12.1 Copyright and intellectual property

Copyright law emerged to protect creative works, including photographs, in response to technological advancements in reproduction. It balances creators' rights with public access to information and cultural heritage, shaping the legal landscape for artistic innovation.

As photography gained recognition as an art form, copyright laws expanded to include visual works. This evolution reflects the growing understanding of intellectual property rights and their importance in fostering creativity while addressing challenges in the digital age.

Origins of copyright law

• Copyright law emerged as a response to technological advancements in printing and reproduction, shaping the legal landscape for creative works including photography
• The development of copyright protection reflects the evolving understanding of intellectual property rights and their importance in fostering artistic innovation

Early copyright statutes

Top images from around the web for Early copyright statutes

• 

  Intellectual Property | Information Systems View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Open Source Copyright Casebook: Class 1: Introduction to Copyright View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Intellectual Property | Information Systems View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Open Source Copyright Casebook: Class 1: Introduction to Copyright View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

Top images from around the web for Early copyright statutes

• 

  Intellectual Property | Information Systems View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Open Source Copyright Casebook: Class 1: Introduction to Copyright View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Intellectual Property | Information Systems View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Open Source Copyright Casebook: Class 1: Introduction to Copyright View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 2

• Statute of Anne (1710) established first modern copyright law in England
• Granted authors exclusive rights to their works for a limited time period
• Influenced subsequent copyright legislation in other countries (United States Copyright Act of 1790)
• Focused primarily on written works, laying groundwork for future expansion to visual arts

Evolution of intellectual property

• Gradual expansion of copyright protection to include various forms of creative expression
• Incorporation of visual works, including photographs, into copyright frameworks
• Shift from purely economic rights to recognition of moral rights for creators
• International agreements (Berne Convention) standardized copyright protection across borders

Copyright in photography

• Photographic works gained copyright protection in the late 19th century, recognizing the artistic and commercial value of images
• Copyright laws for photography balance the rights of creators with the public interest in access to information and cultural heritage

Originality requirements

• Photographs must exhibit minimal creativity to qualify for copyright protection
• Courts consider factors such as composition, lighting, timing, and subject selection
• Mere mechanical reproduction of existing works generally does not meet originality threshold
• Candid or spontaneous photos can still be copyrightable if they involve creative choices

Idea vs expression dichotomy

• Copyright protects the expression of ideas in photographs, not the underlying ideas themselves
• Similar photographs of the same subject can be independently copyrightable
• Scenes a faire doctrine limits protection for standard or inevitable elements in certain types of photographs
• Photographers can copyright their unique interpretation of common subjects (landscapes, portraits)

Types of photographic copyright

• Copyright law recognizes various categories of photographic works, each with distinct legal considerations and protections
• Understanding these distinctions helps photographers navigate their rights and obligations in different contexts

Artistic vs commercial works

• Artistic photographs focus on aesthetic value and creative expression
• Commercial photographs serve primarily functional or promotional purposes
• Different standards may apply for fair use and licensing of artistic vs commercial works
• Some photographs can be considered both artistic and commercial, depending on context and use

Derivative works in photography

• Photographs based on or incorporating existing copyrighted works
• Require permission from original copyright holder unless fair use applies
• Include photo manipulations, collages, and adaptations of other visual works
• Derivative works can receive their own copyright protection for original elements added

Duration of copyright protection

• Copyright duration for photographs has evolved over time, reflecting changing attitudes towards intellectual property
• Understanding copyright terms is crucial for determining when works enter the public domain and become freely usable

Term length for photographs

• In the United States, works created after 1978 protected for life of author plus 70 years
• Works made for hire protected for 95 years from publication or 120 years from creation, whichever is shorter
• Different terms may apply to older works or in other countries
• Anonymous or pseudonymous works have specific duration rules

Public domain considerations

• Photographs enter public domain after copyright expiration
• Some works immediately enter public domain (U.S. government works)
• Public domain status can vary by country due to different copyright terms
• Determining public domain status requires careful analysis of creation date, publication history, and applicable laws

Fair use doctrine

• Fair use allows limited use of copyrighted material without permission for purposes such as criticism, commentary, or education
• This doctrine plays a crucial role in balancing copyright protection with free speech and creative expression in photography

Four factors of fair use

• Purpose and character of use (including commercial vs non-profit educational use)
• Nature of copyrighted work
• Amount and substantiality of portion used
• Effect on potential market or value of copyrighted work
• Courts weigh these factors holistically, no single factor is determinative

Fair use in photography

• Applies to various photographic uses (news reporting, artistic appropriation, educational purposes)
• Transformative uses more likely to be considered fair use
• Parody and criticism of photographs often protected under fair use
• Commercial use does not automatically preclude fair use, but may weigh against it

Licensing and permissions

• Licensing allows photographers to grant specific rights to use their work while retaining copyright
• Understanding different license types helps photographers maximize the value of their work and control its use

Types of photo licenses

• Rights-managed licenses grant specific, limited usage rights
• Royalty-free licenses allow broader use for a one-time fee
• Exclusive licenses grant sole usage rights to a single entity
• Non-exclusive licenses allow multiple parties to use the work simultaneously

Creative Commons licenses

• Standardized public copyright licenses for free distribution of creative works
• Six main license types offering different levels of permissions
• Allow creators to specify allowed uses (attribution, non-commercial, no derivatives)
• Facilitate sharing and reuse of photographs while maintaining some control

Digital rights management

• DRM technologies aim to control access, use, and distribution of digital photographs
• These measures have become increasingly important in the age of widespread digital sharing and reproduction

Technological protection measures

• Watermarking embeds visible or invisible information in digital images
• Encryption restricts access to authorized users or devices
• Metadata tagging includes copyright information within image files
• Digital fingerprinting allows tracking of image use across the internet

DMCA and takedown notices

• Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) provides legal framework for addressing online copyright infringement
• Copyright holders can submit takedown notices to online service providers
• Safe harbor provisions protect service providers who comply with takedown procedures
• Counter-notice process allows users to dispute improper takedowns

Copyright infringement in photography

• Unauthorized use of copyrighted photographs can lead to legal consequences
• Photographers and users alike must understand the various forms of infringement to protect their rights and avoid liability

Direct vs indirect infringement

• Direct infringement involves unauthorized reproduction, distribution, or display of copyrighted photographs
• Indirect infringement includes contributory infringement (knowingly facilitating infringement) and vicarious infringement (profiting from infringement while having right and ability to stop it)
• Online platforms may face indirect infringement claims for user-uploaded content
• Determining infringement requires analysis of substantial similarity and access to original work

Damages and remedies

• Statutory damages range from $750 to$30,000 per work (up to $150,000 for willful infringement)
• Actual damages based on lost profits or infringer's profits
• Injunctive relief to stop ongoing infringement
• Attorney's fees may be awarded to prevailing party in some cases

International copyright law

• Photography's global nature necessitates understanding of international copyright frameworks
• Harmonization efforts aim to provide consistent protection across borders while respecting national differences

Berne Convention overview

• Established minimum standards for copyright protection among signatory countries
• Automatic protection without registration in member countries
• National treatment principle ensures equal protection for foreign and domestic works
• Minimum copyright term of life plus 50 years (many countries extend this)

Cross-border copyright issues

• Determining applicable law in international infringement cases
• Enforcement challenges in countries with weak copyright protection
• Impact of digital technologies on territorial nature of copyright
• Efforts to streamline cross-border licensing and enforcement (EU Copyright Directive)

Moral rights for photographers

• Moral rights protect non-economic interests of creators, recognizing the personal connection between artists and their work
• These rights are particularly relevant in photography, where attribution and integrity of images are crucial

Right of attribution

• Photographer's right to be identified as the author of their work
• Includes right to publish anonymously or under a pseudonym
• Persists even after transfer of economic rights
• May be waived in some jurisdictions, but generally cannot be transferred

Right of integrity

• Protects against distortion, mutilation, or modification of photographs that would harm the creator's reputation
• Balances artistic integrity with fair use and freedom of expression
• Scope of protection varies by jurisdiction (stronger in civil law countries)
• May conflict with property rights of physical photograph owners

Orphan works

• Orphan works are copyrighted photographs whose owners cannot be identified or located
• These works present unique challenges for users seeking to obtain permissions and for society's interest in preserving cultural heritage

Challenges of orphan photographs

• Risk of liability for using works without permission
• Difficulty in determining copyright status and duration
• Loss of historical and cultural value when works cannot be used or preserved
• Disproportionate impact on archives, libraries, and educational institutions

Proposed solutions for usage

• Creation of orphan works registries to facilitate searches for copyright owners
• Limited liability provisions for good faith users of orphan works
• Extended collective licensing systems to cover orphan works
• Compulsory licensing schemes with escrow payments for potential rights holders

Copyright registration process

• While copyright protection is automatic upon creation, registration offers additional benefits and protections for photographers
• Understanding the registration process helps photographers maximize their legal rights and remedies

Benefits of registration

• Establishes public record of copyright claim
• Required for filing infringement lawsuit in U.S. federal court
• Allows recovery of statutory damages and attorney's fees in litigation
• Creates legal presumption of validity if registered within five years of publication

Registration procedures for photos

• Online registration through U.S. Copyright Office electronic system
• Group registration options for published and unpublished photographs
• Deposit requirements vary based on publication status and format
• Expedited registration available for time-sensitive cases (additional fee)

Copyright vs trademark vs patent

• Understanding the distinctions between different forms of intellectual property protection helps photographers navigate complex legal landscapes
• Some photographic works may benefit from multiple forms of protection

Distinctions in intellectual property

• Copyright protects original creative expression in photographs
• Trademarks protect distinctive signs, symbols, or designs used in commerce
• Patents protect novel inventions and processes (relevant for photographic equipment)
• Trade secrets protect confidential business information (e.g., proprietary photo editing techniques)

Overlapping protections for images

• Logos or distinctive designs in photographs may be protected by both copyright and trademark
• Product photographs may implicate copyright, trademark, and patent considerations
• Some jurisdictions offer sui generis protection for databases of images
• Unfair competition laws may provide additional protection in commercial contexts

Future of photographic copyright

• Emerging technologies and changing creative practices are challenging traditional copyright frameworks
• Adapting copyright law to address these challenges will be crucial for protecting photographers' rights in the digital age

Impact of AI-generated images

• Questions of authorship and originality for AI-created photographs
• Potential need for new legal frameworks to address machine learning-based works
• Implications for copyright infringement when AI systems are trained on copyrighted images
• Balancing protection of human creativity with innovation in AI technologies

Blockchain for copyright management

• Decentralized systems for registering and tracking photographic copyrights
• Smart contracts to automate licensing and royalty payments
• Enhanced ability to prove ownership and track usage of digital images
• Potential for more efficient and transparent copyright management systems