12.4 Deleuze: Difference and Repetition

Deleuze's philosophy challenges traditional Western thought by prioritizing difference over identity. He rejects fixed essences and stable realities, proposing a dynamic ontology that emphasizes flux and multiplicity.

In "Difference and Repetition," Deleuze redefines these concepts as creative forces. He argues that difference generates reality, while repetition produces novelty through differentiation, not mere recurrence of the same.

Deleuze's Critique of Representation

Challenging Traditional Western Philosophy

Top images from around the web for Challenging Traditional Western Philosophy

• 

  rhizomatic learning – You're the Teacher View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Deleuze, Gilles – Critical Posthumanism Network View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rizomatika: Gregory Flaxman - Gilles Deleuze and the Fabulation of Philosophy Powers of the ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  rhizomatic learning – You're the Teacher View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Deleuze, Gilles – Critical Posthumanism Network View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Challenging Traditional Western Philosophy

• 

  rhizomatic learning – You're the Teacher View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Deleuze, Gilles – Critical Posthumanism Network View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rizomatika: Gregory Flaxman - Gilles Deleuze and the Fabulation of Philosophy Powers of the ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  rhizomatic learning – You're the Teacher View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Deleuze, Gilles – Critical Posthumanism Network View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Deleuze confronts Western philosophy's emphasis on representation and identity limits understanding of reality and experience
• "Difference-in-itself" concept prioritizes difference over identity in ontological thinking
• Rejects Platonic notion of ideal forms asserts representation falsely assumes stable, unchanging reality
• Extends critique to Aristotelian categories and Hegelian dialectics reinforces identity-based thinking
• Proposes "philosophy of immanence" rejects transcendent principles focuses on productive nature of difference
• Introduces "rhizome" as alternative model to hierarchical, tree-like structures of knowledge and representation (contrasts with arborescent model)

Rethinking Ontology and Epistemology

• Challenges traditional metaphysics based on fixed essences and stable identities
• Advocates for a dynamic ontology emphasizes flux, becoming, and multiplicity
• Critiques representational thinking restricts our ability to grasp reality's complexity
• Proposes new approach to epistemology focuses on creative encounters rather than correspondence to pre-existing truth
• Develops concept of "transcendental empiricism" emphasizes experiential nature of thought beyond subject-object dichotomy
• Explores implications of non-representational thinking for ethics, politics, and aesthetics (new forms of social organization)

Difference and Repetition in Deleuze

Redefining Difference

• Difference functions as generative force produces reality not merely distinction between identities
• "Pure difference" or "difference in itself" contrasts with traditional understanding of difference as negation or opposition
• Emphasizes positive nature of difference creates new possibilities and actualities
• Introduces concept of "virtual" realm of pure difference and potentiality
• Explores how difference operates at various levels (molecular, social, conceptual)
• Challenges notion of identity as primary proposes difference as fundamental ontological principle

Reconceptualizing Repetition

• Repetition produces novelty through difference not recurrence of the same
• Distinguishes between "bare" repetition (mechanical reproduction) and "clothed" repetition (creative differentiation)
• Integrates theory of time involving synthesis of present, past, and future into understanding of repetition
• Reinterprets "eternal return" as affirmation of difference rather than recurrence of identical
• Challenges linear causality and deterministic views of reality through concepts of difference and repetition
• Explores repetition's role in formation of habits, memory, and subjectivity (psychological processes)

Deleuze's Philosophy of Creativity

Emergence of Novelty

• Provides framework for understanding creativity as emergence of genuine novelty not recombination of existing elements
• Emphasizes "becoming" continuous change and transformation over static being
• Introduces "virtual" and "actual" concepts offer new perspective on potentiality and realization in creative processes
• Explores "deterritorialization" explains how systems and structures can be disrupted and reconfigured leading to innovation
• Develops "assemblage" concept provides model for understanding complex, dynamic systems and their creative potential
• Challenges traditional notions of authorship and originality suggests more distributed and process-oriented view of creativity

Applications in Art and Culture

• Extends implications to fields of art, literature, and politics offers new ways to conceptualize creative and revolutionary practices
• Influences development of new approaches in visual art (non-representational art)
• Impacts literary theory and practice (experimental writing techniques)
• Shapes understanding of musical composition and performance (improvisation and aleatory music)
• Informs new media art and digital creativity (interactive and generative art)
• Contributes to rethinking of architectural design and urban planning (fluid and adaptive spaces)

Deleuze's Influence on Contemporary Thought

Impact on Philosophy and Cultural Theory

• Significantly impacts poststructuralist and postmodern thought contributes to "linguistic turn" in philosophy and cultural studies
• "Rhizome" concept widely adopted in various fields (literature, media studies, organizational theory)
• Influences development of new materialist philosophies and object-oriented ontology
• Contributes to development of affect theory in cultural studies and psychology
• Shapes contemporary radical political theory particularly through collaboration with Félix Guattari
• Impacts critical psychology and therapeutic practices through critique of psychoanalysis and concept of "schizoanalysis"

Applications in Media and Social Studies

• Applies Deleuzian concepts in film theory and media studies leads to new approaches in analyzing visual culture and digital media
• Influences understanding of social networks and digital communication (rhizomatic structures)
• Shapes approaches to cultural geography and urban studies (smooth and striated spaces)
• Informs analysis of globalization and transnational flows (deterritorialization and reterritorialization)
• Contributes to development of posthumanist and ecological thought (assemblages and becoming-animal)
• Impacts educational theory and practice (nomadic learning and rhizomatic pedagogy)