7.5 Athenian democracy

Athenian democracy emerged as a groundbreaking political system in ancient Greece, shaping future democratic ideals. It developed through reforms by figures like Solon and Cleisthenes, addressing social inequalities and introducing concepts like isonomia (equality before the law).

The system consisted of interconnected institutions like the Ecclesia (Assembly) and Boule (Council of 500), designed to distribute power among citizens. Key principles included isegoria (equality of speech) and direct participation, which both strengthened and challenged the democratic process.

Origins of Athenian democracy

• Athenian democracy emerged as a groundbreaking political system in ancient Greece, shaping the foundation for future democratic ideals
• This revolutionary form of governance developed gradually through a series of reforms and societal changes, reflecting the evolving political landscape of Athens
• Understanding the origins of Athenian democracy provides crucial context for analyzing its portrayal and critique in Greek tragedy

Reforms of Solon

Top images from around the web for Reforms of Solon

• 

  Solon - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The reform legislation of Solon | Exhibition "Democracy and … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Solon - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Solon - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The reform legislation of Solon | Exhibition "Democracy and … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Reforms of Solon

• 

  Solon - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The reform legislation of Solon | Exhibition "Democracy and … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Solon - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Solon - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The reform legislation of Solon | Exhibition "Democracy and … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Implemented in 594 BCE, addressed economic and social inequalities in Athens
• Canceled existing debts and freed citizens who had been enslaved due to debt (seisachtheia)
• Established four property classes based on agricultural output, linking political participation to wealth
• Created the Heliaia (people's court) allowing citizens to appeal decisions made by magistrates
• Introduced the right for any citizen to bring charges on behalf of a wronged party (ho boulomenos)

Cleisthenes and isonomia

• Reforms enacted in 508 BCE fundamentally restructured Athenian political organization
• Replaced the traditional four Ionian tribes with ten new tribes based on geographical location
• Introduced the concept of isonomia (equality before the law) as a cornerstone of democratic ideology
• Created the Council of 500 (Boule) with representatives from each of the new tribes
• Implemented ostracism as a means to protect the democracy from potential tyrants

Development under Pericles

• Led Athens during its Golden Age (461-429 BCE), further strengthening democratic institutions
• Introduced payment for jury duty, enabling poorer citizens to participate in the legal system
• Expanded the use of sortition (random selection) for filling public offices
• Promoted extensive public works projects (Acropolis) providing employment and civic pride
• Delivered the famous Funeral Oration, articulating Athenian democratic ideals and values

Structure of Athenian democracy

• Athenian democracy consisted of interconnected institutions designed to distribute power among citizens
• This complex system aimed to balance direct participation with efficient governance
• Greek tragedies often incorporated elements of these democratic structures, reflecting contemporary political realities

Ecclesia (Assembly)

• Primary decision-making body open to all male citizens over 18 years old
• Met at least 40 times per year on the Pnyx hill to debate and vote on laws and policies
• Quorum of 6,000 citizens required for major decisions (ostracism, granting citizenship)
• Used simple majority voting for most issues, with votes cast by show of hands
• Elected strategoi (generals) and other important officials annually

Boule (Council of 500)

• Administrative body responsible for preparing the agenda for the Ecclesia
• Composed of 50 members from each of the ten Athenian tribes, chosen by lot
• Served one-year terms with a limit of two non-consecutive terms in a lifetime
• Met daily to manage day-to-day affairs of the city-state
• Divided into smaller committees (prytaneis) to oversee specific areas of governance

Dikasteria (Law courts)

• Comprised large juries of citizens chosen by lot, typically 201 or 501 members
• Heard both private and public cases, including challenges to proposed laws
• Jurors voted by secret ballot using bronze disks dropped into urns
• No judges or professional lawyers, litigants argued their own cases
• Verdicts were final with no formal appeals process

Key democratic institutions

• Athenian democracy developed unique mechanisms to safeguard its principles and ensure citizen participation
• These institutions reflected the Athenian commitment to political equality and accountability
• Greek tragedies often explored the implications and potential pitfalls of these democratic innovations

Ostracism

• Annual vote to temporarily exile a citizen perceived as a threat to democracy
• Required a minimum of 6,000 votes cast, with the name receiving the most ostraka (pottery shards) banished
• Exiled individual for 10 years without loss of property or citizenship
• Intended to prevent the rise of tyrants and resolve political deadlocks
• Notable ostracized figures include Themistocles and Cimon

Sortition vs election

• Sortition (selection by lot) used for most administrative positions to ensure equal opportunity
• Believed to prevent corruption and promote fairness in political appointments
• Election reserved for specialized roles requiring specific skills (generals, financial officials)
• Rotation of offices ensured a large portion of citizens gained political experience
• Critics argued sortition could lead to incompetent officials in important positions

Citizenship requirements

• Limited to free adult males born to Athenian parents (after Pericles' citizenship law of 451 BCE)
• Excluded women, slaves, and metics (resident foreigners) from political participation
• Required completion of military service (ephebeia) for full citizenship rights
• Citizenship could be granted by the Assembly for exceptional service to Athens
• Dual citizenship not recognized, forcing individuals to choose between poleis

Democratic principles

• Athenian democracy was built upon foundational concepts that shaped its institutions and practices
• These principles influenced the development of democratic thought throughout history
• Greek tragedies often explored the tensions between these ideals and their practical implementation

Isegoria (equality of speech)

• Guaranteed the right of all citizens to speak in the Assembly
• Encouraged open debate and diverse perspectives in decision-making processes
• Symbolized by the herald's call "Who wishes to speak?" at Assembly meetings
• Extended to the law courts where litigants presented their own cases
• Criticized by some as allowing uninformed or demagogic opinions to sway policy

Isonomia (equality before law)

• Ensured all citizens were subject to the same laws and legal procedures
• Replaced earlier systems based on aristocratic privilege or economic status
• Applied in both political and judicial spheres of Athenian life
• Reflected in the use of large juries to prevent bribery or favoritism
• Challenged by the practical inequalities that persisted in Athenian society

Direct vs representative democracy

• Athenian system emphasized direct participation of citizens in governance
• Contrasts with modern representative democracies where elected officials make decisions
• Allowed for rapid decision-making but could lead to inconsistent policies
• Required significant time commitment from citizens to participate fully
• Debated by philosophers like Plato and Aristotle regarding efficiency and wisdom of collective rule

Criticisms of Athenian democracy

• Despite its innovations, Athenian democracy faced numerous critiques from both contemporaries and later thinkers
• These criticisms often formed the basis for dramatic conflicts in Greek tragedies
• Understanding these critiques provides insight into the ongoing debates about democratic governance

Exclusivity of citizenship

• Limited participation to a small percentage of the total population (adult male citizens)
• Excluded women, slaves, and metics from political rights despite their economic contributions
• Created a disconnect between those making decisions and those affected by them
• Led to tensions and occasional unrest among disenfranchised groups
• Challenged the claim of being truly representative of the entire polis

Potential for demagoguery

• Skilled orators could manipulate public opinion for personal or factional gain
• Assembly vulnerable to emotional appeals and short-term thinking
• Historical examples include Cleon's aggressive policies during the Peloponnesian War
• Criticized by philosophers like Plato as a fundamental flaw in democratic systems
• Reflected in tragic characters who sway crowds through persuasive but misguided arguments

Tyranny of majority

• Majority rule could lead to oppression of minority groups or viewpoints
• Lack of constitutional protections for individual rights
• Historical examples include the trial of Socrates and the Mytilenean debate
• Raised questions about the balance between popular will and justice
• Explored in tragedies through conflicts between protagonists and the wider community

Democracy in Greek tragedy

• Greek tragedies served as a medium for exploring and critiquing contemporary political issues
• Playwrights used mythological stories to comment on the strengths and weaknesses of Athenian democracy
• Performances at the City Dionysia festival were themselves a democratic institution, funded by the state

Portrayal in plays

• Democratic institutions often featured as settings or plot devices (assemblies, trials)
• Characters debated political ideas using rhetorical techniques familiar to Athenian audiences
• Choruses sometimes represented the voice of the demos (people) commenting on events
• Tragic heroes often embodied tensions between individual will and collective decision-making
• Plays like Aeschylus' "Oresteia" dramatized the transition from personal vengeance to civic justice

Reflection of contemporary issues

• Sophocles' "Antigone" explored conflicts between divine law and human legislation
• Euripides' "The Suppliants" depicted debates about war and the treatment of defeated enemies
• Aristophanes' comedies directly satirized democratic leaders and institutions
• Themes of citizenship, justice, and political power recurred throughout the tragic corpus
• Productions coincided with periods of significant political change in Athens

Critiques through dramatic works

• Questioned the wisdom of majority rule through depictions of mob mentality
• Explored the consequences of political decisions made without full information
• Highlighted the potential for manipulation of democratic processes by skilled speakers
• Examined the role of leadership in a system that emphasized equality
• Probed the limits of democratic ideals when faced with external threats or internal divisions

Legacy of Athenian democracy

• Athenian democratic experiments left an indelible mark on political thought and practice
• The strengths and weaknesses of this system continue to inform debates about governance
• Greek tragedies, as products and critiques of this democracy, remain relevant to modern political discourse

Influence on modern democracies

• Inspired concepts of citizenship, civic participation, and equality before the law
• Direct democracy practices (referendums) in some modern systems echo Athenian principles
• Separation of powers and checks and balances developed as refinements of Athenian ideas
• Debates about the role of expertise vs popular will in governance reflect ancient concerns
• Modern democratic institutions (parliaments, courts) have roots in Athenian structures

Philosophical debates

• Plato's critique of democracy in "The Republic" sparked ongoing discussions about ideal governance
• Aristotle's analysis in "Politics" laid groundwork for comparative study of political systems
• Enlightenment thinkers (Rousseau, Montesquieu) drew on Athenian models in their political theories
• Contemporary philosophers continue to engage with questions of democratic legitimacy and practice
• Tensions between liberty and equality explored in tragedies remain central to political philosophy

Historical significance

• Demonstrated the viability of large-scale participatory governance for the first time
• Coincided with (and potentially contributed to) Athens' cultural and intellectual flourishing
• Provided a contrast to oligarchic and monarchic systems prevalent in the ancient world
• Established a vocabulary and conceptual framework for discussing democratic ideals
• Legacy preserved and transmitted through historical works, philosophical texts, and dramatic literature