18.2 Prisoner's Dilemma and Cooperation

Game Theory's Prisoner's Dilemma shows how self-interest can lead to bad outcomes for everyone. It's like when you and your friend both want the last slice of pizza, but if you fight, neither gets it.

Repeated interactions can change the game. If you know you'll see your friend again tomorrow, you might share the pizza today. This idea applies to everything from business deals to international politics.

The Prisoner's Dilemma

Game Structure and Payoffs

Top images from around the web for Game Structure and Payoffs

• 

  Oligopoly in Practice | Boundless Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Nash equilibrium - Simulace.info View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Prisoner’s Dilemma | Microeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Oligopoly in Practice | Boundless Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Nash equilibrium - Simulace.info View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Game Structure and Payoffs

• 

  Oligopoly in Practice | Boundless Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Nash equilibrium - Simulace.info View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Prisoner’s Dilemma | Microeconomics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Oligopoly in Practice | Boundless Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Nash equilibrium - Simulace.info View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Prisoner's Dilemma exemplifies conflict between individual and collective rationality in decision-making
• Two suspects interrogated separately choose to cooperate with each other or defect by betraying their partner
• Payoff structure creates situation where individual self-interest leads to suboptimal outcomes for both parties
• Nash Equilibrium occurs when both players choose to defect, despite mutual cooperation yielding better collective outcome
• Demonstrates how rational self-interest can lead to socially inefficient outcomes
• Challenges notion that pursuit of self-interest always benefits society (Adam Smith's invisible hand)

Applications and Implications

• Extends to various fields (economics, political science, environmental studies)
• Illustrates pervasiveness of cooperation dilemmas in society
• Used to analyze arms races, environmental protection, and business competition
• Helps explain difficulties in achieving international cooperation on global issues (climate change)
• Provides insights into human behavior and decision-making processes
• Informs policy design for promoting cooperation in social dilemmas

Repeated Interactions and Cooperation

Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma

• Involves multiple rounds of play, allowing for strategy development based on past behavior and future expectations
• Tit-for-Tat strategy starts with cooperation and mimics opponent's previous move
  • Highly effective in promoting cooperation in repeated interactions
  • Simple, easily understood, and forgiving
• Shadow of the future concept explains how prospect of future interactions incentivizes cooperative behavior in present
• Reputation effects in repeated games lead to emergence of cooperative norms and trust-building between players over time

Theoretical Foundations

• Folk Theorem in game theory suggests cooperation can be sustained as equilibrium in infinitely repeated games if players are sufficiently patient
• Evolutionary game theory models demonstrate how cooperative strategies emerge and persist in populations through natural selection and cultural evolution
• Axelrod's tournaments showed success of simple, cooperative strategies in iterated games
• Repeated interactions allow for learning and adaptation of strategies over time

Strategies for Cooperation

Communication and Trust-Building

• Communication and pre-play agreements significantly enhance cooperation
  • Allow players to coordinate actions and build trust
  • Can lead to formation of social norms and expectations
• Creation of shared group identity or emphasizing common goals fosters cooperation
  • Aligns individual interests with collective outcomes
  • Examples include team-building exercises in organizations
• Transparency and information sharing about others' actions promote cooperation
  • Enables reputation-based decision-making and social learning
  • Public leaderboards for charitable giving

Institutional Mechanisms

• Enforceable contracts or third-party monitoring alter payoff structure to incentivize cooperative behavior
• Graduated sanctions and peer punishment systems deter free-riding
  • Maintain cooperation in large-scale social dilemmas
  • Examples include community-based resource management systems
• Reciprocity norms, both direct and indirect, play crucial role in sustaining cooperation
  • Direct reciprocity (I scratch your back, you scratch mine)
  • Indirect reciprocity (reputation-based cooperation)
• Designing choice architectures that make cooperative options more salient or default
  • Nudges individuals towards more prosocial behaviors
  • Examples include opt-out organ donation systems

Prisoner's Dilemma in the Real World

Global and Environmental Issues

• International climate change agreements exemplify global Prisoner's Dilemma
  • Countries balance short-term economic interests with long-term environmental cooperation
  • Paris Agreement as attempt to overcome this dilemma
• Arms race during Cold War represented Prisoner's Dilemma scenario
  • Mutual disarmament agreements served as attempts to achieve cooperative outcomes
  • SALT and START treaties as examples
• Common pool resource management illustrates community solutions to tragedy of the commons
  • Fisheries management (individual fishing quotas)
  • Water rights allocation systems

Economic and Business Applications

• Cartel behavior in oligopolistic markets demonstrates firms navigating tension between cooperation and defection
  • Maintaining high prices (cooperation) vs. undercutting competitors (defection)
  • OPEC as an example of attempted cartel cooperation
• Corporate social responsibility initiatives viewed as attempts to resolve Prisoner's Dilemma-like situations
  • Balancing profit maximization with societal benefits
  • Examples include sustainable sourcing practices or voluntary emissions reductions
• International trade negotiations and tariff policies often reflect Prisoner's Dilemma dynamics
  • Protectionism represents defection, free trade represents cooperation
  • WTO agreements as mechanisms to promote cooperative trade policies