8.4 The 1951 waterfront dispute and industrial relations

The 1951 waterfront dispute was a pivotal moment in New Zealand's labor history. A 151-day conflict between workers and the government erupted over wage demands, leading to widespread strikes and lockouts that disrupted industries nationwide.

The government's harsh response, including emergency powers and union deregistration, shifted the balance of industrial relations. This dispute weakened unions, reshaped labor laws, and left a lasting impact on workers' rights and government-labor relations in New Zealand.

Causes of the 1951 Waterfront Dispute

Economic and Labor Tensions

Top images from around the web for Economic and Labor Tensions

• 

  Special Branch constable's report on waterfront dispute meeting – Intelligence services – Te Ara ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  1951 New Zealand waterfront strike Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Don't Scab! 1951 Waterfront Dispute | One of the biggest ind… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Special Branch constable's report on waterfront dispute meeting – Intelligence services – Te Ara ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  1951 New Zealand waterfront strike Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Economic and Labor Tensions

• 

  Special Branch constable's report on waterfront dispute meeting – Intelligence services – Te Ara ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  1951 New Zealand waterfront strike Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Don't Scab! 1951 Waterfront Dispute | One of the biggest ind… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Special Branch constable's report on waterfront dispute meeting – Intelligence services – Te Ara ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  1951 New Zealand waterfront strike Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• 151-day industrial conflict from February to July 1951 involved approximately 22,000 waterside workers and other unionists
• New Zealand Waterside Workers' Union (NZWWU) wage claim for 15% pay increase rejected by New Zealand Employers' Federation
• Post-World War II economic pressures heightened tensions
  • Inflation reduced workers' purchasing power
  • National government sought to maintain economic stability
• Waterside workers initiated "go-slow" campaign
  • Refused to work overtime
  • Led to Waterfront Industry Commission locking out workers
• Lockout prompted watersiders to refuse work under imposed conditions, effectively starting a strike
• Industrial action spread to other sectors (miners, freezing workers, seamen)

Escalation and Public Impact

• Widespread industrial action disrupted multiple industries
• Public demonstrations increased visibility of the dispute
• Confrontations occurred between workers, police, and strike-breakers
• Strike impacted daily life and commerce throughout New Zealand
• Media coverage intensified public interest and debate
• Political tensions rose as government and unions clashed over resolution approaches

Government Response to the Dispute

Emergency Measures and Restrictions

• Prime Minister Sidney Holland's National government declared State of Emergency on February 21, 1951
• Invoked extraordinary powers to combat what it termed a "strike" (technically a lockout)
• Introduced emergency regulations severely restricting civil liberties
  • Censorship of media limited public information
  • Banned union meetings to prevent organization
  • Prohibited financial support for strikers' families
• Military personnel deployed to work on wharves
• Government actively recruited and protected strike-breakers ("scabs")
• Deregistered New Zealand Waterside Workers' Union and supporting unions
  • Effectively outlawed their existence and activities

Shift in Industrial Relations Power

• Government's hard-line approach set precedent for state intervention in industrial disputes
• Significantly weakened trade unions' power in subsequent years
• Demonstrated government's willingness to use legislative and executive powers to control industrial action
• Shifted balance of power between employers and employees
• Influenced future labor policies and negotiations
• Created lasting impact on relationship between government and labor organizations

Trade Unions' Role in the Dispute

Union Organization and Solidarity

• New Zealand Waterside Workers' Union (NZWWU) led dispute as militant and well-organized labor sector
• Federation of Labour (FOL) initially supported watersiders
  • Later withdrew support under government pressure
• Sympathy strikes by Miners' Union and Freezing Workers' Union demonstrated labor movement solidarity
• Unions organized support for striking workers and families
  • Set up relief committees
  • Distributed food and essential supplies
• Coordinated communication networks to maintain worker unity
• Negotiated with employers and government representatives

Ideological Divisions and Challenges

• Dispute exposed ideological divisions within labor movement
  • Militant unions advocated for aggressive action
  • Conciliatory unions favored negotiation and compromise
• Struggle to maintain bargaining power against government and employer opposition
• Unions faced public relations challenges due to media restrictions
• Internal debates over strike duration and negotiation strategies
• Long-term impact on union membership and influence
• Contributed to evolving relationship between unions and political parties

Long-Term Consequences of the Dispute

Impact on Labor Movement and Industrial Relations

• Significant weakening of trade union movement
  • Many unions took years to recover membership and influence
• Long-lasting division within labor movement
  • Contributed to eventual split between Federation of Labour and New Zealand Labour Party
• Shift towards more centralized wage-fixing mechanisms
• Establishment of Arbitration Court to handle industrial disputes
• Trend towards more conservative unionism in subsequent decades
• Decline in militant industrial action following the dispute

Legislative and Historical Legacy

• Influenced development of labor laws in New Zealand
  • Contributed to introduction of Employment Contracts Act 1991
  • Further decentralized industrial relations
• Pivotal moment in New Zealand's social and political history
• Often referenced in discussions about:
  • Civil liberties
  • Workers' rights
  • Role of government in industrial relations
• Shaped public perception of unions and industrial action
• Influenced future government approaches to labor disputes
• Became case study in labor history and industrial relations courses