6.3 Postcolonial art criticism and the critique of cultural imperialism

Postcolonial art criticism emerged in the late 20th century to challenge Western-centric views of art. It explores concepts like hybridity, diaspora, and alterity, drawing from cultural studies, anthropology, and political theory to examine power dynamics between colonizers and the colonized.

This approach deconstructs the Eurocentric art canon and critiques cultural imperialism. It questions Western dominance in art institutions and challenges stereotypical representations of non-Western art. Postcolonial criticism has led to increased recognition of diverse artistic traditions and alternative art histories.

Origins of Postcolonial Art Criticism

Emergence and Key Concepts

Top images from around the web for Emergence and Key Concepts

• 

  Rosalind Krauss and American Philisophical Art Criticism: From Formalism to Beyond Postmodernism View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rosalind Krauss and American Philisophical Art Criticism: From Formalism to Beyond Postmodernism View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

Top images from around the web for Emergence and Key Concepts

• 

  Rosalind Krauss and American Philisophical Art Criticism: From Formalism to Beyond Postmodernism View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rosalind Krauss and American Philisophical Art Criticism: From Formalism to Beyond Postmodernism View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

• Postcolonial art criticism emerged in the late 20th century as a response to the legacy of colonialism and its impact on art and culture in formerly colonized regions
• Key concepts in postcolonial art criticism challenge Western-centric perspectives and highlight the experiences of marginalized communities
  • Hybridity explores the mixing and blending of cultural identities and practices (Afro-Caribbean art)
  • Diaspora refers to the dispersal and migration of people from their ancestral homelands (South Asian artists in the UK)
  • Alterity emphasizes the recognition and respect for cultural differences and otherness (Indigenous Australian art)
  • The subaltern focuses on the voices and experiences of marginalized or oppressed groups (Dalit artists in India)

Interdisciplinary Influences and Theorists

• Postcolonial art criticism draws from various disciplines to analyze the power dynamics and cultural exchanges between the colonizer and the colonized
  • Cultural studies examines the production, circulation, and consumption of cultural artifacts and meanings
  • Anthropology investigates the social and cultural practices of human societies across time and space
  • Political theory explores issues of power, governance, and resistance in colonial and postcolonial contexts
• Influential postcolonial theorists have shaped the discourse of postcolonial art criticism by examining issues of representation, identity, and resistance
  • Edward Said's concept of Orientalism critiqued the Western construction and representation of the "Orient" as an exotic and inferior other
  • Homi K. Bhabha's notion of hybridity emphasized the ambivalence and negotiation of cultural identities in colonial and postcolonial contexts
  • Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak's work on the subaltern highlighted the need to amplify the voices and agency of marginalized subjects in art and cultural discourses

Challenging the Eurocentric Canon

• Postcolonial art criticism seeks to deconstruct the Eurocentric canon and challenge the hierarchies and binaries that have historically privileged Western art and aesthetics
• It questions the universal validity and superiority of Western artistic traditions and values (Renaissance, Modernism)
• Postcolonial art criticism advocates for the recognition and inclusion of diverse artistic practices and knowledge systems from non-Western cultures (African masks, Islamic calligraphy)
• It challenges the notion of a singular, linear art history and promotes alternative, pluralistic narratives that acknowledge the contributions and innovations of non-Western artists and cultures

Critique of Cultural Imperialism

Domination and Imposition of Western Culture

• Cultural imperialism refers to the domination and imposition of Western cultural values, norms, and practices on non-Western societies through various means, including art and cultural institutions
• Postcolonial art criticism interrogates the ways in which cultural imperialism perpetuates unequal power relations and marginalizes or appropriates non-Western art and cultural practices
• It examines how Western cultural institutions (museums, galleries, art schools) have historically privileged and promoted Western art while excluding or devaluing non-Western art
• Postcolonial art criticism also critiques the imposition of Western aesthetic standards and criteria as universal and normative (perspective, realism)

Colonial Gaze and Othering

• Critics argue that cultural imperialism reinforces a colonial gaze, exoticizing and othering non-Western art and artists while maintaining Western cultural hegemony
• The colonial gaze constructs non-Western cultures as primitive, exotic, or inferior, denying their complexity and contemporaneity (Orientalist paintings, ethnographic exhibitions)
• Postcolonial art criticism challenges the objectification and fetishization of non-Western art and artists as curiosities or sources of inspiration for Western artists (Picasso's appropriation of African masks)
• It critiques the use of stereotypical or essentialist representations that flatten the diversity and dynamism of non-Western cultures (the "noble savage," the "mystical East")

Institutional Critique and Decolonization

• Postcolonial art criticism examines the role of museums, galleries, and art markets in perpetuating cultural imperialism by privileging Western aesthetics and modes of display
• It critiques the colonial origins and legacies of many Western art institutions (British Museum, Louvre) and their acquisition and display of non-Western art as trophies or curiosities
• The critique of cultural imperialism also extends to the use of language and terminology in art discourse, which often reflects Western-centric biases and assumptions ("primitive art," "ethnic art")
• Postcolonial art criticism calls for a decolonization of art institutions and practices, advocating for greater representation, agency, and self-determination for non-Western artists and communities
• It promotes the repatriation of looted or unethically acquired artworks to their communities of origin (Benin Bronzes, Maori carvings)
• Postcolonial art criticism also supports the development of alternative, community-based art spaces and initiatives that prioritize local knowledge, practices, and values

Representation of Non-Western Art

Primitivism, Exoticism, and Authenticity

• Postcolonial art criticism interrogates the ways in which non-Western art and artists have been historically represented, often through the lens of primitivism, exoticism, or cultural authenticity
• Primitivism refers to the Western fascination with and appropriation of non-Western art as a source of raw, untamed creativity and spirituality (Gauguin's Tahitian paintings)
• Exoticism constructs non-Western cultures as alluring, mysterious, or sensual, often through stereotypical or romanticized imagery (Delacroix's Orientalist paintings)
• Cultural authenticity assumes that non-Western art should conform to traditional, unchanging, or "pure" cultural expressions, denying the possibility of innovation, hybridity, or contemporaneity

Challenging Binaries and Stereotypes

• Critics argue that these representations perpetuate stereotypes and power imbalances, denying non-Western artists agency and complexity in their artistic expressions
• Postcolonial theory challenges the binary opposition between "traditional" and "contemporary" art, recognizing the fluid and dynamic nature of cultural practices and identities
• It critiques the essentialist notion of "authentic" or "pure" cultural expressions, acknowledging the historical and ongoing exchanges, influences, and transformations of art and culture
• Postcolonial art criticism examines the ways in which non-Western artists negotiate their cultural heritage and engage with global art discourses, often through strategies of appropriation, subversion, or hybridity (Yinka Shonibare's Victorian-style African textile installations)

Diaspora, Migration, and Cultural Identity

• The representation of diaspora and migrant artists is a key concern in postcolonial art criticism, as it highlights the complexities of cultural identity, belonging, and displacement in the context of globalization
• Diaspora artists often navigate multiple cultural influences and affiliations, challenging fixed notions of national or ethnic identity (British-Nigerian artist Chris Ofili)
• Migrant artists may face issues of cultural translation, adaptation, or assimilation as they negotiate their place in new cultural contexts (Chinese-American artist Hung Liu)
• Postcolonial art criticism explores how diaspora and migrant artists use their art to express hybrid, fluid, or transnational identities and to critique the boundaries and exclusions of national or cultural categories

Commodification and Authenticity in the Global Art Market

• Postcolonial art criticism also addresses issues of cultural authenticity and the commodification of non-Western art in the global art market, questioning the power dynamics and ethical implications of such practices
• It critiques the fetishization and marketing of non-Western art as "primitive," "tribal," or "ethnic" art, which often decontextualizes and devalues the cultural significance and complexity of these artworks
• Postcolonial art criticism examines the role of Western collectors, dealers, and auction houses in shaping the value and circulation of non-Western art, often based on problematic notions of rarity, authenticity, or exoticism
• It also addresses issues of cultural appropriation and exploitation, where non-Western art and cultural practices are commodified and consumed by Western audiences without proper recognition, compensation, or respect for the originating communities

Impact of Postcolonial Art Criticism

Challenging Eurocentric Biases and Assumptions

• Postcolonial art criticism has challenged the Eurocentric biases and assumptions that have historically shaped the global art world, calling for greater diversity, inclusivity, and cultural sensitivity
• It has exposed the limitations and exclusions of Western art historical narratives and canons, which have marginalized or ignored the contributions of non-Western artists and cultures
• Postcolonial art criticism has promoted the recognition and appreciation of diverse artistic traditions, aesthetics, and knowledge systems from around the world
• It has encouraged a more critical and reflexive approach to the study and practice of art history, acknowledging the power dynamics and cultural biases that shape our understanding and valuation of art

Increased Representation and Recognition

• The critique of cultural imperialism has led to increased awareness and recognition of non-Western art and artists, as well as the need for more equitable representation in art institutions and discourses
• Postcolonial art criticism has advocated for the inclusion and visibility of non-Western artists in major exhibitions, biennials, and art fairs (Venice Biennale, Documenta)
• It has supported the development of dedicated spaces, platforms, and initiatives for non-Western art and artists, such as specialized museums, galleries, and residencies (Museum of African Contemporary Art Al Maaden, Sharjah Art Foundation)
• Postcolonial art criticism has also promoted the work of curators, scholars, and educators from non-Western backgrounds, who bring diverse perspectives and expertise to the field

Alternative Art Histories and Narratives

• Postcolonial art criticism has contributed to the development of alternative art histories and narratives that center the experiences and perspectives of marginalized communities and challenge dominant Western paradigms
• It has emphasized the need for more inclusive, pluralistic, and decolonial approaches to art history, which acknowledge the multiple modernities and artistic innovations of non-Western cultures
• Postcolonial art criticism has promoted the study and preservation of indigenous, diasporic, and minority art histories, which have often been overlooked or suppressed by colonial or nationalist narratives
• It has also encouraged the development of transnational and comparative art histories, which explore the cross-cultural exchanges, influences, and parallels between different artistic traditions and movements

Global Art Biennials and Exhibitions

• The impact of postcolonial art criticism can be seen in the rise of global art biennials, exhibitions, and platforms that showcase the work of non-Western artists and engage with postcolonial themes and issues
• Major biennials and exhibitions, such as the Havana Biennial, the Gwangju Biennale, and the Asia Pacific Triennial, have prioritized the representation of artists from the Global South and diaspora
• These events have provided important opportunities for non-Western artists to gain international recognition, network with peers and professionals, and engage with global art discourses
• They have also served as sites for critical reflection and dialogue on postcolonial issues, such as cultural identity, globalization, migration, and social justice

Curatorial Practices and Museum Policies

• Postcolonial art criticism has also influenced curatorial practices and museum policies, leading to greater collaboration, consultation, and repatriation efforts with indigenous and diasporic communities
• Museums and cultural institutions have increasingly recognized the need to address their colonial legacies and to develop more ethical and inclusive approaches to the collection, display, and interpretation of non-Western art
• This has involved initiatives such as the repatriation of looted or unethically acquired artworks, the development of collaborative exhibitions and programs with source communities, and the hiring of diverse staff and advisors
• Postcolonial art criticism has also promoted the use of alternative curatorial strategies, such as co-curation, community engagement, and participatory practices, which prioritize the voices and agency of marginalized communities

Contemporary Art Discourses and Practices

• The legacy of postcolonial art criticism continues to shape contemporary art discourses and practices, as artists and scholars grapple with the ongoing effects of colonialism, globalization, and cultural exchange in the 21st century
• Contemporary artists from non-Western backgrounds often engage with postcolonial themes and strategies in their work, such as hybridity, appropriation, and critique of power structures (Kehinde Wiley's subversive portraits, Kara Walker's silhouette installations)
• Postcolonial art criticism has also informed the development of new theoretical frameworks and methodologies, such as decolonial aesthetics, critical race art history, and global art studies
• It has encouraged a more reflexive and politically engaged approach to art criticism and scholarship, which acknowledges the social, cultural, and ethical dimensions of art and its interpretation
• The ongoing impact of postcolonial art criticism can be seen in the proliferation of exhibitions, publications, and academic programs dedicated to non-Western and diasporic art, as well as the growing recognition of the global and multicultural nature of contemporary art practice.