4.3 Flying buttresses

Flying buttresses revolutionized Gothic architecture in the 12th century. These arched supports allowed for taller, thinner walls and larger windows by redistributing the weight of stone vaulted ceilings. They first appeared in the Abbey of Saint-Denis, marking a key innovation in structural design.

Flying buttresses played a crucial role in Gothic cathedrals, counterbalancing outward thrust and supporting heavy ceilings. Their distinctive arched shape efficiently transferred forces while allowing for an open appearance. Famous examples include Notre-Dame de Paris, Chartres Cathedral, and Reims Cathedral, showcasing the evolution of this architectural element.

Origins of flying buttresses

• Flying buttresses originated in the 12th century during the development of Gothic architecture, evolving from earlier Romanesque buttresses
• Enabled the construction of taller, thinner walls with larger windows by redistributing the weight and lateral forces of stone vaulted ceilings
• First appeared in the rebuild of the choir at Abbey of Saint-Denis in 1140s, marking a key innovation in Gothic structural design

Structural role in Gothic architecture

Support for stone vaulted ceilings

Top images from around the web for Support for stone vaulted ceilings

• 

  Free Stock photo of Flying Buttresses at York Minister Cathedral | Photoeverywhere View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Free Stock photo of Notre Dame flying buttress detail | Photoeverywhere View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Free Stock photo of Notre Dame Cathedral architectural detail | Photoeverywhere View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Free Stock photo of Flying Buttresses at York Minister Cathedral | Photoeverywhere View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Free Stock photo of Notre Dame flying buttress detail | Photoeverywhere View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Support for stone vaulted ceilings

• 

  Free Stock photo of Flying Buttresses at York Minister Cathedral | Photoeverywhere View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Free Stock photo of Notre Dame flying buttress detail | Photoeverywhere View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Free Stock photo of Notre Dame Cathedral architectural detail | Photoeverywhere View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Free Stock photo of Flying Buttresses at York Minister Cathedral | Photoeverywhere View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Free Stock photo of Notre Dame flying buttress detail | Photoeverywhere View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Flying buttresses provide essential support for the heavy stone vaulted ceilings characteristic of Gothic cathedrals
• Transfer the downward and outward thrust of the ceiling vaults to the buttresses, which bear the load down to the ground
• Allow for thinner, taller walls and more expansive windows by relieving the walls of the ceiling's weight

Counterbalance for outward thrust

• Stone vaulted ceilings exert significant lateral forces that would cause walls to collapse outward without additional support
• Flying buttresses counteract this outward thrust by channeling the force safely down to the ground at a distance from the wall
• Act as a counterbalance, pushing inward against the outward pressure of the ceiling vaults to maintain equilibrium

Architectural elements of flying buttresses

Arch design and shape

• Flying buttresses feature a distinctive arched shape, typically a segment of a circle or a quadrant arch
• Arch shape helps to efficiently transfer forces while allowing for an open, airy appearance
• Double or triple arched designs used in some cathedrals for added support and visual complexity (Notre-Dame de Paris)

Pinnacles and spires

• Vertical pinnacles and spires often sit atop the piers of flying buttresses, adding weight to help stabilize the structure
• Pinnacles also serve a decorative function, enhancing the sense of soaring verticality and drawing the eye upward
• Elaborately carved and ornamented spires reflect the Gothic emphasis on intricate, delicate details (Reims Cathedral)

Decorative vs functional features

• While flying buttresses serve a crucial structural purpose, they also incorporate decorative elements that integrate them with the overall Gothic aesthetic
• Sculpted figures, foliage, and other ornamental details adorn many flying buttresses, particularly in later Gothic styles
• Functional components like water spouts (gargoyles) blend with decorative carvings to create a seamless fusion of form and function

Famous examples in cathedrals

Notre-Dame de Paris

• Notre-Dame's flying buttresses, rebuilt in the 13th century, are among the most recognizable examples of this architectural feature
• Cathedral features multiple tiers of flying buttresses, with the upper level added in the 14th century for additional support
• Arched design, slender piers, and ornate pinnacles exemplify the elegance and intricacy of French Gothic style

Chartres Cathedral

• Chartres Cathedral, largely constructed in the late 12th-early 13th centuries, showcases early Gothic flying buttresses
• Buttresses at Chartres are relatively simple in design compared to later examples, reflecting the early experimental phase of this architectural element
• Play a crucial role in supporting the cathedral's innovative vaulted ceiling and allowing for expansive stained glass windows

Reims Cathedral

• Flying buttresses at Reims Cathedral, built primarily in the 13th-14th centuries, illustrate the increasing complexity and ornamentation of High Gothic style
• Feature multiple tiers, intricate pinnacles, and decorative carvings that enhance the cathedral's sense of verticality and visual richness
• Support the weight of the cathedral's stone vaulted ceiling, which reaches heights of over 120 feet (37 meters) in the nave

Evolution and refinements over time

Early experimental phase

• Flying buttresses first appeared in the mid-12th century, representing a bold innovation in structural design
• Early examples, such as those at Abbey of Saint-Denis and Chartres Cathedral, were relatively simple in form and limited in height
• Builders experimented with different configurations and designs to find the most effective and visually pleasing approach

High Gothic innovations

• In the 13th-14th centuries, flying buttresses became increasingly sophisticated and integral to the High Gothic style
• Multiple tiers of buttresses used to support taller walls and more complex vaulting systems (Notre-Dame de Paris, Reims Cathedral)
• Pinnacles and spires added to piers for additional stability and decorative effect
• Arches became more slender and graceful, enhancing the sense of lightness and verticality

Late Gothic elaborations

• Late Gothic period (15th-16th centuries) saw further elaboration and ornamentation of flying buttresses
• Decorative details like carved tracery, foliage, and figural sculpture became more prominent, sometimes obscuring the structural role
• Double and triple arched designs used for visual complexity and to distribute forces more evenly (Saint-Maclou Church, Rouen)
• Flying buttresses remained an essential feature of Gothic architecture until the style gradually gave way to the Renaissance

Influence on other architectural styles

Renaissance interpretations

• Renaissance architects admired the structural achievements of Gothic flying buttresses while seeking to adapt them to a new aesthetic
• Flying buttresses sometimes incorporated into Renaissance buildings, but often hidden behind walls or integrated into the interior design (St. Peter's Basilica, Vatican City)
• More restrained, geometrically regular designs reflected Renaissance ideals of proportion, balance, and classical simplicity

Gothic Revival imitations

• Gothic Revival movement of the 18th-19th centuries sought to recapture the spirit and style of medieval Gothic architecture
• Flying buttresses featured prominently in Gothic Revival buildings as a hallmark of the style (Palace of Westminster, London)
• Designs often exaggerated or romanticized, prioritizing visual impact over structural necessity
• Use of flying buttresses in Gothic Revival architecture helped to revive interest in and appreciation for this distinctive feature

Symbolic and aesthetic significance

Divine aspirations and verticality

• Soaring verticality of Gothic cathedrals, enabled by flying buttresses, symbolized spiritual aspirations and reaching towards the divine
• Upward thrust of the architecture drew the eye and the soul heavenward, creating a sense of awe and transcendence
• Flying buttresses, with their arched forms and pinnacles, contributed to this overall impression of lightness and upward movement

Play of light and shadow

• Flying buttresses help to create the dramatic interplay of light and shadow that characterizes Gothic cathedral interiors
• By supporting thinner walls and allowing for larger windows, buttresses enable the filtering of light through expansive stained glass
• Shadows cast by the buttresses themselves add to the dynamic visual effects, shifting throughout the day as the sun moves

Visual rhythm and unity

• Repetition of flying buttresses along the length of a cathedral creates a strong visual rhythm and sense of unity
• Regular spacing and consistent design of the buttresses contribute to the harmonious, balanced appearance of the exterior
• Integration of decorative elements on the buttresses (pinnacles, carvings) helps to unify them with the overall architectural composition

Modern structural analysis and preservation

Assessing stability and stresses

• Modern structural engineers use advanced techniques to analyze the stability and structural integrity of historic flying buttresses
• Finite element analysis (FEA) helps to model and assess the distribution of stresses and forces within the buttress system
• Non-destructive testing methods (radar, thermography) used to evaluate the condition of materials and identify potential weaknesses

Restoration challenges and techniques

• Centuries of exposure to the elements, structural settling, and past modifications can compromise the stability of flying buttresses
• Restoration efforts must balance the need for structural interventions with the desire to preserve the historic fabric and appearance
• Common restoration techniques include:
  • Replacing damaged stones with carefully matched materials
  • Reinforcing foundations and piers to ensure stability
  • Installing discreet structural supports (steel ties, anchors) when necessary
  • Cleaning and repointing masonry joints to prevent water infiltration
• Laser scanning and 3D modeling increasingly used to document and monitor the condition of flying buttresses over time