2.3 Lieder and Art Songs: Schubert, Schumann, and Brahms

Lieder and art songs revolutionized vocal music in the late 19th century. These intimate compositions for voice and piano blended poetry with music, creating emotionally rich experiences. Composers like Schubert, Schumann, and Brahms pushed the genre's boundaries, exploring new harmonic territories and expressive techniques.

The evolution of lieder reflected broader cultural shifts. As the middle class grew, so did the demand for music suitable for home performance. This genre became a perfect vehicle for the Romantic movement's emphasis on individual expression and emotion, shaping the landscape of vocal music for generations to come.

Lieder and Art Song Characteristics

Structure and Composition

Top images from around the web for Structure and Composition

• 

  Die Erwartung, D.159 (Schubert, Franz) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  5 Lieder, Op.40 (Schumann, Robert) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Schubert: Der Erlkönig | Music Appreciation View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Die Erwartung, D.159 (Schubert, Franz) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  5 Lieder, Op.40 (Schumann, Robert) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Structure and Composition

• 

  Die Erwartung, D.159 (Schubert, Franz) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  5 Lieder, Op.40 (Schumann, Robert) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Schubert: Der Erlkönig | Music Appreciation View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Die Erwartung, D.159 (Schubert, Franz) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  5 Lieder, Op.40 (Schumann, Robert) - IMSLP: Free Sheet Music PDF Download View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Lieder and art songs are vocal compositions set to pre-existing poetry, typically for solo voice and piano accompaniment
• The structure of lieder and art songs is often strophic, with the same music repeated for each verse of the poem, or through-composed, with new music for each verse to reflect the changing mood or narrative of the text
• Late 19th-century lieder and art songs often feature a more complex and expressive piano accompaniment that goes beyond mere support for the voice, becoming an integral part of the composition's emotional and dramatic content
• Composers of this period frequently employed chromaticism, modulation, and tonal ambiguity to enhance the emotional depth and psychological complexity of the poetry

Vocal Line and Text

• The vocal line in late 19th-century lieder and art songs is often more declamatory and speech-like, reflecting the natural inflections and rhythms of the text
• Composers sought to create a symbiotic relationship between the poetry and the music, with each element enhancing and illuminating the other
• The vocal line's melody, phrasing, and rhythm are often shaped to reflect the natural inflections and cadences of the spoken language, enhancing the intelligibility and expressive power of the poetry
• The choice of key, harmony, and modulation often reflects the emotional content of the poetry, with shifts in tonality mirroring changes in mood or perspective

Schubert, Schumann, and Brahms Contributions

Franz Schubert

• Franz Schubert is considered the father of the German lied, composing over 600 songs that set a new standard for the integration of poetry and music
• Schubert's song cycles, such as "Die schöne Müllerin" and "Winterreise," explored the psychological and emotional journey of a central character through a series of thematically linked songs
• Schubert's lieder are known for their melodic simplicity and naturalness, often featuring memorable tunes that closely mirror the contours and rhythms of the text
• Schubert's piano accompaniments, while expressive, tend to be more straightforward and subordinate to the vocal line compared to those of Schumann and Brahms

Robert Schumann

• Robert Schumann expanded the expressive range of the piano accompaniment in his lieder, using innovative harmonies and textures to create a more equal partnership between voice and piano
• Schumann's song cycles, like "Dichterliebe" and "Frauenliebe und -leben," often explored the inner emotional world of the protagonist, reflecting his own psychological struggles
• Schumann's lieder are characterized by their highly expressive and psychologically complex piano accompaniments, which often feature innovative harmonies, chromatic shifts, and intricate textures
• Schumann's vocal lines are often more declamatory and speech-like than Schubert's, reflecting his interest in the expressive potential of the text

Johannes Brahms

• Johannes Brahms brought a more classical sense of structure and form to his lieder, while still maintaining the genre's expressive depth and emotional intensity
• Brahms's lieder often feature more complex and technically demanding piano accompaniments, reflecting his background as a virtuoso pianist
• Brahms's "Vier ernste Gesänge" (Four Serious Songs) exemplify his late style, with a more introspective and philosophical approach to the poetry
• Brahms's lieder combine elements of Schubert's melodic gift and Schumann's expressive depth, while also incorporating a more classical sense of structure and form
• Brahms's vocal lines often feature wider leaps and more challenging intervals than those of Schubert or Schumann, demanding greater technical facility from the singer

Poetry and Music in Lieder

Word Painting and Musical Devices

• The piano accompaniment frequently employs musical devices such as word painting, using specific motifs or textures to illustrate or evoke the imagery of the text
• Composers may use recurring musical themes or motifs throughout a song cycle to create a sense of unity and to underscore the overarching narrative or emotional arc of the work
• The choice of key, harmony, and modulation often reflects the emotional content of the poetry, with shifts in tonality mirroring changes in mood or perspective

Integration of Poetry and Music

• Composers of lieder and art songs sought to create a symbiotic relationship between the poetry and the music, with each element enhancing and illuminating the other
• The vocal line's melody, phrasing, and rhythm are often shaped to reflect the natural inflections and cadences of the spoken language, enhancing the intelligibility and expressive power of the poetry
• The structure of lieder and art songs is often influenced by the form and content of the poetry, with composers using strophic or through-composed settings to reflect the poem's narrative or emotional arc

Schubert vs Schumann vs Brahms

Melodic and Harmonic Characteristics

• Schubert's lieder are known for their melodic simplicity and naturalness, often featuring memorable tunes that closely mirror the contours and rhythms of the text
• Schumann's lieder are characterized by their highly expressive and psychologically complex piano accompaniments, which often feature innovative harmonies, chromatic shifts, and intricate textures
• Brahms's lieder combine elements of Schubert's melodic gift and Schumann's expressive depth, while also incorporating a more classical sense of structure and form

Vocal and Piano Writing

• Schubert's piano accompaniments, while expressive, tend to be more straightforward and subordinate to the vocal line compared to those of Schumann and Brahms
• Schumann's vocal lines are often more declamatory and speech-like than Schubert's, reflecting his interest in the expressive potential of the text
• Brahms's piano accompaniments are often more technically demanding than those of Schubert or Schumann, reflecting his own virtuosic piano skills
• Brahms's vocal lines often feature wider leaps and more challenging intervals than those of Schubert or Schumann, demanding greater technical facility from the singer

Cultural Context of Lieder

Social and Musical Influences

• The rise of the middle class and the increasing popularity of domestic music-making in the 19th century created a demand for lieder and art songs that could be performed in the home by amateur singers and pianists
• The Romantic movement's emphasis on individual expression, emotion, and the power of poetry found its musical counterpart in the intimate and expressive genre of the lied
• The growing influence of nationalism in the 19th century led to a renewed interest in folk poetry and vernacular languages, which composers often drew upon for their lieder and art songs

Dissemination and Reception

• The establishment of music publishing houses and the expansion of the concert industry in the 19th century helped to disseminate lieder and art songs to a wider audience, both through sheet music sales and public performances by professional singers
• The late 19th century saw a shift towards more introspective and psychologically complex poetry, which composers like Schumann and Brahms sought to reflect in their increasingly sophisticated and expressive musical settings
• The popularity of lieder and art songs in the 19th century contributed to the development of a rich and enduring tradition of German vocal music, influencing later composers such as Hugo Wolf, Richard Strauss, and Gustav Mahler