9.1 Hermeneutics and the art of interpretation

Hermeneutics in art interpretation digs into the meaning behind artworks. It looks at historical context, artist intentions, and viewer experiences to uncover layers of significance. This approach recognizes that art's meaning isn't fixed, but emerges through interaction between the work and its audience.

The history of hermeneutics in art criticism traces back to ancient Greek philosophy. It evolved through the centuries, with thinkers like Schleiermacher and Gadamer shaping its modern form. Their ideas about the "hermeneutic circle" and "fusion of horizons" still influence how we understand art today.

Hermeneutics for Art Interpretation

Definition and Relevance

Top images from around the web for Definition and Relevance

• 

  Chagall Tribe of Levi detail 2 – Matters of Interpretation View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  "Introduction to Art: Design, Context, and Meaning" by Pamela Sachant, Peggy Blood et al. View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Analyzing Symbols | Art Appreciation View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chagall Tribe of Levi detail 2 – Matters of Interpretation View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  "Introduction to Art: Design, Context, and Meaning" by Pamela Sachant, Peggy Blood et al. View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Definition and Relevance

• 

  Chagall Tribe of Levi detail 2 – Matters of Interpretation View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  "Introduction to Art: Design, Context, and Meaning" by Pamela Sachant, Peggy Blood et al. View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Reading: Analyzing Symbols | Art Appreciation View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Chagall Tribe of Levi detail 2 – Matters of Interpretation View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  "Introduction to Art: Design, Context, and Meaning" by Pamela Sachant, Peggy Blood et al. View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Hermeneutics is the theory and methodology of interpretation, particularly the interpretation of texts, artworks, and cultural artifacts
• In the context of art, hermeneutics seeks to uncover the meaning, symbolism, and significance of artworks through a process of interpretation
• Hermeneutics considers the historical, cultural, and social contexts in which an artwork was created, as well as the artist's intentions and the viewer's subjective experiences
• The application of hermeneutics to art interpretation acknowledges the complex, multifaceted nature of artistic meaning and the role of the interpreter in constructing that meaning
• Hermeneutics recognizes that the meaning of an artwork is not fixed or inherent, but rather emerges through the dynamic interaction between the artwork, the artist, and the viewer
• Example: A hermeneutical approach to interpreting Leonardo da Vinci's "Mona Lisa" would consider factors such as the Renaissance cultural context, Leonardo's artistic techniques and intentions, and the viewer's own emotional response to the enigmatic smile

Hermeneutics in Art Criticism: History

Origins and Development

• The origins of hermeneutics can be traced back to ancient Greek philosophy, particularly the works of Aristotle and his ideas on the interpretation of literature
• In the 19th century, German philosophers such as Friedrich Schleiermacher and Wilhelm Dilthey developed hermeneutics as a systematic method for interpreting texts, emphasizing the importance of understanding the author's intentions and historical context
• Schleiermacher introduced the concept of the "hermeneutic circle," which describes the iterative process of interpreting parts of a text in relation to the whole, and vice versa
• Dilthey expanded the scope of hermeneutics beyond texts to encompass all forms of human expression, including art, and emphasized the role of empathy in understanding the artist's lived experience

Philosophical Hermeneutics

• The 20th century saw the emergence of philosophical hermeneutics, led by thinkers such as Martin Heidegger and Hans-Georg Gadamer, who expanded the scope of hermeneutics to encompass all forms of human understanding, including the interpretation of art
• Heidegger's concept of the "hermeneutic circle" highlights the iterative nature of interpretation, in which the understanding of the whole informs the interpretation of the parts, and vice versa
• Heidegger also emphasized the role of the interpreter's own historical and cultural context in shaping their understanding of an artwork
• Gadamer's theory of "fusion of horizons" emphasizes the dialogical nature of interpretation, in which the interpreter's own historical and cultural context merges with that of the artwork to create new meaning
• Gadamer argued that the meaning of an artwork is not fixed or predetermined, but rather emerges through the dynamic interaction between the artwork and the viewer

Applying Hermeneutical Approaches to Art

Interpreting Artworks

• The hermeneutical approach to art interpretation involves a close examination of the artwork itself, including its formal elements, subject matter, and symbolism
• Interpreters must also consider the historical, cultural, and social contexts in which the artwork was created, as well as the artist's biography, intentions, and influences
• Example: In interpreting Pablo Picasso's "Guernica," a hermeneutical approach would consider the painting's cubist style, its depiction of the horrors of war, and the historical context of the Spanish Civil War
• The viewer's own subjective experiences, knowledge, and cultural background play a crucial role in the interpretation process, as they shape the way the artwork is perceived and understood
• Example: A viewer with a personal history of war or violence may interpret "Guernica" differently than a viewer without such experiences

The Dialogical Process

• Hermeneutical interpretation often involves a dialogical process, in which the interpreter engages in a "conversation" with the artwork, asking questions, making connections, and revising their understanding as new insights emerge
• This dialogical process recognizes that the meaning of an artwork is not fixed or static, but rather evolves through the active engagement of the viewer
• The application of hermeneutics to art interpretation can lead to multiple, sometimes conflicting interpretations of the same artwork, reflecting the inherent ambiguity and openness of artistic meaning
• Example: Different viewers may interpret the smile of the "Mona Lisa" as enigmatic, seductive, or melancholic, depending on their own perspectives and experiences

Strengths vs Limitations of Hermeneutics in Art Criticism

Strengths

• One of the main strengths of hermeneutics is its ability to uncover the rich, multifaceted nature of artistic meaning, taking into account the complex interplay of historical, cultural, and personal factors that shape the creation and reception of art
• Hermeneutics encourages a deep, nuanced engagement with artworks, fostering a greater appreciation for the artist's intentions, the artwork's historical significance, and the viewer's own role in the interpretation process
• By recognizing the role of the viewer in constructing meaning, hermeneutics democratizes the interpretation of art and challenges the notion of a single, authoritative interpretation
• Hermeneutics provides a framework for understanding how artworks can have different meanings for different viewers, and how those meanings can change over time

Limitations and Criticisms

• However, the subjective nature of hermeneutical interpretation can also be seen as a limitation, as it may lead to relativism and the idea that all interpretations are equally valid, regardless of their grounding in evidence or logical coherence
• Some critics argue that an overemphasis on the viewer's subjective experience may lead to interpretations that are more reflective of the viewer's own biases and preconceptions than the artwork itself
• The emphasis on the interpreter's own context and experiences may also lead to a neglect of the artwork's inherent qualities and the artist's intentions, potentially resulting in interpretations that stray too far from the artwork itself
• Some critics argue that hermeneutics, with its focus on language and textual interpretation, may not be fully adequate for addressing the unique challenges posed by visual and non-representational art forms
• The open-ended nature of hermeneutical interpretation may also make it difficult to arrive at a consensus or shared understanding of an artwork's meaning, potentially limiting its usefulness in academic or critical contexts