6.3 The concept of Verfremdungseffekt (alienation effect)

Bertolt Brecht's Verfremdungseffekt, or alienation effect, shook up traditional theatre. This technique aimed to distance audiences from emotional involvement, encouraging critical thinking about social issues. It challenged the idea that plays should be purely entertaining or cathartic.

Brecht used various methods to achieve this effect. Breaking the fourth wall, non-realistic staging, and episodic structures were key. These techniques reminded viewers they were watching a play, pushing them to question societal norms and consider the need for change.

Verfremdungseffekt in Brechtian Theatre

Definition and Purpose

Top images from around the web for Definition and Purpose

• 

  Rhetorical Context | Writing Skills Lab View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Theatre of the absurd - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Toward a Psychology of Social Change: A Typology of Social Change View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rhetorical Context | Writing Skills Lab View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Theatre of the absurd - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Definition and Purpose

• 

  Rhetorical Context | Writing Skills Lab View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Theatre of the absurd - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Toward a Psychology of Social Change: A Typology of Social Change View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Rhetorical Context | Writing Skills Lab View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Theatre of the absurd - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Verfremdungseffekt, or the alienation effect, is a theatrical technique developed by German playwright Bertolt Brecht in the early 20th century
• Aims to distance the audience from emotional involvement in the story and characters, encouraging them to view the play critically and objectively
• Brecht believed that by creating a sense of estrangement or "making strange" the familiar aspects of society (social norms, power structures), the audience would be compelled to question the status quo and consider the need for social change
• Achieved through various staging techniques, acting styles, and narrative devices that constantly remind the audience they are watching a play, rather than allowing them to become fully immersed in the fictional world

Brechtian Philosophy

• Brecht rejected the Aristotelian concept of theatre, which emphasized the audience's emotional identification with characters and catharsis through the resolution of conflicts
• Instead, he advocated for a theatre that would stimulate the audience's intellect and encourage them to critically examine the social and political issues presented on stage
• Brecht believed that the theatre should be a tool for social and political change, exposing the contradictions and injustices of society and inspiring the audience to take action

Techniques for Alienation Effect

Breaking the Fourth Wall

• Direct audience address involves actors speaking directly to the audience, acknowledging their presence and breaking the illusion of the "fourth wall" that traditionally separates the stage from the spectators
• Can also be achieved through asides, where characters step out of the scene to comment on the action or share their thoughts with the audience
• Placards or signs displaying commentary, scene titles, or summaries may be used to interrupt the flow of the narrative and provide a critical framework for the audience

Non-Realistic Staging

• Non-realistic or minimalist stage design, exposed lighting, and visible stage machinery can highlight the artificiality of the theatrical presentation and prevent the audience from becoming fully absorbed in the illusion
• Costumes and props may be intentionally anachronistic or incongruous with the setting to further emphasize the constructed nature of the performance
• The use of a half curtain or visible scene changes can also serve to disrupt the illusion and remind the audience that they are watching a play

Episodic Structure and Narrative Devices

• Epic Theatre often employs an episodic structure, presenting a series of loosely connected scenes rather than a tightly-knit plot, to encourage the audience to focus on the larger social and political themes rather than individual character arcs
• Songs or musical interludes that comment on the action or themes of the play can also serve to disrupt the narrative and encourage critical reflection (The Threepenny Opera)
• Narration, placards, and projected titles can provide additional context or commentary on the action, guiding the audience's interpretation of the events on stage

Acting Techniques

• Actors may adopt a detached or exaggerated acting style, avoiding naturalistic portrayal of characters and emotions, to further emphasize the constructed nature of the performance
• Gestus, a Brechtian acting technique, involves the use of specific gestures, movements, and facial expressions to convey the social and political attitudes of a character, rather than their individual psychology
• Actors may also directly address the audience, comment on their own characters, or switch roles to highlight the artificiality of the performance and prevent emotional identification

Purpose of Alienation Effect

Encouraging Critical Thinking

• Aims to transform passive spectators into active, critical thinkers who can analyze the social and political implications of the play's content
• By preventing emotional identification with characters and situations, the alienation effect encourages the audience to approach the play's themes and ideas from a more rational, objective perspective
• The disruption of theatrical illusion can prompt the audience to question the accepted norms, values, and power structures represented in the play and consider alternative possibilities for social organization

Promoting Social Awareness

• Can be particularly effective in addressing social and political issues, as it allows the audience to recognize the constructed nature of societal conventions and the potential for change
• Encourages the audience to examine their own roles and responsibilities within society and consider the need for social and political action
• By exposing the contradictions and injustices of society, the alienation effect can inspire the audience to challenge the status quo and work towards a more equitable and just world

Limitations and Challenges

• The effectiveness of the alienation effect may vary depending on the receptiveness and prior knowledge of the audience, as well as the skill with which the techniques are employed in the production
• Some critics argue that the alienation effect can be intellectually demanding and may alienate audiences who are seeking primarily entertainment or emotional engagement
• The success of the alienation effect also depends on the audience's willingness to actively participate in the critical analysis and reflection encouraged by the techniques

Verfremdungseffekt in Contemporary Theatre

Influence on Modern Theatre Practices

• Many contemporary theatre practitioners have adapted and incorporated elements of the alienation effect into their work, recognizing its potential for encouraging critical engagement with social and political issues
• Epic Theatre, a form pioneered by Brecht, continues to influence contemporary theatre-makers who seek to create politically engaged and thought-provoking performances (Caryl Churchill, Tony Kushner)
• Postmodern and experimental theatre often employ techniques that disrupt the theatrical illusion and challenge the audience's expectations, drawing on the principles of the alienation effect (The Wooster Group, Forced Entertainment)

Application in Other Performing Arts

• The alienation effect has also been applied to other performing arts, such as dance and performance art, where it can be used to subvert traditional forms and provoke critical reflection on the medium itself
• In dance, choreographers may incorporate pedestrian movements, spoken text, or unconventional staging to disrupt the audience's expectations and encourage a critical examination of the art form (Pina Bausch, William Forsythe)
• Performance artists often employ alienation techniques to challenge societal norms, question the boundaries between art and life, and engage the audience in critical dialogue (Marina Abramović, Guillermo Gómez-Peña)

Relevance in Contemporary Society

• In an increasingly media-saturated and politically polarized world, the alienation effect remains a valuable tool for artists seeking to engage audiences in critical dialogue and promote social awareness
• Documentary theatre, verbatim theatre, and theatre of testimony frequently incorporate alienation techniques to underscore the reality of the stories being presented and encourage the audience to consider their implications (The Laramie Project, Notes from the Field)
• As societies continue to grapple with complex social and political issues, the alienation effect can serve as a powerful means of encouraging critical reflection, empathy, and social change