2.1 Ancient Greek and Roman art criticism

Ancient Greek and Roman art criticism laid the foundation for how we think about art today. It introduced key concepts like mimesis (imitation of reality) and sparked debates about art's purpose and moral impact.

Plato and Aristotle's contrasting views on art shaped centuries of discussion. While Plato saw art as potentially deceptive, Aristotle believed it could reveal universal truths and serve as a tool for learning and emotional catharsis.

Mimesis in Ancient Greek Art

The Concept and Role of Mimesis

Top images from around the web for The Concept and Role of Mimesis

• 

  Ancient Greek art - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek art - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Hellenistic art - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek art - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek art - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for The Concept and Role of Mimesis

• 

  Ancient Greek art - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek art - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Hellenistic art - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek art - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Ancient Greek art - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Mimesis, or imitation, was a central concept in ancient Greek art criticism referring to the representation of reality in art
• The concept of mimesis influenced the development of realism in ancient Greek art, particularly in sculpture and painting
• Mimesis played a crucial role in shaping the aesthetic values and artistic practices of ancient Greece
• The debate surrounding mimesis laid the foundation for future discussions on the relationship between art and reality

Plato and Aristotle's Views on Mimesis

• Plato believed that art was an imitation of an imitation, as the physical world itself was an imitation of the ideal forms
  • He argued that art was three times removed from truth and could be deceptive
  • Plato's perspective influenced later debates on the value and purpose of art (e.g., the role of art in society and its potential to influence moral behavior)
• Aristotle viewed mimesis more positively, seeing it as a natural human instinct and a means of learning
  • He believed that art could represent reality in a way that revealed universal truths
  • Aristotle's ideas provided a counterpoint to Plato's more critical view, shaping future discussions on the purpose and value of art

Plato and Aristotle's Influence on Art

Plato's Theory of Forms and Its Impact

• Plato's theory of forms held that the physical world was an imperfect reflection of ideal forms, leading him to view art as a deceptive imitation
  • This perspective influenced later debates on the value and purpose of art (e.g., the role of art in society and its potential to influence moral behavior)
• Plato's dialogues, such as "The Republic" and "Ion," addressed the role of art in society and its potential to influence moral behavior
  • In "The Republic," Plato argued for the censorship of certain forms of art to protect moral values
  • "Ion" explores the nature of artistic inspiration and the relationship between the artist and the divine

Aristotle's "Poetics" and Its Significance

• Aristotle's "Poetics" is considered one of the earliest surviving works of literary criticism, focusing on the elements and structure of tragedy
  • His ideas on catharsis (the purging of emotions through art) and the role of emotion in art influenced later aesthetic theories
  • "Poetics" also discusses the importance of plot, character, and theme in literary works
• Aristotle's emphasis on the educational and cathartic value of art provided a counterpoint to Plato's more critical view
  • He believed that art could help individuals develop empathy and understanding of human nature
  • Aristotle's ideas shaped future discussions on the purpose and value of art

Rhetorical Theory in Roman Criticism

The Application of Rhetorical Principles to Art

• Rhetorical theory, which originated in ancient Greece, played a significant role in Roman art criticism and the evaluation of artistic works
• The Roman philosopher and rhetorician Cicero applied rhetorical principles to the analysis of art, emphasizing the importance of clarity, coherence, and persuasiveness in artistic expression
  • Cicero's works, such as "De Oratore" and "Brutus," discuss the role of rhetoric in art and the qualities of effective artistic communication
• The use of rhetorical devices, such as metaphor, allegory, and symbolism, was examined in the context of Roman art criticism, as these elements were seen as powerful tools for conveying meaning and emotion
  • For example, the use of allegory in Roman poetry and visual arts was analyzed through the lens of rhetorical theory

Quintilian's Views on Art and Education

• Quintilian, another influential Roman rhetorician, discussed the role of art in education and the cultivation of moral character
  • He believed that the study of art could help develop critical thinking skills and ethical behavior
  • In his work "Institutio Oratoria," Quintilian emphasizes the importance of a well-rounded education that includes the study of art and literature
• Quintilian's ideas contributed to the development of a more systematic and analytical approach to the evaluation of artistic works in Roman criticism
  • His emphasis on the educational value of art influenced later discussions on the role of art in society and personal development

Art and Morality in Ancient Criticism

The Debate on Art's Influence on Moral Behavior

• Ancient Greek and Roman philosophers often explored the connection between art and morality, debating the potential of art to influence moral behavior and character development
• Plato believed that art could have a negative impact on morality, as it had the power to arouse strong emotions and lead people astray from rational thought
  • He argued for the censorship of certain forms of art (e.g., poetry and drama) to protect moral values
  • Plato's views on art and morality influenced later discussions on the social responsibility of artists
• Aristotle took a more moderate stance, acknowledging the potential of art to influence moral behavior but also recognizing its educational and cathartic value
  • He believed that art could help individuals develop empathy and understanding of human nature
  • Aristotle's ideas provided a counterpoint to Plato's more critical view, shaping future discussions on the ethical implications of artistic expression

The Importance of Appropriate Artistic Subjects and Themes

• The Roman philosopher Seneca emphasized the importance of selecting appropriate artistic subjects and themes that promoted virtuous behavior and moral character
  • In his work "Moral Epistles," Seneca argues that art should serve a moral purpose and contribute to the cultivation of wisdom and virtue
  • He believed that artists had a responsibility to create works that inspired ethical behavior and personal growth
• The debate surrounding art and morality in ancient criticism laid the groundwork for future discussions on the social responsibility of artists and the ethical implications of artistic expression
  • These ideas influenced later movements, such as the didactic function of art in medieval Christian thought and the moral concerns of Victorian art criticism