6.2 Rice's theorem and generalizations

Rice's theorem is a fundamental result in computability theory. It states that for any non-trivial property of partial functions, the set of Turing machines computing functions with that property is undecidable. This has far-reaching implications for program analysis and verification.

The theorem proves that many questions about program behavior are undecidable, including halting, equivalence, and correctness. This limits what we can automatically determine about programs, pushing us towards approximate methods and heuristics for practical analysis.

Rice's Theorem and Its Implications

Rice's theorem and its implications

Top images from around the web for Rice's theorem and its implications

• 

  Automata theory - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS 340: Lecture 7: Turing Machines View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  computability theory - Variant of the usual proof method for undecidability of the halting ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Automata theory - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS 340: Lecture 7: Turing Machines View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Rice's theorem and its implications

• 

  Automata theory - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS 340: Lecture 7: Turing Machines View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  computability theory - Variant of the usual proof method for undecidability of the halting ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Automata theory - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  CS 340: Lecture 7: Turing Machines View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Rice's theorem asserts for any non-trivial property of partial functions, the set of Turing machines computing functions with that property is undecidable
  • A property is non-trivial if it holds for some, but not all, computable functions (totality, constancy, specific input-output behavior)
• The theorem implies no general algorithm exists to decide whether a given Turing machine computes a function with a specific non-trivial property
• Consequently, many questions about program behavior are undecidable (halting, equivalence, correctness)

Proof using halting problem reduction

• To prove Rice's theorem, reduce from the undecidable halting problem
• Assume, for contradiction, a non-trivial property $P$ exists such that the set of Turing machines computing functions with property $P$ is decidable
• Let $H$ be the set of Turing machines halting on input $w$
• Construct a computable function $f$:
  1. $f(x) = 1$ if $M_x \in H$ (Turing machine with index $x$ halts on input $w$)
  2. $f(x) = 0$ otherwise
• Show $\{x : M_x \text{ computes a function with property } P\}$ is decidable if and only if $H$ is decidable
• Since $H$ is undecidable (halting problem), the set of Turing machines computing functions with property $P$ must also be undecidable

Applications to program properties

• Rice's theorem proves the undecidability of various program properties:
  • Determining if a program always halts (termination)
  • Checking if a program computes a specific function (correctness)
  • Deciding if two programs are equivalent (compute the same function)
  • Verifying if a program satisfies a given specification (validation)
• To apply Rice's theorem, show the property is non-trivial and pertains to the partial function computed by the program

Generalizations in computability theory

Generalizations in computability theory

• Rice-Shapiro theorem extends Rice's theorem to properties of recursively enumerable sets
  • States any non-trivial property of the domain of a partial computable function is undecidable
• Generalization to other Turing-complete models of computation (lambda calculus, register machines)
  • Rice's theorem holds for any Turing-complete model
• Consequences for automated program analysis and verification:
  • Many program properties are inherently undecidable, limiting the scope of automatic analysis
  • Approximate methods and heuristics are often used to analyze programs in practice (static analysis, testing)
• Impact on the foundations of mathematics:
  • Rice's theorem is closely related to Gödel's incompleteness theorems, demonstrating limitations of formal systems
  • It highlights the existence of undecidable problems and the boundaries of computability (decision problems, Entscheidungsproblem)