10.2 Grice: Implicature and Meaning

Grice's theory of implicature explores how we derive meaning beyond literal words. It introduces conventional and conversational implicatures, showing how context and shared assumptions shape understanding. This concept is crucial for grasping the nuances of language and communication.

The Cooperative Principle and its maxims form the backbone of Grice's work. These ideas explain how we navigate conversations, infer implied meanings, and resolve apparent violations of communication norms. Understanding these concepts helps us analyze and improve our everyday interactions.

Conventional vs Conversational Implicatures

Defining Implicatures

Top images from around the web for Defining Implicatures

• 

  The Process of Communication | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Defining Communication | SPCH 1311: Introduction to Speech Communication View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Context in Generalized Conversational Implicatures: The Case of Some | Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Process of Communication | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Defining Communication | SPCH 1311: Introduction to Speech Communication View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Defining Implicatures

• 

  The Process of Communication | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Defining Communication | SPCH 1311: Introduction to Speech Communication View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Context in Generalized Conversational Implicatures: The Case of Some | Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Process of Communication | Organizational Behavior and Human Relations View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Defining Communication | SPCH 1311: Introduction to Speech Communication View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Conventional implicatures derive from conventional meanings of words and phrases, independent of context
• Conversational implicatures arise from conversation context and assumption of cooperative principles
• Conventional implicatures remain constant when utterance rephrased (detachable)
• Conversational implicatures can change with context
• Conventional implicatures cannot be canceled by speaker
• Conversational implicatures can be explicitly canceled
• Distinction crucial for understanding meaning beyond literal interpretations

Examples of Implicatures

• Conventional implicature example: "She is poor but honest" implies contrast between poverty and honesty
• Conversational implicature example: "I'm out of gas" implies request for help when said to friend on road
• Conventional implicature in "even": "Even John passed the test" implies John was least likely to pass
• Conversational implicature cancellation: "Some students passed" followed by "In fact, all of them did"

Grice's Cooperative Principle for Communication

Foundation of the Principle

• Introduced by H. Paul Grice
• States participants expect contributions as required for talk exchange purpose
• Assumes speakers and listeners work together for mutual understanding
• Serves as foundation for interpreting implied meanings
• Resolves apparent violations of conversational norms
• Guides speakers to provide appropriate information amounts
• Encourages truthfulness, relevance, and clear communication
• Explains how listeners infer meaning beyond explicit statements

Applications of the Cooperative Principle

• Essential for analyzing communication strategies in various contexts (business meetings, academic discussions)
• Helps identify miscommunication sources in cross-cultural interactions
• Useful in designing effective public speaking and presentation techniques
• Applies to written communication (emails, reports) to ensure clarity and efficiency
• Aids in developing artificial intelligence for natural language processing and generation

Maxims of Conversation: Quantity, Quality, Relation, and Manner

Quantity and Quality Maxims

• Quantity maxim requires providing necessary information without excess
  • Example: Answering "Where do you live?" with city name, not exact address
• Quality maxim emphasizes truthfulness and adequate evidence
  • Avoid false statements or those lacking sufficient support
  • Example: Saying "I think it might rain" instead of "It will definitely rain" without certainty

Relation and Manner Maxims

• Relation (relevance) maxim requires pertinent contributions to current topic
  • Example: Discussing work projects in a business meeting, not personal vacation plans
• Manner maxim encourages clarity, brevity, and orderliness
  • Avoid ambiguity and unnecessary wordiness
  • Example: Giving directions using clear landmarks and concise instructions

Implications and Violations

• Maxim violations often lead to conversational implicatures
• Listeners infer additional meaning based on cooperative assumption
• Maxims serve as guidelines, not strict rules
• Deliberate flouting used for rhetorical effect or implicit meanings
  • Example: Sarcasm violates quality maxim to convey opposite meaning
• Understanding maxims helps analyze communication breakdowns
• Improves interpersonal and public communication skills

Applying Gricean Theory to Real-World Communication

Everyday Communication Analysis

• Analyze conversations, political speeches, advertising for implied meanings
• Explains interpretation of sarcasm, irony, non-literal language
• Identifies potential cross-cultural misunderstandings from different cooperation norms
• Aids legal discourse interpretation (contracts, testimonies)
• Analyzes digital communication (social media, instant messaging) lacking traditional cues

Practical Applications

• Framework for improving communication skills
• Consciously adhere to or strategically violate maxims for specific goals
• Recognize implicature generation and role in shaping overall meaning
• Enhance persuasive communication techniques in marketing and negotiations
• Develop more natural and context-aware language models for AI applications
• Improve conflict resolution strategies by identifying implied meanings and intentions