9.1 Characteristics of tragic heroes

Greek tragedy introduced the concept of tragic heroes, central figures who embody complex moral struggles. These characters, originating in 5th century BCE Athens, serve as vehicles for exploring human nature and societal issues through their downfall.

Tragic heroes possess key elements like noble status, admirable qualities, and fatal flaws. Their journey involves intense suffering, self-realization, and ultimately evokes both pity and fear in the audience, leading to emotional catharsis.

Definition of tragic hero

• Tragic heroes originated in ancient Greek drama as central figures in tragedies
• These characters embody complex moral and emotional struggles, serving as vehicles for exploring human nature and societal issues
• Greek tragedies use tragic heroes to evoke powerful emotions in the audience, leading to catharsis

Origins in Greek drama

Top images from around the web for Origins in Greek drama

• 

  Classical Greek Theater | Western Civilization View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Portrait of the Athenian tragedian Aeschylus, Roman copy o… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Classical Greek Theater | Western Civilization View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Portrait of the Athenian tragedian Aeschylus, Roman copy o… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Origins in Greek drama

• 

  Classical Greek Theater | Western Civilization View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Portrait of the Athenian tragedian Aeschylus, Roman copy o… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Classical Greek Theater | Western Civilization View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Portrait of the Athenian tragedian Aeschylus, Roman copy o… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• Emerged in 5th century BCE Athens during the Golden Age of Greek theater
• Developed by playwrights like Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides
• Rooted in religious festivals honoring Dionysus, god of wine and theater
• Evolved from earlier forms of choral performances and mythological storytelling

Key elements of tragedy

• Protagonist of high status or noble birth
• Possesses admirable qualities and relatability to the audience
• Experiences a significant downfall due to a combination of fate and personal flaws
• Undergoes intense suffering and self-realization
• Evokes both pity and fear in the audience

Hamartia

• Hamartia plays a crucial role in Greek tragedy, driving the hero's downfall
• This concept explores the intersection of fate, free will, and human imperfection
• Understanding hamartia helps analyze character motivations and plot development in tragic plays

Fatal flaw concept

• Refers to a hero's inherent character defect or error in judgment
• Often stems from excessive pride, ambition, or moral blindness
• Not necessarily a moral failing, but a mistake or misjudgment
• Leads to the hero's eventual downfall and suffering
• Distinguishes tragic heroes from purely virtuous characters

Examples in Greek plays

• Oedipus' rashness and pride in Sophocles' Oedipus Rex
• Creon's stubbornness and inflexibility in Antigone
• Medea's uncontrollable rage and desire for revenge in Euripides' Medea
• Agamemnon's excessive ambition in Aeschylus' Oresteia trilogy
• Pentheus' close-mindedness and rejection of Dionysus in The Bacchae

Hubris

• Hubris represents a critical aspect of many tragic heroes in Greek drama
• This excessive pride or self-confidence often leads to the hero's downfall
• Exploring hubris allows playwrights to examine the dangers of unchecked ego and arrogance

Pride vs arrogance

• Pride involves a sense of self-worth and dignity
• Arrogance manifests as an inflated sense of superiority over others
• Hubris goes beyond healthy pride, leading to overconfidence and poor decisions
• Often blinds the hero to their own limitations and vulnerabilities
• Can cause the hero to challenge or defy the gods, leading to divine punishment

Consequences in tragedies

• Alienation from friends, family, and supporters
• Impaired judgment and decision-making abilities
• Conflicts with other characters, including gods or fate itself
• Eventual downfall and loss of status or power
• Realization of mistakes, often too late to rectify the situation
• Serves as a cautionary tale for the audience about the dangers of excessive pride

Peripeteia

• Peripeteia represents a crucial turning point in Greek tragedies
• This sudden reversal of fortune dramatically alters the hero's trajectory
• Understanding peripeteia helps analyze the structure and emotional impact of tragic plays

Reversal of fortune

• Marks a significant shift in the hero's circumstances or fate
• Often occurs as a result of the hero's actions or decisions
• Can involve a change from good fortune to bad, or vice versa
• Reveals hidden truths or consequences previously unknown to the hero
• Serves as a pivotal moment in the play's plot development

Impact on plot development

• Creates dramatic tension and heightens audience engagement
• Reveals the consequences of the hero's hamartia or hubris
• Often leads to the hero's anagnorisis or moment of recognition
• Accelerates the hero's journey towards their ultimate fate
• Contributes to the overall tragic arc of the story
• Elicits emotional responses from the audience (pity, fear, shock)

Anagnorisis

• Anagnorisis plays a vital role in the emotional and intellectual journey of tragic heroes
• This moment of recognition or discovery often follows the peripeteia
• Analyzing anagnorisis helps understand character development and thematic depth in Greek tragedies

Moment of recognition

• Refers to the hero's sudden realization of a truth or their true situation
• Often involves the discovery of one's own identity or the nature of past actions
• Can be triggered by new information, events, or self-reflection
• Marks a turning point in the hero's self-awareness and understanding
• May come too late to prevent the hero's downfall or suffering

Relationship to catharsis

• Contributes to the audience's emotional purification or catharsis
• Intensifies the tragic impact by revealing the full extent of the hero's situation
• Evokes pity and fear as the audience empathizes with the hero's realization
• Often leads to the hero's acceptance of their fate or consequences
• Provides insight into the play's themes and moral lessons
• Serves as a catalyst for the audience's own self-reflection and emotional release

Noble birth

• Noble birth traditionally characterizes tragic heroes in Greek drama
• This aspect reflects the societal structure and values of ancient Greece
• Examining the hero's social status provides insight into the play's context and themes

Social status importance

• Heroes often come from royal or aristocratic families
• High status amplifies the impact of the hero's downfall
• Reflects the belief that those in power have greater responsibilities and potential for tragedy
• Allows playwrights to explore themes of leadership, duty, and societal expectations
• Creates a stark contrast between the hero's initial position and their ultimate fate

Exceptions to the rule

• Some tragic heroes come from more humble origins
• Euripides introduced characters of lower social status in his plays
• Focus shifts to moral nobility rather than just social rank
• Allows for exploration of social mobility and class dynamics
• Broadens the scope of tragic themes to include a wider range of human experiences
• Challenges traditional notions of who can be considered a tragic hero

Suffering and downfall

• Suffering and downfall form the core of the tragic hero's journey in Greek drama
• These elements evoke powerful emotions in the audience and drive the play's themes
• Analyzing the hero's demise reveals insights into human nature and societal values

Causes of hero's demise

• Often results from a combination of fate and personal choices
• Hamartia or fatal flaw contributes significantly to the hero's downfall
• External forces (gods, prophecies, societal expectations) play a role
• Conflicts with other characters may accelerate the hero's decline
• Poor decision-making stemming from hubris or ignorance
• Inability to escape predetermined fate despite attempts to do so

Audience sympathy

• Hero's suffering elicits pity and empathy from viewers
• Relatability of the hero's flaws and struggles creates emotional connection
• Contrast between the hero's former glory and current state heightens impact
• Recognition of the hero's humanity despite their elevated status
• Exploration of universal themes (love, loss, ambition) through the hero's experience
• Cathartic effect achieved through shared emotional journey with the protagonist

Catharsis

• Catharsis represents the ultimate goal of Greek tragedy for the audience
• This concept of emotional purification or release is central to understanding tragic drama
• Analyzing catharsis helps explain the enduring power and purpose of Greek tragedies

Emotional purification

• Refers to the cleansing or purgation of emotions in the audience
• Primarily focuses on arousing and releasing pity and fear
• Achieved through intense emotional engagement with the tragic hero's journey
• Involves a complex interplay of empathy, horror, and relief
• Allows viewers to experience strong emotions in a safe, controlled environment
• May lead to greater self-awareness and emotional balance after the performance

Role in tragedy's purpose

• Serves as a form of emotional and psychological therapy for the audience
• Helps viewers confront and process their own fears and moral dilemmas
• Reinforces social norms and values through shared emotional experience
• Provides a means of collective reflection on human nature and societal issues
• Contributes to the educational and moral function of theater in ancient Greek society
• Enhances the overall impact and memorability of the tragic performance

Complex character development

• Complex character development distinguishes tragic heroes in Greek drama
• This depth of characterization allows for nuanced exploration of human nature
• Analyzing character complexity reveals the psychological and moral dimensions of tragedy

Internal conflicts

• Heroes often struggle with competing desires or obligations
• Tension between personal ambition and societal expectations
• Conflict between reason and emotion in decision-making
• Struggle to reconcile fate with free will
• Grappling with the consequences of past actions or inherited guilt
• Balancing individual needs with responsibilities to family, state, or gods

Moral dilemmas

• Heroes face difficult choices with no clear right answer
• Exploration of ethical gray areas and competing value systems
• Conflict between personal loyalty and broader moral obligations
• Challenges to traditional notions of justice and honor
• Questioning of divine laws versus human laws
• Examination of the limits of human knowledge and judgment in moral decisions

Tragic vs epic heroes

• Distinguishing between tragic and epic heroes illuminates different literary traditions
• This comparison reveals the unique characteristics and purposes of tragic drama
• Understanding these differences helps analyze the structure and themes of Greek tragedies

Key differences

• Tragic heroes experience significant downfall, while epic heroes often triumph
• Focus on internal flaws in tragedy vs external challenges in epics
• Tragic heroes evoke pity and fear, epic heroes inspire admiration and awe
• Emphasis on moral complexity in tragedy vs clear-cut virtues in epics
• Tragic heroes often confined to a specific time and place, epic heroes journey extensively
• Exploration of human limitations in tragedy vs superhuman feats in epics

Overlap in characteristics

• Both types of heroes often come from noble or divine lineage
• Courage and determination feature prominently in both traditions
• Interaction with gods or fate plays a role in both tragic and epic narratives
• Both hero types face significant challenges and undergo personal growth
• Exploration of themes like honor, duty, and sacrifice in both genres
• Both serve as vehicles for examining societal values and human nature

Modern interpretations

• Modern interpretations of tragic heroes reflect evolving societal values and literary trends
• This evolution demonstrates the enduring relevance of tragic themes in contemporary culture
• Analyzing modern tragic heroes reveals both continuity and change in dramatic traditions

Evolution of tragic hero

• Shift away from exclusively high-born protagonists to more diverse backgrounds
• Increased focus on psychological complexity and internal struggles
• Exploration of social and political issues through tragic hero narratives
• Blending of tragic elements with other genres (comedy, realism)
• Deconstruction of traditional hero archetypes and expectations
• Emphasis on moral ambiguity and relativism in character development

Contemporary examples

• Willy Loman in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman
• Blanche DuBois in Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire
• Walter White in the television series Breaking Bad
• Anakin Skywalker/Darth Vader in the Star Wars saga
• Jay Gatsby in F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby
• Cersei Lannister in George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire series