opportunities, such as teaching or social work
  • Urban areas tended to offer more diverse job options for women compared to rural areas

Empowerment and Double Burden

• Some women found empowerment through their work experiences, gaining a sense of independence and contributing to their family's economic survival
  • Employment provided women with a source of income, increased autonomy, and a sense of purpose beyond traditional domestic roles
  • Women's participation in the workforce challenged traditional notions of gender roles and demonstrated their capabilities and resilience
• However, this empowerment was often tempered by the double burden of balancing work and domestic responsibilities
  • Women were still expected to fulfill their traditional roles as homemakers and caregivers, even when employed outside the home
  • The combination of paid work and unpaid domestic labor often led to long hours, exhaustion, and limited leisure time for women
  • The unequal division of household responsibilities between men and women persisted, despite women's increased workforce participation

Government Policies and Gender Dynamics

New Deal Programs and Gender Implications

• The New Deal, a series of government programs and reforms introduced by President Franklin D. Roosevelt, aimed to provide relief, recovery, and reform in response to the economic crisis
  • These programs had both positive and negative effects on gender roles and relations
• Some New Deal programs, such as the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) and the Works Progress Administration (WPA), primarily benefited men by providing employment opportunities in construction, conservation, and public works projects
  • The CCC employed young, unmarried men in conservation and infrastructure projects, reinforcing the importance of male labor and the idea of men as primary breadwinners
  • The WPA provided jobs for unemployed men in construction, road building, and other public works, helping to restore a sense of masculine pride and purpose
• Other programs, such as the Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA) and the Social Security Act, provided assistance to families and individuals, including women and children
  • FERA offered direct relief to families in need, providing aid to women and children who were often the most vulnerable during the economic crisis
  • The Social Security Act established a system of old-age pensions, unemployment insurance, and aid to dependent children, offering some financial security to women, particularly in their roles as mothers and caregivers

Reinforcement of Traditional Gender Roles and Inequalities

• Many New Deal programs and policies were designed with a male-centric view of work and family, often reinforcing traditional gender roles and inequalities
  • The emphasis on male employment and the male breadwinner model sometimes had the unintended consequence of marginalizing women's contributions and reinforcing gender-based discrimination in the workforce
  • The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938, which established minimum wage and maximum hour standards, initially excluded many female-dominated industries, such as domestic service and agricultural labor
  • The National Recovery Administration (NRA), which set industry-wide codes for wages and working conditions, often codified lower pay scales for women and reinforced occupational segregation based on gender
• The prioritization of male employment in New Deal programs and the assumption that women's income was supplementary to men's contributed to the persistent gender wage gap and limited opportunities for women's advancement in the workforce
  • Women were often paid less than men for the same work, justified by the belief that men deserved higher wages as primary breadwinners
  • The concentration of women in low-paying, "pink-collar" jobs, such as clerical work and domestic service, reinforced occupational segregation and limited women's economic mobility

Opportunities and Limitations for Women

• Despite the limitations, some women benefited from New Deal programs and found opportunities for education, job training, and employment
  • The National Youth Administration (NYA) provided education and job training opportunities for young women, helping them develop skills and gain work experience
  • The Federal Art Project and the Federal Writers' Project employed women artists and writers, providing them with a means of creative expression and financial support
  • The expansion of the teaching profession and the growth of social work during the New Deal era offered some middle-class women a pathway to professional careers
• However, the opportunities provided by New Deal programs were not equally accessible to all women
  • African American women often faced discrimination and were excluded from many of the benefits and opportunities offered by New Deal programs
  • Women from working-class and rural backgrounds had limited access to education and job training programs, which often favored middle-class, urban women
  • The emphasis on traditional gender roles and the assumption of women's primary responsibility for domestic life constrained women's ability to fully participate in and benefit from New Deal initiatives