6.2 Therapeutic touch and healing touch

Energy healing modalities like Therapeutic Touch and Healing Touch are gaining attention in holistic healthcare. These practices aim to balance the body's energy field to promote healing and well-being. While their effectiveness is debated, many patients report positive outcomes.

Both techniques involve practitioners using their hands to sense and manipulate energy fields. Therapeutic Touch, developed in the 1970s, focuses on off-body techniques. Healing Touch, from the 1980s, incorporates on-body and off-body methods from various traditions.

Therapeutic Touch vs Healing Touch

Origins and Philosophical Foundations

Top images from around the web for Origins and Philosophical Foundations

• 

  Still Life | Mary Pocock receives therapeutic touch from Mau… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Zwierzenia Wiedźmy: Energetyczny masaż dotykowy - terapia, która zmieni Twoje życie View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lightbody - Ascension Glossary View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Still Life | Mary Pocock receives therapeutic touch from Mau… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Zwierzenia Wiedźmy: Energetyczny masaż dotykowy - terapia, która zmieni Twoje życie View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Origins and Philosophical Foundations

• 

  Still Life | Mary Pocock receives therapeutic touch from Mau… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Zwierzenia Wiedźmy: Energetyczny masaż dotykowy - terapia, która zmieni Twoje życie View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Lightbody - Ascension Glossary View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Still Life | Mary Pocock receives therapeutic touch from Mau… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Zwierzenia Wiedźmy: Energetyczny masaż dotykowy - terapia, która zmieni Twoje życie View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Therapeutic touch (TT) is a nursing intervention developed by Dolores Krieger and Dora Kunz in the 1970s, based on the concept of human energy fields
• Healing touch (HT) is an energy therapy developed by Janet Mentgen in the 1980s, which incorporates a variety of techniques from other energy healing practices
• TT is based on the belief that the practitioner can sense and balance the patient's energy field without necessarily touching the body
• HT involves a combination of on-body and off-body techniques, drawing from various energy healing traditions (Reiki, Ayurveda, Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Differences in Techniques and Procedures

• Both TT and HT involve the practitioner using their hands to sense and manipulate the patient's energy field, but they differ in their specific techniques and philosophical foundations
• TT focuses primarily on off-body techniques, while HT incorporates both on-body and off-body techniques
• TT emphasizes the practitioner's ability to sense and direct energy, while HT places greater emphasis on the patient's active participation in the healing process
• HT includes a wider range of techniques, such as chakra balancing and pain drain, compared to TT

Techniques of Touch Therapies

Therapeutic Touch Procedure

• In TT, the practitioner begins by centering themselves and assessing the patient's energy field through a series of hand movements above the body
  • Centering involves the practitioner becoming grounded and focused, often through meditation or deep breathing
  • Assessment involves sensing areas of imbalance or congestion in the patient's energy field
• The practitioner then uses sweeping or unruffling motions to clear any blockages or congestion in the energy field
  • Sweeping involves smooth, continuous hand movements over the body to remove excess or stagnant energy
  • Unruffling involves more vigorous, shaking motions to break up and disperse areas of congestion
• Finally, the practitioner directs healing energy to the patient through their hands, with the intention of balancing and harmonizing the energy field
  • This may involve visualizing the flow of energy from the practitioner's hands to the patient's body
  • The practitioner may also use specific hand positions or gestures to direct energy to particular areas of the body

Healing Touch Techniques

• HT involves a series of steps, including centering, assessing the energy field, clearing and balancing the energy field, and providing energetic support
  • Centering and assessment are similar to the processes used in TT
  • Clearing and balancing involve a combination of on-body and off-body techniques to remove blockages and restore equilibrium to the energy field
• HT techniques may include light touch, off-body hand movements, and the use of specific hand positions to direct energy to different areas of the body
  • Light touch involves gentle, non-invasive physical contact with the patient's body to promote relaxation and healing
  • Off-body hand movements are similar to those used in TT, but may be more varied and complex
• HT also incorporates techniques such as chakra balancing, magnetic clearing, and pain drain
  • Chakra balancing involves focusing energy on the seven major energy centers of the body to promote physical, emotional, and spiritual well-being
  • Magnetic clearing uses hand movements to remove negative or stagnant energy from the field
  • Pain drain is a technique used to draw pain and discomfort away from the body

Scientific Basis of Touch Therapies

Human Energy Field Concept

• TT and HT are based on the concept of a human energy field or biofield, which is believed to extend beyond the physical body and interact with the environment
  • The biofield is thought to be composed of electromagnetic and subtle energy components that play a role in health and healing
  • This concept is rooted in various traditional healing systems, such as Ayurveda and Traditional Chinese Medicine
• Practitioners of TT and HT propose that imbalances or disruptions in the energy field can lead to physical, emotional, and spiritual health problems
  • These imbalances may manifest as areas of congestion, depletion, or stagnation in the energy field
  • By sensing and manipulating the energy field, practitioners aim to restore balance and promote healing

Proposed Mechanisms of Action

• Proposed mechanisms of action for TT and HT include the transfer of healing energy from the practitioner to the patient, the activation of the patient's self-healing abilities, and the promotion of relaxation and stress reduction
  • Some practitioners believe that they can channel universal life force energy (qi, prana) through their hands and into the patient's body
  • Others propose that the techniques help to stimulate the patient's own innate healing capacities by removing blockages and restoring balance to the energy field
• Some researchers have suggested that the effects of TT and HT may be mediated by the placebo effect, the therapeutic relationship between practitioner and patient, or the activation of the parasympathetic nervous system
  • The placebo effect refers to the positive outcomes that can occur due to a patient's belief in the effectiveness of a treatment
  • The therapeutic relationship involves factors such as empathy, trust, and rapport between the practitioner and patient, which can contribute to healing
  • Activation of the parasympathetic nervous system, responsible for "rest and digest" functions, may promote relaxation and reduce stress, supporting the healing process

Evidence for Touch Therapies

Mixed Research Findings

• Research on the efficacy of TT and HT has yielded mixed results, with some studies showing positive outcomes and others finding no significant effects compared to control groups
• Positive findings have been reported for conditions such as pain, anxiety, stress, and wound healing, but the quality of the evidence is often limited by small sample sizes, lack of blinding, and other methodological issues
  • A systematic review by So et al. (2008) found that TT may have a modest effect on pain relief, but the evidence was not conclusive due to the low quality of the included studies
  • A meta-analysis by Anderson et al. (2015) reported significant reductions in pain and anxiety associated with HT, but noted that the included studies had a high risk of bias

Challenges in Studying Touch Therapies

• Critics argue that the positive effects of TT and HT can be attributed to non-specific factors such as relaxation, expectation, and the therapeutic relationship, rather than the manipulation of energy fields
  • These factors, often referred to as the "common factors" of therapy, are present in many therapeutic interventions and can contribute to positive outcomes
  • Separating the specific effects of energy manipulation from these non-specific factors can be challenging in research design
• The lack of a clear scientific understanding of the human energy field and the difficulty in measuring or quantifying subtle energy pose challenges for research on TT and HT
  • Current scientific instruments may not be sensitive enough to detect the subtle energy changes proposed by TT and HT practitioners
  • The subjective nature of energy perception and the variability in practitioner skill and experience can also complicate research efforts

Future Research Directions

• More high-quality, rigorously designed studies are needed to establish the efficacy of TT and HT and to elucidate their mechanisms of action
  • Randomized controlled trials with larger sample sizes, proper blinding, and well-defined control groups can help to provide more conclusive evidence
  • Studies that compare TT and HT to other established therapies, such as relaxation techniques or massage, can help to determine their relative effectiveness
• Future research should also aim to develop more sensitive and reliable methods for measuring and quantifying subtle energy and its effects on health and well-being
  • Advances in biophysics, bioelectromagnetics, and related fields may provide new tools and insights for studying the human energy field
  • Collaborations between energy healing practitioners, scientists, and healthcare professionals can help to bridge the gap between traditional knowledge and modern research methods